Liverpool Rumours Member Posts


Use our rumours form to send us liverpool transfer rumours.

Single or recurring donation
(single word yields best result)
If you have a question for Ed1, press the big button.

Har_red92's Profile

Current Avatar:
Har_red92's Avatar

Current Profile Picture:
Click to view larger image
Har_red92's Profile Picture

Team: Liverpool

Where from: Ireland

Favourite player: Jamie carragher

Best team moment: Istanbul, hands down

Interests: Football football football

Timezone: (GMT) London

Har_red92's Posts and Other Poster's Replies To Har_red92's Posts



To Har_red92's last 5 rumours posts


To Har_red92's last 5 banter posts


To Har_red92's last 5 rumour replies


To Har_red92's last 5 banter replies


Har_red92's rumours posts with other poster's replies to Har_red92's rumours posts


03 Aug 2019 05:56:48
Any news on where Kent is most likely to move? Any advanced talks taking place?

1.) 03 Aug 2019 18:22:30

2.) 03 Aug 2019 20:03:27
Would be a good signing for them.

3.) 04 Aug 2019 11:56:30
I can’t see a move to be honest Har. From what I can tell it’s fairly stuck where it is. If there was a move away that would leave London and Surrey with a coastline which would be fun but I think East Sussex would be a bit exposed so it’s a non starter. There could be a loan to France but it take a while to get there.

4.) 03 Aug 2019 14:16:42
Last i heard was no club could afford him (they don't think he is worth it) and only want loan deals. Klopp Said no loans but when no bids come in we'll let him go on loan with an option/ obligation to buy or something.

5.) 04 Aug 2019 20:37:18
Not even close to an accurate prediction. In your defence Lerchy that’s how the vast majority of confident calls go on this site.

6.) 04 Aug 2019 22:41:05
The PFA Scotland Young Player of the Year? No interest!? Shockin.
He'll prob be sold for 6mil on Wednesday, no biggy. I'm actually way more curious to see if there'll be any late surprise incomings. I expect nothing, but they've surprised us before.



04 Jul 2019 11:17:19
Ed a quick question if you have any info.

I remember laxalt being linked in the past but I'm sure you mentioned us giving up on any interest. With Milan now poised to sign Theo Hernandez would they possibly look to offer laxalt around at a decent price? Would it be a possibility we may look again at him if readily available or is it non runner?

{Ed002's Note - It is a good question. Laxalt would be happy to stay at Milan and it is Ricardo Rodriguez who was blocking his place in the first team for much of last season who is being offered around. However, with Marco Giampaolo as the new coach and Theo Hernandez joining it will still limit opportunities - although with serious financial issues they will be thinking about keeping him to cover the LB, LM and LW positions - which he is capable of doing. Interest remains from Atalanta and Newcastle enquired - seeing him as a left sided option to Kenedy. For me he would be ideal cover for LB, LM and LW at Liverpool but there has seemingly been no recent interest from the club although he is one of those players - like Valentino Lazaroon the right, who is comfortable in several positions.}

1.) 04 Jul 2019 12:16:41
Thanks for that answer, very insightful overview in fairness. It's his versatility indeed is what would have made him a sensible option too I think. Cheers.

{Ed002's Note - You are welcome.}




Har_red92's banter posts with other poster's replies to Har_red92's banter posts


It's impossible to compare different Football Eras

21 Jan 2020 16:36:13
{Ed's Note - Har_red92 has posted a new article entitled, It's impossible to compare different Football Eras



21 Jan 2020 01:34:43
I remember posting back when we were heading into winter with a 7 or 8 point lead and we were all rightly nervous and cautious but I was predicting that I thought we might double that lead by Xmas as it was at a time where city faced 6 fixtures mostly against bigger sides while our 6 fixtures were favourable. It turned out accurate and I'm now feeling similar thoughts. City next 6 games they have 4 away, they play spurs Leicester arsenal and United along with sheff Utd away and even Chelsea before they play us.

In that period we play west ham twice, wolves, Bournemouth, Watford, Southampton, Norwich and I think palace. I could see it very possible that we pull so far ahead that the league may be won before March is out, . Of course city can win every game but I can honestly see them dropping more points than we will over next 6 or 7 games. Cities easiest run of fixtures is their last 6 which are all against the weakest teams while we are just now facing into our best run of opponents while city face their toughest run. This could genuinely be over by the 30 game mark and I'm saying this with realism and not just arrogance. Pep will at some point look to move all his importance to the champions league as he knows it's too large a task to catch us, . If we take 6 points over the next week we'll be sitting on 70 points with 14 games left, city can only get to 93points with 100% record from 15 games, I can only see them reaching 80-85 points so we could realistically pass that mark with 7 or 8 games to spare considering the level of opponents we face compared to city over next 7 or 8 gameweeks.

I'm going to predict that we seal the title in the Merseyside derby.

1.) 21 Jan 2020 04:54:18
Not sure why this is even debatable any more. I lived through the hay days of the 70's and 80's so have been overly cautious predicting a title. But, in the current climate you'd be mad not to be at least 90% confident of winning the league this year. We're not steam rolling teams, but getting the job done and those beneath us are dropping points with regularity.
It wouldn't overly bother me if we didn't go deep in the champions league but set some severe records in the league this season. Let's be honest, if at the start of the season anyone predicted we could win the league with half a dozen games left to play and have a shot at beating City's 100 pt total and potentially matching Arsenal's invincibles, you'd have laughed.

2.) 21 Jan 2020 07:21:30
I just want the league, nothing else matters. If we have games to spare, I’d love to see some younger lads get more mins in. Set us up better for next season.

3.) 21 Jan 2020 08:39:03
I’m agreeing with Burkey on this. We are in a position that no top flight team has ever been in or could ever be again. Let’s make the most of it and smash all records. People still revere Arsenal’s invincibles and rightly so. If we could do that with 112pts we’d be talked about and revered for generations to come.

4.) 21 Jan 2020 08:57:48
I’m not disagreeing with Har but in the matches we have in that period we are playing 3 teams (Wolves, Norwich and Palace) who took points off City. No “easy” games but of course there are “easier” games you are expected to have more chance to win.

5.) 21 Jan 2020 12:45:07
If the records come then that is a bonus, but never ever EVER should achieving records to make Arsenal and United fans jealous come before winning the Champions League. That’s what we’re famous for, it’s the pinnacle of the sport (maybe even the pinnacle of sport as a whole), the top level of competition, the ultimate sign of glory and prestige. We have a very good chance to win both trophies this year, we’re by far the best team in the world right now, you’d have to be bonkers to accept anything other than at least making it to the semi finals even if that means we throw away the unbeaten league record.



18 Dec 2019 15:01:31

regarding the point that we are buying the title and this will hamper youngsters coming through. We didn't sign any senior players last summer and the path got easier for young lads to get a chance. Brewster is being backed to prove himself and has yet to show he deserves to be trusted yet, minamino is a 7 million player who doesn't even play in Brewsters role so hardly just splashing out on his replacement.

You say Trent was the last to get his chance and only kept his spot because he played magnificent! . That's this whole point, Trent played well every time we needed him so deserved to play, Brewster has been given chances but yet to deserve to play ahead of others, solanke was given chances but didn't deserve to play anymore.

Hoever, Jones, Elliot are all being given their chance but are yet to prove they are better than other options. It's up to the players to prove their quality to deserve the right to play more regularly. Klopp has given plenty of kids the chance since Trent but none have been as good as him which has you thinking for some reason that Trent was the only guy given time. Woodburn, ojo, ibe, ejaria, solanke, chirivella, Stewart all played in as many games as it took for Trent and Gomez to show their quality was good enough. No one has the automatic right to be given minutes if not performing in training or on the field.

How can you say Duncan made the right move when he has yet to make any progress since leaving? He's having less joy in youth level than he had with us and yet to given any first team action for a team much weaker than us. This season he would realistically have already played 3 or 4 games for our first team against the likes of arsenal, games at a packed Anfield, games live on sky sports, chance to travel to compete in CWC and it would have been up to him to take his chance that he would have been given if he's actually even deserving of it.

We give the kids a chance and it's up to them to take it, not to klopp. If Brewster doesn't succeed at Liverpool no one can say he never got the chance, he's played poor in each of his performances so far so will have to be patient to earn klopp's trust and origi has deserved to take his potential playing time. Neco Williams has great debut and rewarded with chances to play backup RB in first team match squad.

We're not stopping these youngsters from any future. If they're good enough to play for LFC and can prove it then they will make it, if they're not then why would we play them and weaken our team.

I can't think of any young players really who never got given a sniff under klopps 4 years in charge and has since proven that he was ever good enough to play more minutes for this team? I can't think of one player who's progress the club has blocked without that player actually himself being responsible for his own success or failings. Grujic and Wilson are both currently still being given time and potential to make it at a high level but we've not let any youngsters leave under klopp who've proved him or the club wrong.

If youngsters want to leave for more chances then fair dues to them but it's nonesense that they or others can then say that we didn't give them a chance or that we simply buy our way to success when it's very far from true. Jordan ibe got the same chance that sterling got. 1 took it, one didn't. Andre wisdom got the last same chance that Trent got, 1 took it, one didn't. Martin Kelly got the same chance that Joe Gomez got, 1 took it, 1 didn't. Solanke was given the same chance as Origi was given a few years back.

At United rashford was given the same opportunity as all their other young forwards who have yet to make it at a high level. Harry Kane took his chance at spurs. Abraham and mount now taking theirs at Chelsea. If you want to make it at a top club you need to perform and take your chance. You can't blame the club or their ambition as a reason for not making it.

If you're good enough you'll make it, if not the club will look elsewhere or else inevitably start getting weaker like arsenal who've wasted far too much time on youngsters who weren't performing.

We're not a club buying our way to the top and that's so obvious to clearly see.

1.) 18 Dec 2019 15:17:08
When you say “you” who are you taking about. ?

2.) 18 Dec 2019 15:28:09
Spent about 40p last summer. Still top.

3.) 18 Dec 2019 21:47:58

Mate I agree with your post that our club and Klopp do not impede youngsters to harm their careers. My post simply meant that for a young player to succeed at Liverpool they will have to be truly exceptional and lucky. Even a player of Brewster's caliber is finding it difficult to find a space in the match day squad on a regular basis. So for a player like Duncan who did not fancy a scrap to break through into an elite side, it was better for him to move on (to a challenge that meets his lower ambitions) .

My post did not mean any less or any more than that. I agree with what you have said in your post about the club being fair. I do not condone young players leaving Liverpool. In fact I love to see them have the belief in themselves to take up the challenge. I'm however realistic about the need to balance the championship winning streak with giving youth a chance so I firmly believe that we will keep buying excellent prospects (like Mane and Salah etc) in future rather than having a team full of academy products just because the pressures of the game do not allow a lot of experimentation (besides in the League Cup) .

With regards to the taunt of "buying the league", I don't want to get into it because I don't know if there is an objective definition of buying the league (in terms of money spent) . We have spent a lot of money in the recent years. And yes our net spent is much lower than City. But Leicester spent much less than us to win the league. So there is no objective definition to buying the league. I just think that our owners will do whatever is necessary to win the trophies (e. g. buying Van Dijk and Alisson) so I'm not interested in the labels and I am enthralled by our team, our owners and our manager/ staff.

4.) 19 Dec 2019 11:14:28
Both make valid points, the question is then how many young players realistically stand a chance to play with Virgil or Allison in the team? As an academy player looking at our 1st there aren't as many opportunities up for grabs. I read somewhere that Brew isn't good enough, is he not good enough as compared to our 40mil plus signing or he just not good enough? I am only asking to get a clear view of the bases of your conclusion and not opposing it.
Kids (in fact athlete in general) need more than the occasional appearance to show their worth and frankly we just not giving our kids that. You rate Harvey as not good enough, we talking about a 16 year old who will most likely play the day a Mo or Sadio need a break.

How many team's would really have had the stomach to agree the range of fees we have had recently and still not see it fit to accept the tag "buying success", You don't smash the record twice for no reason.

Yes we in a much better position thanks to money spent but reality is that majority of our young guns will probably never get to shoot for Liverpool FC.



15 Dec 2019 06:43:15
I must say what a fantastic 2 years weeks for us. We've continued to win every league game, Bournemouth, Everton, Watford. City dropped points to Newcastle and United, Leicester dropped points to Norwich.

We topped our group in CL, salah back in the goals, mane still on fire. Shaqiri, Keita, origi this season rarely used have been incorporated and scored 5 goals between them in 10 days. Henderson and Gomez improving their early season shaky form, 3 consecutive clean sheets. Lovren looking confident, allison back and strong. Oxlade Chamberlain being crucial when needed Salah, mane, Trent, robertson, gini, Henderson all afforded a matchday rest from starting 11. Crucial early season performers like fabinho and matip getting injured not disrupting us. Klopp and Milner signing new contracts, minimoto signing looking likely at bargain price, 4 of our players making top 7 in ballon d'or with only trio of Messi, Ronaldo and mbappe alongside that top 7.

10 points clear of 2nd place Leicester, 17 points clear of city who's game in hand away to arsenal. City vs Leicester next week means 1 if not both drop more points. Then we face Leicester with chance to wipe them out of competition before new year.

17 played, 49 from possible 51 points, unbeaten, 100% anfield record. League cup quarter final, club world cup, fa cup, champions league knockout stages all still to be competed. No players publicly showing unhappiness or desire to leave.

Must surely be considered the strongest setup that liverpool fc have sat in for decades and very realistic to predict that this strenght can be sustained for upcoming years. Young squad, players with great mentality, a manager made for the club, backroom staff and owners all working together and hugely productive. Now capable of attracting the elite talent and ability of spending big amounts if needed. Teenagers like Curtis Jones, Hoever, VDB, Williams, Elliot, Brewster getting first team starts in cup and earning klopps praise. Players like Harry Wilson, grujic, ejaria doing well on loan and gaining value either for future use or sell on profits.

What a time for us fans to saviour with joy and pride after 30 or so years with little consistency and very brief spells of excitement . Couldn't be happier 😊.

{Ed047's Note - Har you’ve been fantastic mate, it’s been a pleasure to watch you guys play.

1.) 15 Dec 2019 09:04:05
Har enough of the doom and gloom mate let’s hear some positives 😉.

2.) 15 Dec 2019 09:07:59
Very good post Har. You are precise on all points. We are looking in good shape. Hopefully the success on the pitch can translate continued financial improvements off the pitch as well but this is the most solid team and squad I have seen since the 80's / 90's. Klopp signing his extension really is out of this world news. Based on what he has do e to tur the club around in his tenure I would argue he is the best in the world at this time (my biased view of course and many may disagree if they felt otherwise) ;-)

3.) 15 Dec 2019 17:24:55
I know it's not a major trophy but we also have the super cup in the bag.



20 Nov 2019 01:55:26
Just for a bit of fun.

From squad number 1-20 the Liverpool players have worn in the PL era try to pick the best player for each number while considering that some players wore more than 1 number and try to work out fitting in the 20 best players possible. Here's mine.

1. Allison
2. Arbeloa
3. Fabinho
4. VVD
5. Gini.
6. Aurelio
7. Suarez
9. Torres
10. Owen
11. Fowler
12. Hyypia
13. Murphy
14. Alonso
15. Berger
16. Hamann
17. Macmanaman
18. Kuyt
19. Mane
20. Mascherano.

I'd expect many variations in other fans favourite picks for a few numbers.

1.) 20 Nov 2019 09:16:07
1. Karius
2. Kromkamp
3. Koncheskey
4. Aquilani
5. Baros
6. Hutchinson
7. Keane
8. Leonardson
9. El hadj Diouf
10. Voronin
11. Pongolle
12. Pellegrini
13. David James
14. Jovanovic
15. Salic Diao
16. Dundee
17. Guthrie
18. Moreno
19. Caulker
20. Le Tallec.

2.) 20 Nov 2019 10:21:25
Good pick Ibiza Red . very good memory some of these players done nothing to be remembered .

3.) 20 Nov 2019 13:35:05
How do you find out old squad numbers? I refuse to believe Ibiza Red remembered all of those squad numbers, unless he's Dustin Hoffman.

4.) 20 Nov 2019 16:27:19
Bit Harsh on Baros i think.

5.) 20 Nov 2019 17:45:48
Some crackers there Ibiza Red.

6.) 20 Nov 2019 17:55:40
Pongolle appearing at no. 11 reminds me: Are we going to have to number the players we take to the CWC 1-23 again, or do they not bother anymore?


1. Alisson
2. Jones
3. Fabinho
4. van Dijk
5. Agger
6. Aurelio
7. Suarez
8. Gerrard
9. Fowler
10. Barnes
11. Salah
12. Hyypia
13. Alisson (you didn't tell me I can't have him twice. Two Alissons is better than one)
14. Alonso
15. Berger
16. Hamann
17. McManaman
18. Kuyt
19. Mane
20. Mascherano

Only being able to pick two out of Bobby, Salah and Fowler is a PITA.

7.) 20 Nov 2019 18:35:12
Rugby Parker - google. Remember all the players but not the numbers. A few may have been harsh. But there wasn’t too many poor players in the number 5 shirt. 7 Keane was a good player but such a let down at anfield and most the others speak for themselves.

8.) 20 Nov 2019 19:06:53
Nice alternate list Ibiza haha. I'd have assaidi or mark Gonzalez as worse 11s than pongolle though.

9.) 20 Nov 2019 19:10:06
1. Carragher
2. Carragher
3. Carragher
4. Carragher
5. Carragher
6. Carragher
7. Carragher
8. Carragher
9. Carragher
10. Carragher
11. Carragher
Etc etc.

10.) 20 Nov 2019 19:43:36
Haha love it g1dgo!

11.) 21 Nov 2019 08:41:51
Pongolle doesn’t deserve to be on that list, neither does Baros, although he could trap a ball further than most people could kick it. Westerveld at 1 for me.

12.) 21 Nov 2019 14:36:51
What about Nunez?




Har_red92's rumour replies


Click To View This Thread

21 Jan 2020 04:58:12
I don't know about the loner issue but allison and firmino also aren't speaking English so as much as it is frustrating I'm not going to use that as a reason to write him off. Tevez spent years not speaking English, took aguero ages too but if he can do his talking on the field we won't care, . I just want to see him have a spell where he's fit and playing regularly before I give up on him because i know there's a great midfielder in there. I'm hoping it can fall into place for him, remember OX spent 5 years like this at arsenal before finding his spark. Klopp will I'm sure know exactly what direction keitas career is heading and I guess in the summer we might find out if we have belief or not in him to succeed.



Click To View This Thread

20 Jan 2020 23:55:34
I'm still optimistic with keita, I'd feel different if he's been playing poor for last 18 months but it's just constant injury setbacks is hurting him and his form has been impressive when you consider he's always been playing without any rhythm as yet. His previous injury history was never an issue so I think it's still likely he can overcome and play consistently. Henderson was suffering like keita with niggles for about 2 years at similar age and OX too. The talent is there and he's shown he has it. Last summer his country ruined his rehab and he never got the chance to recover and get up to speed in pre season. He deserves more time as he's still young and only injury has stopped him flourishing.

{Ed025's Note - its not only the injuries though is it har?, not learned the language and a bit of a loner as well...does he really deserve more time?..



Click To View This Thread

20 Jan 2020 23:41:26
I don't think there's any reason we'd buy big this window when we are cruising showing no weak areas. Minamino was exactly what we desired and I'm sure any potential transfer talk we debate is more in view of summer moves. I'd love Werner to add more real quality in attack, possibly a lovren replacement and a left sided player capable of covering robbo while a bonus being a versatile type who could also operate at left CB or one that can play higher up in midfield like Milner has. We don't need more than 3 or 4 squad additions unless we lose big players. Lovren, Shaqiri, lallana realistic squad departures, minamino already added is great business.



Click To View This Thread

20 Jan 2020 23:30:12
He's got 25 goals already this season and has always been prolific, hard working and has that direct pace that suits our frontline, if he is possible to sign for the fee being mentioned he represents great potential, he's still young and fits the klopp mould of transfer. With AFCON next season and the expectation to compete for every honour he would be great strengthening of our attack. Salah, mane and bobby will be hitting 30 within next 2 seasons so why not challenge Werner to come in and earn his spot.



Click To View This Thread

17 Jan 2020 10:06:01
Haha very true.




Har_red92's banter replies


Click To View This Thread

21 Jan 2020 00:58:02
If we take care of Shrewsbury and get another nice draw then suddenly we're in the latter rounds of the cup, by which time I expect us to be closing in on the league. Fa cup is weekend matches not an extra midweek fixture distraction, we can play stronger teams in this situation if we have a healthy squad.

Regarding champions league I see us as the favourites and much stronger than our previous 2 campaigns because right now the big teams like Barca, Madrid, Bayern, juve or city are all showing vulnerability this season and we are the only top team currently at peak of our powers and especially strong over 2 legs. Even the next tier of quality with likes of spurs, Chelsea, Atletico Madrid, Dortmund etc aren't enjoying consistency or form. I think we couldn't have a better chance to assert our dominance and create history if we just continue to stay as focused as we've been to date.
Remember last season we fought a title battle to the death while going for Europe too. Hopefully league comfort may let us have the chance to shift focus to cup plans in coming months.



Click To View This Thread

21 Jan 2020 00:35:55
OP I completely agree, we've always been on fire during December and Xmas busy periods and we've often struggled following training camps or with a week or 2 break. The 3 week break before CL final I felt led to the rusty performance.



Click To View This Thread

21 Jan 2020 00:32:19
Ox did play very well in his role but I do think Trent isn't able to influence as good when OX is on that side, I still prefer hendo operating and protecting Trent when fabinho is available to play in DM.



Click To View This Thread

21 Jan 2020 00:27:40
I was shocked to see that United 99 side only had 41 points after 22 games, in context that would have them 4th currently fighting for a champions league spot. They won an amazing treble but stole the champions league win also with 2 goals in 90th minute. Overall I see us currently as a team much more dominant in terms of winning relentlessly. They had 23 points less than us at this stage, that is a lot of dropped points for a team to be considered the best.



Click To View This Thread

15 Jan 2020 05:20:30
There were actually quiet a lot of games this season where a nervy scoreline made many forget about the overall performance. Sheff Utd away we should have easily been 3 or 4 up by HT. Spurs at home we hammered their goal only for gazzaniga was on fire, Chelsea Stamford bridge we dominated them all over first 70 mins. Newcastle and Burnley we cruised at ease. Arsenal we played off the park while and Leicester with last minute Milner penalty we should have finished them before HT and dominated. Our problem was a nervy defence for a while but nearly every game we have controlled and created enough chances to score more. Our lack of clean sheets was giving off an unfair vibe towards our performance levels I feel.

I can think of 2 games where we were poor, United 1-1 and villa away we were dreadful . First 45 mins vs Southampton we were 2nd best but should have scored 3 or 4 goals 2nd half.