Liverpool Rumours Member Posts

Red Bengal Tiger's Posts and Other Poster's Replies To Red Bengal Tiger's Posts

To Red Bengal Tiger's last 5 banter posts

To Red Bengal Tiger's last 5 banter replies

Red Bengal Tiger has no Rumours Posts

Red Bengal Tiger's banter posts with other poster's replies to Red Bengal Tiger's banter posts

23 May 2016 00:28:39
Since last season I've been a fan of Krychowiak. He was absolutely fierce for sevilla tonight. I think we should put a bid for him to sort out the dm position. Becuz i think he is one of the best DMs in the world right now. Eds do u rate him? .

{Ed002's Note - Liverpool has shown no interest in him.}

22 May 2016 19:10:48
Wow there are so many milner and lallana and Can sympathizers here.

1.) 22 May 2016 19:25:46
Can is 22 mate and one of our best players. Have a day off .

Milner and Lallana aren't the required quality but you can't hate people who work that hard for the shirt. Yes, they need to be improved upon, but they're not bad players and they a great role models. They will likely leave this summer, but they can leave with respect.

Perhaps you should have a little more respect.

2.) 22 May 2016 20:15:28
Can has been getting better and better, can't see why anyone would want him gone.
For me, it's fine having a player who puts it in, by you don't need two. Couldn't tell you who I'd keep. Lallana is younger, wins the ball back high, makes chances but has very few assists or goals, and dilly Dallys a lot. Milner is more experienced, and versatile and has a fair few assists, but has the misfortune of being called James Milner. I'm torn, but wouldn't mind if either left. If I had to pick, it would be Milner as he's probably going to decline soon, and lallana can learn more off Klopp, and add more to his game like goals, whereas Milner is as good as he has going to be.

3.) 22 May 2016 20:41:51
I dunno Fencey. I reckon I'd let them both go now we have no European football. There is less room for rotation. If Ojo, Grujic and Ibe are going to get any game time, we can't have Milner, Allen and Lallana taking up squad roles behind Coutinho, Firmino and Silva/ Zielinski/ Gotze etc.

There is no need for older back ups who are no more than good players. If we had Europa next year I'd have kept at least one of them. As it is, we simply don't need the squad to be anymore than 20 players or so, with the academy providing cover for injuries.

Lucas and Toure are both probably staying in some capacity so we have the experience there. A week ago I was sure we'd beat Sevilla and was therefore happy to keep Milner. Things change fast though, unfortunately!

4.) 22 May 2016 20:53:58
Agree with adam, i'd rather see our younger or better players play as a team without europe and gel more, we don't need the squad players anymore neither for their ability or backup, they will only have a detrimental affect on klopps signings or academy players. Why do you think we have so many youngsters being forced to leave now? I don't want to see an exodus of this sorts ever again, so many young players leaving at once due to lack of development or simy giving up on getting into the team.

5.) 22 May 2016 20:56:34
I don't want Can gone but he is far from as good or as flexible in roles as people think. Box to box, yes he can be fantastic but his defensive work against any kind of pace or quality and he's found lacking. The speed and ease of which Sevilla cut through our midfield just proves this point in my opinion. He is our platform to build our midfield on don't get me wrong but he needs someone behind him that allows him to do what he does best. Lallana, well you have to admire his effort and his work rate plus his willingness to run for the team. My main beef with him and its a big one really is his end product both in terms of assists and goals just isn't good enough, its never been great so its likely not going to improve, he's never scored more than five goals in a season I believe. Seeing how he's a CAM that's a big drawback and I agree with MKS that he needs to be improved upon but would be great backup. Milner I must admit I really didn't understand why he was signed and I thought this belief justified under Rodgers because he was dire but Klopp has found something in him and he has been outstanding and our only real crosser of the ball, his number of assists speak for themselves. He has proved me wrong and I don't mind admitting that. If I have one problem with him it is he doesn't chip in with enough goals but you can forgive him he assists so many. Milner Hendo and Can are good cover for the two CM spots but need a dedicated DM behind them.

6.) 22 May 2016 21:17:58
I would keep Milner. He has proved this season with goals/ assists and playing multiple positions that he can be a good player to have in the squad. Also, it certainly won't be easy to move on Milner who is on wages that only a handful of clubs in the PL can afford, and the ones who can afford him don't need him in the squad.

7.) 22 May 2016 21:41:57
Milner, Allen and Lallana are all better than Ibe, Ojo is not the final product yet (though I hope he gets there this season) and we don't know anything about Grujic and how he will settle in the PL.

Milner's contribution this season in terms of goals and assists was very good. I am fully awere of his deficencies and if we bring a better players than him or Lallana I wouldn't complain at all if they both start on the bench but let's see first that we bring quality players to replace them.

8.) 23 May 2016 04:42:28
I agree with a few things here
1) Milner is a wide player not a CM
2) so is Llalana
3) both work hard
4) both lack end product (although Llalana has scored a few and towards end of the season Milner has provided a lot of assists)
5) Milners assists are mostly crosses, so probably more effective to give us a vital plan B when keeping the opposition is packing the box and we have Origi upfront?
5) when we have both on the field we compound out problem of lack of end product

I think I'd be happy selling either one if we find a quality replacement like Gotze as both are more expensive than their end contribution would suggest. I originally would have gone for keeping Llalana but more recently swing towards keeping Milner as he's more versatile and can cross the ball.

9.) 23 May 2016 12:53:16
Yeah Liverpool should really be getting rid of versatile 22 year German internationals. If he gets in that shoddy side there is no way he is good enough for us.

21 May 2016 14:59:59
Honestly ask urselves. Do u want to rise to the next level? . If your answer is yes, then u need to sell Milner nd replace him with zielinski. Lallana is a one dimensional RUN PAST 9 player whose only capability is he can dribble. He ain't no good passer nor a good shooter. he is an extremely unintelligent, tactless, waste of time nd space. when we counter nd there are gaps to exploit we need sumone who can pass good through balls. Somethin that lallana can't do . If u look at our attack u see a few names who have a specific set of abilities which are all their common attribute. These are all BR SIGNINGS. When u look at coutinho, lallana, Firmino, Can they are all have a common EXPERTISE. They are all QUICK and they are FANCY dribblers nd that's it. We don't have variety is our attack. We have the same one dimensional speed and dribble. No passing, no intelligent buildup. This is a team made for possession football not for gegenpressing. So when we finally replace these fools with proper kloppers we will fly. Nd we will fly towards our first premier league tittle.

1.) 21 May 2016 16:12:56
Show some respect.

2.) 21 May 2016 16:18:02
So essentially you say zielenski is miles miles better than Milner? I haven't seen him play myself but I just doubt this, doubt you've even watched him enough yourself to boldly say that if I'm being honest. Ed002 says he is seen as probably not being first team regular so I just fail to see how this is the huge signing you seem to crave?

3.) 21 May 2016 16:28:49
Wow, embarrassing post imo. I'm not Milners biggest fan but what has Zielinski proven yet? And Can is just a quick and fancy dribbler? Really? I don't see any fools in the team and I certainly don't understand what our three best performers this season (Coutinho, Can and Firmino) have done to attract such criticism. It's the type of critique I would expect from another bunch of fans who's team plays in red.

4.) 21 May 2016 16:34:48
Bacon, like your style.

5.) 21 May 2016 16:44:52
There is so much nonsense in the OPs post, I think I will just take this as a windup and move on.

6.) 21 May 2016 17:06:02
Yeah think i'll just take that OP as a joke.

7.) 21 May 2016 17:07:43
"he is an extremely unintelligent, tactless, waste of time nd space. "
Sorry buddy but I think you're confusing Lallana with yourself.

8.) 21 May 2016 17:57:10
Surely a troll post? Anyone who uses that many capitals and that bad English has to be a troll. Instantly reminds me of these dodgy emails you get from Ugandan banks.

9.) 21 May 2016 19:00:12
How many players can better millers stars this year? Your a joke!

10.) 21 May 2016 19:35:08
Red - there is so much that is so wrong in your post that I don't know where to start. So, I'm not going to bother.

11.) 21 May 2016 20:46:31
Do you even know the meaning of 'tactless'? To be tactless is to say something without thinking about it. For example, if someone's mum had just died it would be tactless to make a mum joke.

I don't know Lallana so perhaps he is tactless, but that certainly doesn't affect his ability on the pitch haha.

12.) 21 May 2016 21:03:50
On the positive side, is zielinski is miles better then I am sooo looking forward to him coming and at least doubling milners production! Say 16 goals and about 30 assists would do nicely!

20 May 2016 00:24:59
If u want to give Emre can a big thumbs up then u are totally clueless about the game. After all, what is emre can? He is a defensive midfielder. His role is the same as Fernandinho of city or Matic of chavski. Which is to DEFEND. The one and only job of a defensive midfielder is to protect the back line. That is it. If somebody is not good at that then it doesn't matter what else they do.

Emre can can not defend. He has a 0 defensive awareness or instict. Yes I know he bursts forward a few times in a game but how does that help? It doesn't matter wtf he does if he simply can't defend nd protect the back line. Defensively he gets run over like a stooge. Becuz he ain't an expert like Lucas or mascherano or busquets.

He is as clueless as Charlie Adams was when he played there for a few games for us. A proper central defender was the problem we had during Bodgers. We conceded so many silly goal during him. Beciz we had no cdm. And usually u need two not one. city have Fernando nd fernandinho. Rafa had Lucas and mascherano. What a joy it was to see Lucas and masch play together.

They dominated the shit out of teams like real Madrid at that time. And here we are now. Bodger brought these one dimensions Run Past 10 men dribblers. They can not defend. They can not pass like modric. All they can do is dribble past 5,players at a time and lose the ball. In our entire squad we have only one cdm. One expert cdm Lucas. Lucas woudve dealt with Sevilla on his own.

Milner is another stupid player. His defensive work is soooo awful. I request u guys to watch him defend in the midfield role for one. Shocking. Even a league two player can run past him 3 times then nutmeg nd do all sorts of stuff. Thank god we have klopp. He knows wat joke we are dealing with . He needs nd will get proper defensive midfielders in the summer.

1.) 20 May 2016 05:04:35
I agree I feel can is massively overrated by people that don't understand the position properly. Just watch him closely and you'd understand he has massive deficits playing in that sitting role.

Yesterday was a perfect example at how weak our midfield is when you don't have any experience and top quality in there. Can has a lot of potential but people are making him out to be our future captain (which is borderline nonsense) or the finished article and he is far from any of them. We need a much better midfielder. Someone that reads the game well with proper midfielders quality and experience, to either partner hendo or can.

Let it be known that a fully fit and on form hendo is miles ahead of a fully fit on form can. Hendo just understands the position a lot better. Can is not a defensive midfielder, I'd say he's more of a box to box midfielder but isn't even good at that as his stats suggest.

Even hendo being injured for most of the season he still registers better figures than can. Yet can is somehow seen as our midfield maestro haha. If that's the case then it just proves how bang average our squad is as can should never in a million years be our best midfielder.

{Ed001's Note - he doesn't play a sitting role. Anyone who thinks he does I fear for. The only point he played a holding role was when Allen came on and Klopp changed things around.}

2.) 20 May 2016 05:46:20
Emre Can is not a defensive midfielder. some believe so just because rodgers played him at right back and center backs. he can fill those roles because well he had to, to be in the team. similarly for germany. he is box to box player, he loves to run with the ball etc etc .

he is more similar to henderson.
he never is was will be a defensive mid. he can sometimes dominate the midfield with some tackles interceptions and winning headers but he cannot protect your defence by sitting in front of it. it baffles me now that lucas didn't start the final to provide defensive cushion since sakho wasnt there and moreno has always been a liability defensively.

It just tells you how clueless klopp is at times. All he wants is the gegenpress and whilst it worked well in the first half once sevilla changed in the second half we got ran over, partly because we were still trying to press instead of defending, partly because it takes a lot out of players. as soon as we conceded quick in the second half and were literally destroyed in the first five minutes he should have brought on lucas or even skrte (well not really) to absorb and shore up the defence just to break their play and momentum.

Instead he continued with his team and brought on a half match fit origi in for firmino once we had conceded the second. How stupid is that? once you are 2-1 you have to get rock solid defensively and get lucas on to ensure you don't concede the third and are in the game but no, he brings on allen and benteke next! So we weren't good at all but it has to go down to Klopp, he didn't change the system right, you can't gegenpress once its found out.

Football finals are won solely on great defensive prowess alone. We would have won the game if after their first goal and relentless pressure he would have sent Lucas on to just do what lucas does. Intercept and break play and slow down the game.

I had not said this for long enough but I can't believe how people here just jump on players it was 100 percent klopps fault, he should changed his system in the second half when they were ascending all over us. he didnt. yea moreno can etc well the entire team didn't do much at all to help their cause but i think their desperation got them weak in the knees.

at that time you needed senior cool and defensively sound players like lucas or even skrtel to change the pace of game and make it a bit scrappy. instead klopp let us be ran over still stick with the press. and it obviously doesn't need bright mind to realise when you press for the ball with two three players pressuring for the same ball you are leaving huge gaps in the pitch and when the opposition knows this they will just play the ball in the gaps expecting one of their player reaches it.

and then its their attack. so to play that kind of game one has to ensure their is always lucas sititng back to ensure their is one player filling in the huge gap in midfield. unfortunately for us in basel neither of can or milner were capable enough to be that man. and it hurt us. i hope Klopp understands he can't act all stubborn with his gegenpress and incorporates more styles in his coaching.

I hope he understands his way has been found out big time at times in this season. so while many first 30 minutes of the game will go our way but the game might not. So either he makes his players machines in training that can relentlessly successfully gegenpress the whole 90-95 minutes or he adopts some tactful changes in his style.

I fear Klopp will not change his style but he will rather train his players to the max to play his style of game. whilst we might win many games in the league with his style, i don't think its the best style for a big final. I am with Klopp 100 percent, if he thinks he can train the team to press 90-95 minutes he will do it. But its always necessary to accept sometimes that you way is failing and be proactive and switch to plan B. with passionate guys like Klopp sometimes that is an issue, its hard for them to change something they believe in.

Hope that made sense, and wasnt complete rubbish. i try to write in english, so please excuse my punctuation and tenses.

{Ed001's Note - there was no gegenpress, we have not used that style at all yet. Klopp in no way played that way in the final.}

3.) 20 May 2016 05:54:28
then its just headless people running for the same ball leaving gaps behind them. Ed001, how many times did two or three players try to go for same player to win the ball leaving gaps that surely has to be press. if not what was that? over eagerness?

{Ed001's Note - yes over eagerness. A press is not everyone charging to the ball, nor is a gegenpress.}

4.) 20 May 2016 06:05:22
Klopp’s philosophy when losing is he rather lose 5 -0 and go for it rather than lose 1-0 nad not take risk, he said b4.that explain the situation.

5.) 20 May 2016 06:42:44
The only game we have remotely done Gegenpress is Spurs at WHL.

Do you think that Klopp is holding off from that style till next season ed?

{Ed001's Note - I don't know, he gradually moved away from it during his time at Dortmund, so I see little reason to expect him to return to it.}

6.) 20 May 2016 09:50:40
Klopp has said he sees this team as a possession team, which stands up as the fraud even though didn't know his arse from his elbow was trying to build a possession team.

7.) 20 May 2016 11:03:22
Can is a box to box midfielder, never has been or will be a DM.

8.) 21 May 2016 02:23:51
Im sorry ed01, but i cudnt make sense of your opinion. You said that can only switched to holding position when allen came on. Then please explain that who the heck was playing holding position untill that time if it wasnt can. Nd wat position was can playing. Can is not a cdm.

I know dat. He is clueless in that position. But that does not mean that he was not playing cdm for us. because he was. So what your saying ed01 is totally illogical. He has always played the deep midfield position which is known in football as cdm. If u didn't know. And if u play further upfront they call u CAM. Now can is not a genuine cdm. I thibk he should be playing CAM as his defending is shite. But u need to understand a simple fact that when u play deep in midfield, or let's say u play right in front of the back line (saying this incase u don't understand what a deeper midfield role is), then u are a holding midfielder.

Nd no matter if your leo messi or ronaldo or maradona, your main job is to protect the back line. Even if u have the tag of an attacking midfielder, that is your job. Nd that's y your the holding midfielder which emre was.

Red Bengal Tiger has no Rumour Replies

Red Bengal Tiger's banter replies

Click To View This Thread

21 May 2016 02:23:51
Im sorry ed01, but i cudnt make sense of your opinion. You said that can only switched to holding position when allen came on. Then please explain that who the heck was playing holding position untill that time if it wasnt can. Nd wat position was can playing. Can is not a cdm.

I know dat. He is clueless in that position. But that does not mean that he was not playing cdm for us. because he was. So what your saying ed01 is totally illogical. He has always played the deep midfield position which is known in football as cdm. If u didn't know. And if u play further upfront they call u CAM. Now can is not a genuine cdm. I thibk he should be playing CAM as his defending is shite. But u need to understand a simple fact that when u play deep in midfield, or let's say u play right in front of the back line (saying this incase u don't understand what a deeper midfield role is), then u are a holding midfielder.

Nd no matter if your leo messi or ronaldo or maradona, your main job is to protect the back line. Even if u have the tag of an attacking midfielder, that is your job. Nd that's y your the holding midfielder which emre was.