Current Avatar:
No Avatar image uploaded
No Avatar image uploaded
Liverpool Rumours Member Posts
Viren1900's Profile
Viren1900's Posts and Other Poster's Replies To Viren1900's Posts
To Viren1900's last 5 rumours posts
To Viren1900's last 5 banter posts
To Viren1900's last 5 rumour replies
To Viren1900's last 5 banter replies
Viren1900's rumours posts with other poster's replies to Viren1900's rumours posts
04 Jul 2017 18:36:41
Ed01 as u also believe robertson will sign now do u believe we will sign another full back and what others player will come i don't now but except whoever comes in do u believe this season we will challenge for title now
Thanks for your great work.
{Ed001's Note - I never said I believed he would sign, just that he is the most likely right now. There are a number of other clubs interested in him who might jump in and get him.}
1.) 05 Jul 2017 06:04:30
With Robertson is LFC upgrading defence or downgrading its defence?
He is not going to improve.
2.) 05 Jul 2017 10:27:49
Hope some other Club signs him. He is a downgrade on Moreno.
{Ed025's Note - is there such a thing as a downgrade on moreno?..
3.) 05 Jul 2017 10:40:12
Just having a natural LB in place will be an upgrade on Milner, I'm not slagging Milner off, he's done an amicable job, but not being left footed has hindered us in terms of playing out from the back and in slowing down or killing our attacks due to having to cut back onto his right foot.
He was targeted by the opposition as a weak link in our defence so that should scream out that we need someone better.
Robertson is an ok defender, definitely better than Milner, and is a good attacking threat, definitely better than Milner (in the LB position) .
Are there better players than Robertson out there, yes probably, who they are and if they are available are two different subjects.
Just remember two years ago most were saying they wanted Moreno over Bertrand, now I think it's safe to say we would all take Bertrand now in a heartbeat!
Not all signings need to be £30-40m, Robertson could step up big-style and prove to be a cracking LB for us, or he could prove to be a disaster, who knows how it will go, but one thing I can guarantee you though is he will not reach the former without your support! So stop bitching and moaning and support the managers decisions and stop writing off players before they've even signed for us let alone kicked a ball for us!
{Ed025's Note - good post that scarface..
4.) 05 Jul 2017 11:04:57
Not being funny boys but take a look at JK's history with signing players Aubemeyang Lweendowski Hummel Subotic, Reus, And these are just a few to say the least and it is worth pointing out that Auba And lewendowski were not his first choice at the time but when he compiles a list of possible players he clearly thinks it out and if he thinks Robertson has something so let's just pile out trust in a man that let's be honest has a proven track record of signing players people were not sure on and making them world beaters if we sign Robertson then I'm sure he will be good enough to pull on a Liverpool shirt and help us win the league.
5.) 05 Jul 2017 11:31:43
Personally I think Robertson could be konchesky with hair.
6.) 05 Jul 2017 12:40:24
Robertson seems the type who will fight and will learn, most footballers who are bombed out from Celtic at a young age don't make it to the premier league do they? So he must have done something right.
7.) 05 Jul 2017 13:23:20
Bigsqueeze did you ever see konchesky play no one can be as bad as him.
8.) 05 Jul 2017 14:23:22
Reusch, unfortunately I did see him play in a Liverpool shirt and he was shocking. im sorry but we should be aiming much higher calibre players then Robertson. i would love pereira he is quality and can play both flanks but there are many left backs better than Robertson. surely Tymon from the same club would even be a better option although he is close to joining stoke. would love tierny (bad spelling possibly) but heard he doesn't want to leave, Mendy who apparently needs to lower wage demands, but at the moment regarding availability and price why not Bertrand. surely would cost £20 mill or below an proven premier quality and can defend and attack.
9.) 05 Jul 2017 19:13:31
Of course he will improve. He's coming from a fairly small club who punch above their weight. At melwood with klopp and the guys and our pure class set up. He is young and will be playing for a champions league team. Reckon he is worried we will sign another left back as well as Robertson and he could end up playing second fiddle. Important time in his career. But do the lean already!
10.) 06 Jul 2017 14:00:19
Just look at the number of completed crosses on target last season from the wings and it tells the whole story, doesn't it? THe model Klopp implements demands more service from those areas. We have the right players up front but they don't get enough accurate crosses.
I miss Gerrard, Alonso, Riise, Bjornebye and even Finnan!
03 Jul 2017 17:01:08
Ed01 I am hearing a lot of Naby kieta here as well as in news i wanna hear your views do u believe as it is looking like we will sign kieta and pay such a huge money to bring him this season
Wanna hear from your sourcesand urside
Thanks and appreciate your hardwork.
{Ed001's Note - I really have no idea whether or not we will pay enough to get the move done. There is certainly the desire to make a deal from the club, but I have no idea whether there is the potential funding available to make a deal happen.}
1.) 03 Jul 2017 17:31:44
Personally, I think our weakest player last season was Origi followed by Clyne.
Our midfield was decent and we have a lot of good players there.
Though Kieta would be a great signing but CM is not a pressing need.
2.) 03 Jul 2017 17:33:15
I agree with ed. If we can get the price closer to 50M mark then there is a chance but I can't see us and wouldn't want to us to pay over the odds for a player. I know it is crazy market but we need to work harder, and better to compete.
3.) 03 Jul 2017 18:00:04
The funding is there no question. Its whethr the club want to put a huge portion of hat budget on one player. My opinion is to go for it. I would be happy with Keita and a left back now and wait until January and see where we are.
4.) 03 Jul 2017 18:06:18
Ed001, do you feel that any Keita deal mesns the Ox is not happening, or not related?
{Ed001's Note - unrelated, Ox depends on whether he decides to stay with Arsenal or not. Which does seem unlikely with his agent. He will only look at $$ signs, rather than what is best for the player's career, so I doubt he will stay put unless Arsenal offer a massively increased contract.}
5.) 03 Jul 2017 18:32:57
Ok mate cheers.
6.) 03 Jul 2017 18:21:07
Ed, do you have an opinion on whether he's worth the investment?
{Ed001's Note - Keita? No idea. I very much doubt anyone is worth the money being asked when we need fullbacks as a priority. If central midfield was the priority, then maybe, but it's not.}
7.) 03 Jul 2017 18:59:45
There is my issue, Ed. We don't have issues at CM hence, Keita is a more than a luxurious signing as none of our current mids will be leaving at least that we know of and we have issues elsewhere in the team that need addressing ASAP. I know many will use the "we need depth" argument and I hear that BUT at 70m? For just one player who is like it or not, unproven in Europe? Sorry, that is just some fairy dust.
I too, don't see where a deal can be done esp. for 70m as that is just madness esp. cos RBL don't want to sell and them putting 70m on NK was to kill any interest from other clubs, not cos they think he's worth it (no palayer is as you are worth what someone will pay for your services) .
8.) 03 Jul 2017 19:35:10
I've just feel that if we are pushing for Keita then maybe Hendersons injury is a lot worse than we are being told.
9.) 03 Jul 2017 20:50:30
Henderson's injury, can contract, Milners age. attempting to sign this lad is a no brainer in my opinion.
Something is brewing, and it isn't necessarily associated with this potential signing.
10.) 03 Jul 2017 20:58:02
Eds r we in the market for any strikers? as this page at the moment is all about VVD, Keita and the Ox. Just feel we can't rely on what we have at the moment.
{Ed002's Note - Added one already and one has returned from injury. There are now plenty indeed.}
11.) 03 Jul 2017 21:19:21
We have about five strikers already.
I just wish we could move for Aubameyang . We would have an explosive attack. Probably second to only Barcelona.
And mayb we should allow Sturidge and Origi leave. #fantasy.
{Ed025's Note - if you got aubameyang tegar...who would be the other 2 who could elevate your attack to that of barcelona??..
12.) 03 Jul 2017 21:10:43
Injury prone sturridge and unproven solanke great. Cheers for the reply.
{Ed002's Note - Plus Ings, Origi and Firmino, and Mane and Salah can play there. Overloaded.}
13.) 03 Jul 2017 22:04:24
Anyone else think we have missed out massively in not going for lacazette?
I rate him better than origi and ings and would play more than sturridge and possibly score more than firmino, would of prefered to go after him than another cm tbh.
14.) 03 Jul 2017 22:28:48
Do clubs, and in particular LFC, take the profile of the agent in consideration when deciding on whether to sign the players? We have had an unpleasant experience, to put it mildly, with Ox's agent on Sterling and Sinclair. Will that have a bearing?
If an agent is so instrumental in unsettling the player as we believe this guy is, then if Ox gets chances and does well he will want more money or move on, and if he does badly and is sidelined he will moan and cause unrest.
15.) 04 Jul 2017 08:08:26
Wisdom sold there for 4.5mill so that's a start towards the huge fee! Anyway looking forward to the new season with or without Keita!
16.) 04 Jul 2017 10:21:47
Cheers ed. I guess with both Ox and Keita as targets it doesn't sound good for the likes of Grujic, Stewart etc. Feel quite sorry for Grujic tbh.
17.) 04 jul 2017 10:46:39
itz mental on one side how many players are there like keita available and if we don't get him this year will there be similar quality available.
but then.
we need a lb and mendy is avaliable. there certainly won't be anyone in his calibre avaliable for a very long time, along with us actually being in a position to get them.
very very rare a player of his quality isn't already at a big club so to have a chance and miss signing your lb for the next 10 years when we haven't had one since riise (aurelio aside, as ed said he was made of tissue paper "ultra quality though') is astonishing.
18.) 04 Jul 2017 11:00:37
We have some of the best attacking players in the league we have more than enough midfielders now (although the Hendo theory above is extremely worrying and has a ring of truth to it) we need top quality defenders if we want our trophy back. Ming was ec.
19.) 04 Jul 2017 11:01:41
We have some of the best attacking players about. We have loads of strong, intelligent midfielders. We need to bring in quality defenders if we want our trophy back. Mingnolet was ok at end of season and although I agree karius should be given a chance I would feel happier with a real safe pair of hands in goal. Dunno if Hart would be the answer. They say a gk can win the league and I just don't know if we have a keeper of that sort of quality. Harsh but let's be honest. true.
20.) 04 Jul 2017 11:03:54
I have my doubts about Lakazette. Big difference between playing in the French league and the Premiere league.
21.) 04 Jul 2017 12:41:10
joe hart is not the answer, every free kick we would face would end up as a goal, he couldn't organize a funeral!
22.) 04 Jul 2017 16:10:36
To be fair, KK, a funeral is quite difficult to organise.
Now if you'r said "piss up in a brewery" you'd be bang on the money.
{Ed025's Note - i thought the same thing mate.. :)
01 Jul 2017 18:15:04
Ed01 I wanna ask u do u think we will get Naby Kieta and another centre half if gomez leaves on loan except VVD have u got any information from your sources
Thanks for your hard work.
{Ed001's Note - we have not agreed anything with RBL, who are not keen to lose the player this season, even knowing there is a good chance he will go for less next. Money is not really an issue for the club, what they want is the best possible squad for the Champions League. So it will be difficult to get him, without paying obscene amounts of money, which was what we baulked at doing with regard to VVD.
I don't know of any other centre back likely to be joining this summer.}
1.) 01 Jul 2017 18:30:12
Thanks a lot Ed01 for your reply its better we wait and see now what will be enfold in few weeks.
2.) 01 Jul 2017 21:58:36
i really wish we would man up and pay what it takes to land our main transfer targets.
3.) 02 Jul 2017 00:56:25
Nothing to do with manning up, Valent. If we don't value a player as highly as his parent club, we will offer less. Simples.
4.) 02 Jul 2017 15:34:27
I think the heightened interest in kieta speaks volumes about are chances of signing vvd sadly. Could never see us shelling out for both I just hope if we do sign kieta it doesn't affect our total football attacking style with three up front. Saying that we looked fantastic playing 41212 at the end of the season with coutinio deeper and sturridge starting. Kieta would fit in with that system well I think. I can't help thinking where that leaves Hendo and can who both seem to be growing into world class cms.
5.) 04 Jul 2017 02:01:13
I have a funny feeling Hendo's injury woes are a lot more serious than we are led to believe. There hasn't been a lot of talk about him. Can will stay and sign a new contract. He fits the Klopp mould and can only get better.
28 Jun 2017 14:10:48
Thanks for the reply ed01 robertson is not i am convinced as well but what can we do we support whoever wear our great club shirt but do u think and from your sources that liverpool will sign ricardo perriera or some other quality right back and go for other centre half like ben gibson or koulibly
Thanks ed001.
{Ed001's Note - I believe all three are off to different teams than ours.}
Viren1900's banter posts with other poster's replies to Viren1900's banter posts
01 Sep 2017 17:41:20
Thanks ed001 and other editors for the great work and ed01 kindly whenever u got time do the review of our signings as well as the whole window
Rhanks and appreciate your work.
{Ed001's Note - I will be doing it as soon as possible I promise and thank you very much Viren.}
24 Aug 2017 08:06:41
Ed001 excellent review mate excellent going forward especially firmino too gud but no discipline in midfield and defence what we can say how lovren gets chance with mignolet every game i don't now if its me mate i would have given chance to ward and gomez but extremely happy with win and waiting from your side a positive update on transfers specially defence
Thanks.
{Ed001's Note - thank you mate.}
1.) 24 Aug 2017 08:34:38
Thank you for the review ed001. It helps novices like me!
23 Aug 2017 17:57:57
Dear ed01 do u think at this moment with very little time left coutinho will leave if they pay huge amount without getting players in what's your take on it.
{Ed001's Note - I expect him to go because I am superstitious and what I want never happens with regards to LFC and player transfers! Plus, if I say I think he will stay, that would jinx it....}
20 Aug 2017 10:05:23
Thanks ed01 for your match review its always spot on waiting for win on wednesday and min.2 signings before transfer window ends and hoping for a great season for all the fans by our team.
{Ed001's Note - cheers mate, glad you enjoyed.}
20 Aug 2017 09:16:43
Deat ed01 u r always spot on i am hearing paul joyce saying barcelona has given the ultimatum to liverpool regarding couts till sunday what's the hell ed01 they are thinking try to get players on cheap by turning thier head not a gud way to negotiate and what's your take do u think if they don't stamp all the cash upfront min.130 mill. do u think we will let him go this summer
I always appreciate your gud work and mate kindly join ourclub liverpool
as a coach mate u have got exceptional knowledge about footbal mate
Thanks.
{Ed001's Note - it is only the kind of tactics we have been employing this summer. It is a club in a mess and they have already been shafted on Paulinho, the fans are upset about that, so now they are trying to bully Liverpool and Dortmund into selling for less than they want.
I am not a coach though mate, thank you for the kind words, but it is analysis that I do well, not coaching. I would be far too harsh as a coach, as I would pick too many faults in everything the players did and these days that is apparently not done.}
1.) 20 Aug 2017 09:51:22
An ultimatum to a club that doesn't want to sell? 😂😂🙌.
2.) 20 Aug 2017 09:58:08
I think the ultimatum makes it easier for us to say no, their offer does not offer value due to £40mil addons!
£120mil straight up and we may well deal, it's up to Barcelona not us, it's ridiculous to say but £80mil is no longer that much in football - I never thought I would say that!
We and Dortmund own the players, I am just grateful Coutinho does not act like Dembele. as far as we know anyway.
01 Jul 2017 18:30:12
Thanks a lot Ed01 for your reply its better we wait and see now what will be enfold in few weeks.
15 Oct 2017 08:14:37
Absolutely perfect review ed001 i wanted to see solanke starting and getting more oppourtunities as astriker he is gud and can be special if given oppurtunities.
{Ed001's Note - thank you V, I agree he has been impressive. Interesting in light of this article: Moenchengladbach Sporting Director claims England are producing the best youngsters that are being held back by a lack of opportunities.
20 Aug 2017 10:13:06
Agree mate o think they are just waiting for united to perform and aing their songs.
13 Aug 2017 08:40:00
Ed01 do u think it will harm our season much more now and can we buy delle ali for 100 mill. If couts go do u think spurs will sell for this amount.
{Ed001's Note - probably not and no.}
28 Jun 2017 14:02:24
I hope for the same.