19 Nov 2026 18:51:11
As it is quiet, here is a two parter.
A) borrowing from the Celtic site, which three players were more succuessful when they left. Lot's of folk who blew it, so it's a struggle.
- Saurez
- Sterling* (114)
- Keegan (personal achievements?)
Knowing that Saurez tips some.folk over the edge, here is part two.
B) What is your 11 made up of good guys that you really wanted to do well.
Mine is:
1. Ali
2. Heggem
3. Hansen
4. Sami
5. Robbo
6 Hendo
7. Kenny
8. Milli
9. Darwin
10.Houghton
11.Barnes
Liverpool Banter
Use our rumours form to send us liverpool transfer rumours.
19 Nov 2026 18:54:01
In order to view all of today's banter, you may have to visit our Liverpool banter 2 to Liverpool banter 10 pages linked at the bottom of this page.
19 Nov 2026 08:42:08
Anyone else have this bad feeling for Sunday? Our home record hasn't been great this season and United have a new manager in place right before our game with them, I'm not saying Pochettino is the answer for United but they may get the new manager bounce. I was so looking forward to Carrick still being in charge. Let hope it's just nerves.
19 Nov 2026 09:43:49
Hopefully we turn up and kick ass
Up the pool.
19 Nov 2026 09:53:29
Am actually quite nervous about Sunday. Like you said the home record isn't great and the pressure is on us. Saying that, this would be a fantastic way for Iraola to finally put his stamp on the team show what we can do. Am praying the refs don't cock it up no matter what the result!
19 Nov 2026 09:54:42
Great opportunity for Ai and the players to leave a marker in the sand and properly kick start the season with a good win at home to their biggest rivals.
No more international breaks or disruptions now so time to go full tilt at the League and CL.
19 Nov 2026 10:01:02
OP, I get where you are coming from because frankly, we have been pôor against them at Anfield since the legendary 7 nil beatdown in 22/23.
Also, we tend to play the occasion and allow all the pregame media circus nonsense to get into our heads and then, lay an egg perf.-wise.
They will be up for the game and will always find their spines whenever they play us, as that has been the norm of late.
This is why our players should take the sting out of the pregame hype, take the actual game (not the occasion) and see it as another opportunity to show our talents and for the players to perform when the lights are on, something we haven't seen this season.
So lads, go out there and show the world what you're truly made of.
Up Da Pool!
19 Nov 2026 10:03:11
Yeh I am. I can see us getting turned over. We've been average at best since Arsenal.
19 Nov 2026 10:59:29
The only reason we won't win is because we play how we normally do against United - lazily, unfocused, and not appreciating the opposition. Unless the players are fired up and aggressive from second 1, we'll be 0-0 at 67' again and not know what to do.
I expect we'll win, but we need to treat them like Man City rather than as the unserious football team they currently are.
19 Nov 2026 11:04:48
No - They need a new players bounce not a new manager one - United are bobbins.
Toxic club, toxic players, serial loser manager.
19 Nov 2026 11:31:21
Your right Crazy Horse but you can guarantee they'll come out the blocks all guns blazing & our usual start of the game lethargy will see us caught napping if we're not on it.
I can still see us getting a result out of a really tight game.
19 Nov 2026 11:32:50
I don't have a bad feeling at all, but I do think anyone expecting a walkover will be bitterly disappointed. United could be bottom of League 2 and still give us a run for our money. They finished 2 places above us last season and will be on the bounce come Sunday.
Anfield's not the fortress it once was and we're yet to hit a proper run of form, I expect a tough game, no result would surprise me.
19 Nov 2026 12:11:24
I'm nervous. As as been said, our home form's been awful. The fact they've a new coach, and they love beating us more than anyone, all adds to this being a banana skin.
19 Nov 2026 12:14:17
@BR - normally I would agree with you based on historical rivalry etc but this is the worst United team I've seen.
I'd go as far as to say they've got the worst defence in the league and are in the bottom 3 for a reason.
19 Nov 2026 12:19:02
Lowe1FC, id.
19 Nov 2026 12:22:33
Lowe1fc, if we treat them like Man City we'd get dry bummed if this season and last are anything to go by. I'd rather we treat them like Norwich City with Luis Suarez up front.
19 Nov 2026 12:29:39
Quansah won't be playing go ye so we won't have some airhead giving goals to Man U.
19 Nov 2026 12:47:55
This is where Iraola needs to and I think will earn his money. 2 1/2 weeks to review the season so far with the biggest enemy coming to Anfield.
19 Nov 2026 13:06:37
I predict VICTORY!
19 Nov 2026 13:15:55
Viktor, point made. Some other hapless performances to make me worried.
19 Nov 2026 13:51:59
What i find amazing is in 218 games between us the goal count is 294-296
We win by 2 goals to even things up on Sunday.
19 Nov 2026 14:04:45
We will win.
19 Nov 2026 14:09:14
I'm more concerned about the ref than the team.
19 Nov 2026 14:20:44
Not the dreaded dry bum!
19 Nov 2026 14:45:36
My arse goes every time we play them.
19 Nov 2026 15:15:50
It must go to the same place that my arse goes to SJ 😂. I'm really not looking forward to Sunday lad's.
19 Nov 2026 15:34:31
I'm looking forward to it. This is exactly what Iraola and the team need. Go out and prove yourselves one and all! We've a better team, manager and the Anfield crowd. It won't be a walk in the park but I do believe that it'll provide the spark required and I expect a good home win.
19 Nov 2026 15:40:58
Zed, it only sounds right when I say it.
19 Nov 2026 17:27:36
I thought you were busy ArAy so thought I would enter your proxy vote!

19 Nov 2026 07:39:01
{Ed's Note - OptimumShots has posted a new article entitled, Everton Transfer Targets Across Three Positions
18 Nov 2026 20:59:16
Too many fans write off conor Bradley and it's not concerning injuries.
The Bradley I think of is the performances against Chelsea and probably two MOTM performances against Real Madrid. Those two performances against Real Madrid He was top top class going forward and defensively.
He has struggled at times with certain set ups and yes injuries but this lad does have it in his locker to be a top top RB.
Under andoni and hopefully with better midfielders, the team will be more explosive and quicker. I expect Bradley to excel.
18 Nov 2026 21:09:59
I love him Ron, think he's going to be brilliant for us.
18 Nov 2026 21:13:44
Ron there were many games where Connor played well but those 2 seem to be the only ones that people remember.
I watched something on LFC TV the other day, I think it was all of Darwin's goals or something and I was surprised at just how many Connor was involved in.
He's a really good player and I can't wait to have him back.
As a side note JK is just preparing a response to my post saying something like 'good job it wasn't all of Darwin's offsides because you still be watching this time next week'.
18 Nov 2026 21:23:47
The first part of being a top, top player is availability. Bradley has not even come close to being available when we need him, even before this most recent injury. Honestly, as much as we all love to see a youth product making the grade, I just don't think that Bradley has that capability.
Better to prepare with someone we know will be with us for the long haul, rather than rely on a player who, game by game, you expect to get injured and miss a significant amount of time.
18 Nov 2026 21:53:31
I think he's backup material in the months coming back from injury. Araujo, despite being put in the RB position, could be Van Dijks successor as a sort of replacement in the CB leadership position. It kinda depends on what Iraola decides to do at the back. I am a big fan of Leoni but would back whatever the manager decides.
So I think we need a starting or at least a competing right back, as well as better competition on the other fullback position for Kerkez. Svennson would do well.
18 Nov 2026 22:06:57
He's had a shockingly bad career threatening injury and it's going to take a while for him to get up to speed let alone hit any sort of form.
He's a good player and if he gets a run of decent form he's a starter - I just don't think his body will hold up to being a regular starter and if we want to progress I think we might we'll need to strengthen in that position.
It's hard to say but we've been over sentimental with "potentially" good players before & one of them still takes a wage at the club but we struggle to get 15 games a season out of him.
18 Nov 2026 22:16:17
too bad we don't play real madrid every week.
18 Nov 2026 22:28:35
His absence has obviously dulled your memory regarding how 'good' a defender Bradley actually is. My opinion; Not very. Easy to remember his big cameos but easy to forget his mistakes. Reliability is key for player and club and unfortunately Bradley is unreliable both football and fitness wise. We require a new RB to take the role.
18 Nov 2026 22:45:20
So what happens if the new rb gets injured and out for months? We bought Frimpong who has been hit and miss and suffered with injuries.
{Ed666's Note - then I’m afraid you’ll have to lace up your boots mate because there’s no way I’m having ping pong play at right back!!!!
18 Nov 2026 22:46:15
Fully agree Ron, some people have very short memories, he's proven he has the ability, hopefully he can stay fit and consistent going forward.
{Ed666's Note - please elaborate on the bit where Bradley has the ability to be a starting right back for Liverpool FC.
18 Nov 2026 22:59:27
We should never have bought Frimpong and my own memory is certainly not short regarding Bradley. Neither of those are what we require for a title winning team and that's what opinions are all about. On to United and victory I say!
18 Nov 2026 23:10:33
Can't rely on an injury prone player. When's he even going to be back?
18 Nov 2026 23:21:17
Up till now he's done nothing to convince me he can become our starting RB. We need do be buying another RB, as he's as reliable as Gomez.
18 Nov 2026 23:32:10
Anyway I like Bradley. I'm not a lover of frimpong tho, used just as an example.
19 Nov 2026 01:49:15
When he absolutely bullied Vini Jr off the park for 90 minutes every one was saying what a great player he was, same in the return leg when he shut down Mbappe and assisted Macca, again against Chelsea when he scored, provided 2 assists and won man of the match, there was the 2 assists against Norwich, his performance against Fulham in the Carabao Cup semi-final. short memories indeed.
There's absolutely no doubt that he has the ability, it's whether he can stay fit and put on top performances consistently that's yet to be proven.
18 Nov 2026 23:04:00
Absence makes the heart grow fonder it seems, Ed.
{Ed666's Note - Are you flirting with me FlyPelican?? It might be working..
19 Nov 2026 05:54:25
Rio's I appear to be living rent free mate.
19 Nov 2026 06:08:08
I don't think there is anything about his skill set that is particularly 'extraordinary' but I do think he has the desire and attitude to make it as a successful and solid Premier League standard full back, and let's be honest, that alone would be a step up. All this if he comes back from this injury as he was before, which is not guaranteed.
19 Nov 2026 07:11:49
He has (had) bags and bags of potential which sometimes was in display, like when he absolutely floored Vinicius 'man and ball', so he does have that in him and it's something that gets the crowd on their feet. IMHO, he is netter going forward than he is defending - that isn't to say he can't defend - but we'll have to see how he has recovered from the injury.
The lad at least deserves a shot at the role before he starts to be written off.
19 Nov 2026 08:10:27
Let's be honest our best and most reliable RB is an on loan CB, love Bradley but we all
know deep down he'll get injured again at some point and we'll need a RB again.
19 Nov 2026 09:36:01
Ron Funk, I remember very clearly when Bradley came into the team and that kid balled out to the point of people saying Trent can go to RM if he wants because we already have his replacement.
WDW, I agree with you as well. The kid performed in the biggest stages as in, in the EFL final vs Chelsea and in both games vs RM of which, one of them was literally last season. But you know what they say, "Out of sight? Out of mind".
Bradley is recovering from a devastating injury and frankly, no one knows how he will come back from that and he will need lots of time to recover to have any chance of getting back to anywhere near the form he was in before the injuries started.
Does he deserve a shot? Yes, of course he does because I feel he has earned it.
What we need to do is support him (and you can add Eki and Leoni to this) his long road back, in the hope they can return to full fitness and performance.
19 Nov 2026 09:55:53
Years ago, our players were regularly called "deadwood". After some furor we finally got rid of that. Can we do the same with this "Ping Pong"? Make fun of the football skills as much as you want.
Criticize the football played by him as much as you want. But stop attacking the dignity of your players. It's childish. Or is YNWA gone in the wind with everything else?
19 Nov 2026 10:12:03
Bradley deserves a chance just like everyone else did after last season. Connor looked promising under Klopp and lacklustre under Slot. He is young and hopefully Iraola can help him progress.
19 Nov 2026 12:58:05
Bradley was good but not seen enough to judge whether he would be a starter.
Right now, I am not sure he will ever get back or kick in from where he was, he has missed a lot of football in these past 18 months. I wouldn't be surprised if he left the end of next year.
{Ed666's Note - 1 goal and 6 assists in 45 premiership games. Draw your own conclusions
18 Nov 2026 20:47:56
I seen Kerkez mentioned again.
A few points. For what was paid and *expected, he's been well off it. We lost a top LB in robbo and expected not the same player, but another top LB.
Last year Kerkez looked soo rash and immature almost in his decision making. He got his season to bed in even though he already was accustomed to the PL.
This season Kerkez looks a little more calm and composed. But his final ball and delivery is still terrible overall. The very odd great cross isn't good enough.
However I continue to give the lad grace is because you watch him closely, he's leaving it all on the pitch. The effort is top notch and he does get his odd reward for it.
There's something there that does remind me of a potentially very good andoni type player. Almost a klopp type player that you know could really flourish.
Times marching on now though and I do expect the club to bring in real competition for Kerkez. He has to really improve in the final third. It's a must if he's to he here for the long term.
I don't agree on eds robbo opinion. Robbo and trent both hit wayward balls. However in a game you were always getting 2 or 3 top deliveries and especially at crucial times when it mattered. That's what made them top top players.
18 Nov 2026 22:53:40
Agreed, defensively he's much improved on last year but his end product is woeful most of the time, I'd say only 1 out of 5 crosses makes it past the first man. Last year I was willing to chalk his 'headless chicken' performances down to a combination of inexperience and an overeagerness to impress.
I think there's probably still a little bit of the latter lingering on at the moment, causing him to snap at the ball, he should be capable of ironing it out.
19 Nov 2026 09:38:08
Chewy, the guy just needs to calm down and play football because he always plays like his pants are on fire and he has to take them off before the flames reach his bare arse. Sheesh!
18 Nov 2026 13:16:49
I know I'm pre-empting something based off nothing but talking heads on YouTube, but just wanted to put it out there, personally I think not signing Big Ronald permanently would be a massive take if we didn't follow it up.
Once Virgil has moved on (which could be in the summer), we're going to have a very inexperienced back line. Fantastic talent's absolutely, but we need someone who has been there and done it. Araujo has played for two super clubs, captained one, experienced the highs and lows of football and still has plenty of time left at the top. Defenders peak slightly later, usually about 30.
So I don't think we've seen the absolute best of him yet, and forgetting how brilliant his attitude and work rate is. He's a cracking player on form as well. I don't think it would just be sentimentality, it would also be a sensible
move to sign him permanently and you won't get better on the market for the price.
Hopefully it's just a case of us trying to squeeze Barca because we know they need the money. No harm in that.
18 Nov 2026 14:29:42
I'm apprehensive reading your first name especially when I omitted 'inis.' It's dreadful. Hopefully, we put them to the sword and nullify their annoying penchant for come backs in recent times. But I get your point.
18 Nov 2026 14:34:33
Even if Araujo is, for some reason, not considered by the club as a first team starter. Then, he can at least be utilised in Joe Gomez's role. He's shown a capability of covering at right back, while also being a natural centre back option. It really is a no brainer, for me.
Gomez should have gone years ago, and we almost managed to shift him when we were in talks to buy Anthony Gordon. We missed out, and have been stuck with him warming the injury table for even more years. He is unreliable and has needed to be replaced for a long time now.
Araujo seems like the perfect fit. Hopefully we don't fumble this.
18 Nov 2026 15:04:33
No brainer to get him signed up with what he's provided our club so far. Looks a future kop hero to me!
18 Nov 2026 15:33:54
Mancinis and Mango are right. From most angles that you look at it from, it can only be a plus. He offers so many things as both a starter and a backup. And once his English is up to speed, I'm sure he will provide some stability in the dressing room with all the previous experience that he has had.
18 Nov 2026 15:40:38
Would love to sign him, but unfortunately there's too many variables right now, and it's too early for a call to be made. What's going to happen with Leoni, will Virgil stay on, which potential replacements have been sounded out, does Araujo fit the profile they've been looking for as a long-term solution etc. Not to mention, what does Araujo want? In an interview not long ago he chose not to comment when asked if he wanted to stay at Liverpool, so it would seem he's keeping his options open, at the very least, he could well see this as an opportunity to show Barca what they're missing and get back in their good graces, hopefully not but who knows? The buy option is not exactly cheap and he's not on modest wages so bringing him in to play back up is likely seen as a no-go MANGO.
We should be doing everything we can to bring him in permanently asap, but I do fear the stars won't allign, keeping my fingers crossed.
18 Nov 2026 15:46:31
Yeah makes sense to me too. He is experienced can play rb and cb and has fight and spirit that this team is severely lacking.
Yes he can be rash and maybe the powers that be are concerned about his mental health long term given his past which could coming into their thinking.
I would sign up if possible.
18 Nov 2026 16:21:03
Would like to see him actually played more at centre back.
Either way it'll be a decision down to the club whether they do or don't.
18 Nov 2026 17:24:12
I think he's been absolutely fantastic. got to sign him up in my opinion.
18 Nov 2026 18:00:27
Will I be first choice fullback if we actually bring a RB in? If not would he get in ahead of JJ/VVD at CB? These are the things that have to be considered. Has done well but it's a lot of money for a 28 year old who could just be backup.
18 Nov 2026 18:26:38
VVD is past his best by a long way, want him to stay but needs phasing out.
JJ is immense, but also needs a rest.
Gomez goes at the end of the season.
Leoni is still not fully recovered and needs time.
Ndukwe looks excellent but is a baby.
We need Araujo 100%.
18 Nov 2026 20:06:05
Araujo just looks like the ideal Premier League defender. If we don't sign him another PL team definitely will. Who else do you get for 47m these days?
18 Nov 2026 20:51:37
I love Araujo to bits, he gives some much needed spine to our team, but why the rush in singing him, he's here for the season, he could have a career ending injury in march. If he keeps it up and he wants to be here, sign him up at the end of the season.
18 Nov 2026 22:18:09
I hope we sign him. we need experienced players who have natural leadership quality.
18 Nov 2026 22:30:26
He has the attitude of a captain.
19 Nov 2026 07:37:23
Virg will be phased out but will it be next season, will it be the year after? still tops metrics in the Premier League even in"decline".No one's saying Araujo's not a good player but at the moment at CB he doesn't play.
Are you paying big money for a 28 year old who could be 29/30 by the time he's a 1st 11 starter? this is on the assumption we get a starting RB in.
18 Nov 2026 13:17:58
Let's assume there isn't an agenda or conspiracy and we'll just go with sheer incompetence.
Either way, it's already - 10 matches in - had a material influence on the title race. The Forest and Palace penalties against and the penalty we didn't receive against Arsenal (we'll assume the penalty would have been scored) amount to three points lost for us, a minus three impact on goal difference and two additional points for Arsenal. Correct decisions in those three cases alone would have us on 21 points, Arsenal on 24 and us very much in pursuit of the top of the table.
More subjectively we might also argue that the red card for Gravenberch against City was unjust and that, without it, that match would have played out as a draw (so that's +1 points and +3 on current goal difference), and that Timber would have been sent off if the correct decision of penalty had been awarded for his pull back on Isak, resulting in Arsenal playing three quarters of that match with 10 men. Reasonable chance in those circumstances that we'd have gone on to win (so that would be +3 points and further improved goal difference and three less points for Arsenal).
There are no outrageous claims in any of that; it is all quite feasible and arguably how things would have played out if laws of the game had been applied correctly. We'd be level with Arsenal on 24 points at the top of the league.
18 Nov 2026 15:37:07
Even if most of us agree with you, at the end of the day and unfortunately, only which team scores the most goals in a game and has the most points at the end of the season, really count and matter. It's left for us fans to ponder over the could haves, should haves and would haves.
18 Nov 2026 16:20:31
Theres a conspiracy allright, but it's not the one you think. Sure, individual refs might be 'in the pocket' of certain clubs, but you have to remember all clubs experience shocking decisions against them at some stage. Go onto any of the cub pages in any forum, and you'll find endless cries of bias and corruption. Arsenal fans are actually the worst for it, they're completely deluded and think all the refs are out to get them.
The truth of it is the big conspiracy is simply that the ref's, pgmol, and former refs all act as a brotherhood, like corrupt cops, and instead of owning up to their errors, they gaslight the fans and try to sweep things under the rug. Of course this affects everybody, and when it happens to your team it feels like everyone's against you, but it's really just incompetency and institutional protection.
It won't be eradicated until 4 things happen: they need to make refereeing a prestigious job, it should come with a (relatively) large pay packet, and they should look to attract ex-pros. Numerous times over the years I've heard ex-pro's say they would be interested in reffing if they weren't paid a pittance. Also, the refs need to be governed by a properly independent body/panel/board (whatever) to avoid this endless gaslighting of the fans over shocking decisions, again ideally made up of well-paid, exceptionally trained experts and ex-pros. There should be no ex-refs involved at the top end, all they do is try and cover for each other. No biased refs, seems obvious but it's not being enforced, for that there needs to be far more effective qualifying, applicants' backgrounds need to be heavily scrutinised and made public for complete transparency. And of course the consistency on rules and the training of them. Far too often we see 2 comparable incidents treated totally differently, or vice versa.
Unfortunately I don't see any of this ever happening.
18 Nov 2026 17:04:43
Shay boils my p*ss, is when come and say that they admit to the mistakes! Like that helps the clubs who it goes against, its points that make a difference
It's like bullseye " see how many points you could have had ".
18 Nov 2026 20:27:14
Pretty sure that is the USA model of dumbassery.
18 Nov 2026 22:34:01
Ifs and buts. Aunties and balls. Move on and see where we end up in May.
18 Nov 2026 10:58:00
Even more egregious than the panel's ruling of the Isak shirt pull incident vs Arsenal.
The panel's comments regards Kerkez penalty incident vs Palace:
"After reviewing the latest round of Premier League games, the panel "unanimously" agreed that Harrington's penalty decision was "incorrect, " as contact was "inevitable."
They, however, also unanimously agreed on the non-intervention of VAR from Michael Salisbury, "on the basis that it was not a clear and obvious error."
FFS the refs decisions was deemed to be a clear error but not clear and obvious enough for VAR to get involved.
What are we doing here.
18 Nov 2026 11:08:52
Same thing they've been doing for years mate. Manipulating the results with Bias decisions for financial gain.
18 Nov 2026 12:29:29
No idea how they come to these conclusions, seems like it's just another opportunity for them to try and gaslight the fans, manipulate opinions and attempt to sweep these mistakes under the rug.
18 Nov 2026 12:52:11
They unanimously agreed that it was an non clear and obvious but definite error.
18 Nov 2026 13:33:11
Let's be honest, VAR is used for no other reason than try and provide justification for the referee's decision, rather than actually get to the correct decision. If they actually scrap the 'clear and obvious' narrative and actually state it will be utilised to get the right decision, it may be half useful.
Cheers.
18 Nov 2026 14:23:45
Faithworks and Chewy, that is the exact same thing they did with the Forest pen that wasn't.
They said the pen should not have been given as the incident wasn't worthy of one.
Then with the other side of their mouth, they said that VAR not intervening to ask the ref to check the monitor (which would have avoided all of this, btw) was the right decision.
Oh and who was VAR that day? The Notorious BIG a. k. a The Notorious Michael Oliver.
I mean like I've been saying, these guys are just playing in our faces and they can because they know nothing will happen.
18 Nov 2026 16:13:05
This is the absolute problem with VAR, the term clear and obvious is a catch all ambiguous statement used to absolve refs of incorrect decisions.
There is no logical reason how a panel can adjudge that the kerkez penalty was a unanimous incorrect call however it didn't meet the threshold for clear and obvious error'. The two statements can't co exist in a logical world unless you want to create confusion intentionally. The PGMOL and Premier League are massive industries and professions so I can't be persuaded that someone in a high position hasn't accepted that this clear and obvious rule is problematic and therefore it is there by intention.
18 Nov 2026 17:39:27
Anybody reckon in years to come,there'll be repercussions in the shape of a betting scandal involving senior officials and leading referees,it stinks that bad at the minute of somebody benefiting from some absolute s****house decisions.
18 Nov 2026 16:21:19
I think (if this is still how VAR works) the problem is that VAR won't intervene if what the ref says to them as the game is happening is what happens, even if he makes the wrong interpretation. Maybe the Ed's know if that's right, I'm sure that's how it was originally operating anyway. So, let's say the ref says there's a clash of heads and gives a pen- whether that interpretation is total bollocks or not, if there has been a clash of heads he doesn't get sent to the monitor.
If that's still how it works it's clearly a big problem, but I think that is the premise of the clear and obvious error- if what the ref says he saw actually happened then they don't get involved.
18 Nov 2026 19:22:20
LFCchopeful, that is pretty much the issue with the rule, if the ref says he saw something even if he interpreted it incorrectly that clear and obvious rule means that VAR can't intervene unless the ref was clearly wrong I. e awards a penalty because the defender fails to play the ball in a tackle, VAR can't intervene unless they show the ball being played.
The rule is fundamentally flawed and only serves to cause confusion, I would either scrap VAR for all subjective calls in its entirety or remove the clear and direct obvious rule and simply focus on what is the correct decision. It's ludicrous that VAR adjudge that a penalty is the correct decision in a game but also refuse to intervene because the error is not big enough or clear enough from the ref.
18 Nov 2026 22:26:07
It's one thing when a panel later decide the referee has made an incorrect decision. Its another when the panel rule that VAR got the decision wrong too.
I mean, that is part of the reason to have video assistance. They slow the footage down and view it from all angles and supposedly spot things the referee missed.
How embarrassing to be a qualified referee and still get crucial decisions wrong after watching the slo-mo. Bunch of incompetant clowns the lot of them.
18 Nov 2026 10:11:06
So it seems the Kerkez "foul" was agreed to be the wrong decision but not clear and obvious enough to over turn VAR. KMI panel therefore think on field decisions were correct.
This allows the PGMOL to have this count as VAR being applied correctly.
Bunch of hogwash.
18 Nov 2026 11:05:21
You can guarantee VAR and the ref will find a way of awarding Man United a penalty on sun.
18 Nov 2026 12:51:57
It'll probably either be a Manc ref or incompetent one or both
Up the pool.
18 Nov 2026 13:20:13
Same ref as Forest and Brighton. Thought he made a lot of dodgy calls against us in both games.
18 Nov 2026 14:24:20
They're playing in our faces, guys. It's not complicated.