Liverpool Rumours Member Posts


Yankee Red's Profile

Current Avatar:
No Avatar image uploaded

No Profile Picture uploaded

Yankee Red's Posts and Other Poster's Replies To Yankee Red's Posts



To Yankee Red's last 5 rumours posts


To Yankee Red's last 5 banter posts


To Yankee Red's last 5 rumour replies


To Yankee Red's last 5 banter replies


Yankee Red's rumours posts with other poster's replies to Yankee Red's rumours posts


17 Aug 2018 19:09:49
What ever happened with Chirivella? I thought he was sold to Rosenborg, but he's in the U23s match today.

Yankee Red

{Ed002's Note - He opted not to make the move, but a transfer to Celtic in Scotland beckons.}

1.) 17 Aug 2018 22:31:07
Thank you.

2.) 18 Aug 2018 06:45:49
Would it be permanent or a loan, any info on that Eds? Big ups to the kid for what ever reason he decided against the move a lot of players would have. Pedro ain't a kid no more so hope this turns out well for him like Hendo and the Fulham show and he doesn't end up like Borini with his Sunderland episode. Kinda got me thinking how these kids get taken to foreign land ( in the sense that new life changing decisions will be taken) only find broken promises and lack of proper plan in place for the . I get that money and agents significant role but we talking human lives. We idolize them and to certain envy them but when you look at people like Gary Speed you realize that these kids have every day emotions, challenges and tribulations.

{Ed002's Note - I am pretty sure it would be permanent as he has no future at Liverpool. As for your more general comment, you are right that it should be more of a concern than it is. Some countries, like Brazil, have restriced moves abroad until the player is 18. Others allow younger players to move if their families move and have jobs not provided by the clubs. Most require education needs to be met in line with national standards - which is what happens in England regardless of language barriers etc.. But there are much more stringent rules coming. Manchester City got away wilth an issue last year by the skin of their teeth when an Italian passport of convience came to their rescue (as the rules discuss such passports but only in terms of adults). Interestingly Pipco is going down that road right now. But as you say, and certainly when moving to a country with an entirely different culture, language, food etc.. And clubs need to recognise when they send players abroad they need to keep a close eye on them to make sure they don't end up spending too much time alone playing electronic games. For instance there was a problem with a couple of players on loan in the Netherlands (where they were simply sat around in apartments for hours on end) and that resulted in the club concerned having them get involved with spending some time with the local community (schools and charities) and putting someone out there for a couple of months to steady everything, and get them playing golf etc.. A very good point, thanks.}

3.) 18 Aug 2018 20:13:13
Thanks on the detailed response Eds, Iam glad teams seem to have recordnised the issue and importantly actively working to words some sort of improvement. Some times Iam just left star struck from reading your response . Legendary stuff. Keep well.

{Ed002's Note - You are welcome.}

4.) 20 Aug 2018 07:57:53
Can someone please explain who PipCo is?

5.) 20 Aug 2018 22:42:44
Isn’t he a pal of #WDS?



19 Dec 2017 17:09:27
Is there much of a chance that Emre stays?

Yankee Red

{Ed002's Note - I think it is unlikely. There are a number of clubs who will look to direct talks with the player in January.}

1.) 19 Dec 2017 17:56:25
And if he does indeed leave in January ed do you expect a replacement, or wait until the Summer?

{Ed002's Note - Clubs are not looking to a January transfer but to talk to the player about a pre-contract for a summer move. Liverpool has more than enough midfield players at the moment and Nobby Keita is arriving in the summer.}

2.) 19 Dec 2017 18:21:09
Cheers ed. Emre qnd Couts will be missed but they both hsve the chance of playing on a higher platform. can't fault them for wanting to improve there playing careers and win trophys.

3.) 19 Dec 2017 18:45:08
What higher platform is Emre Can going to be playing on? Juventus are not a bigger club than Liverpool, either or Dortmund. What everyone and Emre needs to realise is that if he was under a longterm contract Juventus would have no interest in him, they'll promise him the world now but after a few poor performances or when the next young Italian star comes along he'll be dropped or sold in a flash. for a nice tidy profit of course.

{Ed002's Note - what he means is that he will be playing at the higher level - challenging for silverware.}

4.) 19 Dec 2017 19:27:01
I know what he means. he'll be challenging for silverware staying here.

5.) 19 Dec 2017 19:45:52
Ed 002, I am curious as to your thoughts on how Liverpool should progress as a club that can continually challenge for trophies? Anytime one of our players takes their game to the next level (Suarez, Couthino, Etc), clubs try and buy them from us. Yet when we dig our heels in we end up taking stick for it.
We can try and develop youngsters but once they turn 25 if those same clubs come knocking wanting to buy the cycle will repeat itself. Do we just need new owners with more money?

{Ed002's Note - That is just the transfer process - I am not sure why Liverpool fans feel hard done by. It is the same for all clubs.

This was a simple six point plan to get the entire club back on a good footing that I proposed a while back:

1. Corporate Business: Liverpool have done well financially out of the sponsorship and partnership agreements but in some cases have sold their soul to the devil and in others the deal is not as good as it could be for a club of the profile of Liverpool. Look to move away from Standard Chartered and bring in a higher profile and better paying sponsor as soon as is practical. The deal with New Balance/Warrior was a major mistake and the club need to exit it as soon as possible – sadly the boat to get a deal with Adidas after Chelsea dumped them has sailed. Any deals with organisations that are socially questionable (e.g. Bet Victor), socially bankrupt or have caused the club embarrassment (e.g. Dunkin’ Donuts), nonsense (Nivea and the club’s official coconut water supplier TCC), are from a country with controversial human rights (flag carrier Malaysian Airlines – who replaced just as bad Indonesia’s Garuda) should be cancelled or run down as soon as possible. Being on morally better ground will make a club with Liverpool’s profile to get better profile sponsors.

Status: Still not good.

2. Football Business: Liverpool has revamped in the past three years from top to bottom but yet Klopp is still getting an easy ride and the transfer windows are far from successful. Two things to do (a) get a decent Director of Football in (not taking the advice of anyone who suggests Damien Comolli would be a good idea), and (b) explain to Klopp that his inability to adapt is a large part of the problem as to why Liverpool are still inconsistent.

Status: Michael Edwards appointed - not ideal in my view.

3. Fan Considerations: Establish a point of liaison with fan representatives (Ed001 perhaps and the sad fat guy who runs the other site - I don't recall his name) but do not involve the Spirit of Shankly in any way – a bunch of morons in a pub who want the club handed over to them and are planning already to give the owners a hard time starting again this summer need to be brushed aside. If they are interested in buying the club they need to be told to have their bankers call when they have a $1B Banker’s Draft in hand and the club will be sold to them. If they want to act responsibly and represent supporters they need to lose the aggressive and controntational approach.

Status: The club has addressed this and appointed someone.

4. Wrest Power Back from the Players: Players at high profile teams (in particular in the Premier League and a few other individual players dotted around Europe) are not fully focussed on doing what they are employed to do, and in many cases are paid well to do. I would get someone in (a really knowledgeable football guy who can advise the club) and have them speak to each of the players to really understand where their focus is and where they want to be. I would also have a suitable advisor go right through all of the coaching staff and look at the methods of coaching. I would then get the players together and tell them that the club will be making addendums to their contracts requiring such things as responsible behaviour, not wearing flimsy designer football boots that offer little protection, wearing black boots only in games, responsible usage of social media, banning all at club visits by hairdressers and car salesmen, banning the use of all hair care products etc.. The players need to be controlled in any interviews and interviews, and any endorsements, should all be arranged through the club. Any players to which the club is making payments to third parties for such nonsense as image rights need to be moved on or the contracts amended at no penalty to the club. Then they need to be asked if they buy in to the club and these changes – if they don’t their agents can be told that the club is happy for them to find new employers for their charges.

Status: Nothing has been done.

5. Reserves and Loans: Firstly get some structure and planning for a career path and look to establish relationships with a couple of sides such that the loan system can work for the club. The liaison structure is critical as whilst managers may occasionally see players it is generally something undertaken by others dedicated to the task. As an example, each loan player from Chelsea has a liaison officer assigned (some are ex-players) who regularly see them, deal with any issues and report progress back to the club. For instance there was a problem with a couple of players in the Netherlands and that resulted in the club having them get involved with spending some time with the local community (schools and charities). Chelsea has also helped clubs they have and are building relationships with - this may include providing training facilities, loaning coaching staff, having ex-players works with them in some capacity etc.. They have a structure in the Netherlands and Belgium in addition to relationships with South American and old Eastern Bloc countries. They are currently working a deal with a Champions League side as well. Similarly in Italy I know that the clubs with a significant number of players on loan have regular contact and bring them back as a group for training on a couple of occasions mid-season. I am sure there will be someone at Liverpool keeping contact with the younger players on loan where there are legal responsibilities as some are still technically children but others on loan from Liverpool reported the occasional text message only – simply not good enough. Many clubs in Spain and Portugal have built relationships with other sides and it helps with brining in players from South America.

This still needs to be addressed.

6. On Field: Whilst the fans want significant changes every year the club needs to get in to the position of making small changes to improve the team each season, not simply discarding the work done and starting again. It has not worked with the recent managers at the club and Damien Comolli was a massive mistake (which I did explain here the day he joined). Right now the side is not too far away but like other managers it is a task Klopp struggles with – so the club need a good footballing guy as Director of Football to help out. Financially the club need to be self-sufficient or making a profit – particularly given the additional media income. Give Klopp the marquee buy of Julian Brandt this summer and then fix the problem areas though sales.

Status: Financially the club is better placed, ion field the side is playing well but is still inconsistent - but moving in the right direction.}

6.) 19 Dec 2017 20:51:20
Cheers Ed for the response. I also appreciate your answers to the follow up questions. To your response on the status of the club, I agree with each of your six points, and I hope you don't mind me adding my opinions on the matters.

1) I miss the Carlsberg and Adidas days - though we can still do better. Perhaps Nike would pick us up after Man United moved to Adidas?

2) Why can't we purchase a decent defender?

3) I think Tony Barrett is doing a fine job, but will struggle since Liverpool has some of the most delusional fans out there.

4) I don't think we'll ever see this happen. The Spice Boys got this tradition started at Liverpool, and even a consummate professional like Stevie G couldn't get rid of it.

5) I hate when you use Chelsea as a role model (personal reasons, namely jealousy) but I think they are the perfect one for how a loan system should work. IMO, Chelsea is one of the most well run businesses in football, up there with clubs like Monaco, Porto, Ajax. They always seem to break even or profit during transfer windows while improving their squad.

6) Inconsistent yes, but also fun to watch.

I'm not the most knowledgeable fan on the business side of things. I've only been watching the Premier League for the past 15 years (I'm American), and the stuff available to read doesn't seem to provide nearly as much about how things truly are as the Eds on this website. If I'm wrong, on anything, please correct me. But I do like the current status of our club. We are an entertaining side, can compete with the biggest of clubs on any given match day, and have plenty of room for improvement. Thanks again for your time!

{Ed002's Note - I am also an American. But not a Yankee. I think your points are good.}

7.) 19 Dec 2017 20:55:15
Your knowledge Ed2 is absolutely incredible and I admire it, thanks for the second time today.

{Ed002's Note - You are most welcome.}

8.) 19 Dec 2017 22:33:27
It's more of a satirical use of "Yankee" for me. I'm calling myself out as an American before anyone else can. I'm actually from the Southeastern US where Yankee is often used in a derogatory fashion towards "outsiders. "

{Ed002's Note - I am from the West Coast - you would never hear the word used.}

9.) 19 Dec 2017 23:08:15
brilliant, absolutely brilliant stuff Ed. The New Balance deal ends after next season, I believe do you know if they are speaking with anyone else or is it too soon?

{Ed002's Note - I think it goes on rather longer and I am not aware of any discussions with others just yet.}

10.) 19 Dec 2017 23:10:37
Fantastic and appreciated review of the clubs current status ed002. Cheers for your input, although iv no doubt it won’t be long before someone disagrees/ takes imaginary insult and says something silly on here!

11.) 20 Dec 2017 03:52:24
Great post Ed2, touched on a lot of good subjects there. Curious, what is your opinion on Liverpool getting a B team? Worth it?

{Ed002's Note - Liverpool already has one - they are currently top of play of Premier League 2.}

12.) 20 Dec 2017 10:28:35
Wow, Ed002, I don't even know what to say! Someone smart at Melwood should be hiring you right now if only there was anyone from the echelons reading or following this site. Even though you're not a Liverpool fan, your vision for how to run the club is unbelievable! Who could argue with all you just laid out?
Thanks Ed!

13.) 20 Dec 2017 10:48:14
Fantastic insight and comments to move LFC forward, thanks for that eds.

14.) 20 Dec 2017 17:58:04
As always great insights. Stil I have a couple of questions for you Ed 002, and a couple of comments.

1. I know we have made many mistakes appointing Sporting directors; but i wish to know what would make a candidate for Sporting director a good fit for this job, and what would make him/ her a good fit for liverpool sporting director spot.

2. In your point about Wrest Power Back from the Players, you talk about player's image rights, oeher third parties payments, and some of the other clauses you would addemend. So my question, is there any big club that right now has this kind of clauses on their players (specially on their star players) . I ask, beacuse as mucha as this is desirable, i can't imagine players and specially agents, nowdays would like to sign this kind of clauses.

3. I don't know if this was part of your point about football business, but our status and image in the transfer system has been awful for years. So if we can't clean our image, and if we can't get a good mix of players in tranfer windows we will continue in a all life transition team, just bringing good prospects or signing lots of mediocre players, never stablishing a team that can really compete at the highest level again.

4. I love Klopp, he has made a stronger team and squad, but you are right he should have found some solutions by now in problems we have had for a long long time. Stil impressed Migs's our number 1 (I like the lad, but just can't have him as n1 of a team trying to win PL and CL) . Defense and the issue of fitness/ rotation/ consistence are just other.

Hopefully we'll get back into greatest teams again. Since one or two years i think we are finally going forward; just hope we continue to go that way.

{Ed002's Note - (1) Yes, Liverpool has screwed up. Better options would be the likes of Rangnick, Zorc, Monchi, Marotta or Raul Sanllehi (who has just joined Arsenal. The pick would be Luis Campos. (2) Yes, at least one Liverpool player benefitted from substantial payments up until recently from image rights. Other clubs have players who have a serioes of strange clauses. In the past there have been players paid in classic cars and oil paintings and many paid off shore in tax free havens. Most of that has gone. (3) Liverpool need to act professionally for a sustained period if the wish to build a good image and have other clubs show respect to them. (4) Klopp is a good manager but the great manager learn from their mistakes.}

15.) 20 Dec 2017 20:23:47
Thank you very much for the response Ed 002! I got an idea of the kind of sporting direcor you'll be looking for.



01 Sep 2017 18:57:09

Other than VVD, did Liverpool make any real efforts at signing other centre halfs this past window? If so, do you mind providing who? Personally I thought it was a good window, would've been great had a proper CB been signed. And I'm wondering if Klopp felt the need to improve this area of the squad but no one was available, or if VVD was chased as he specifically was wanted.


Yankee Red

{Ed002's Note - No, just a very low bid. Van Dijk was the wanted player.}

1.) 01 Sep 2017 19:23:25
Sounds from the Howedes interview that we had some interest in him.

2.) 01 Sep 2017 19:31:42
hi edd002 im just curious to why we didn't have a plan b like we had with salah when brandt wouldn't come. What was the reason we didn't move onto other targets? . was it just a case of we thought that southampton would eventually let him go which was clear way before deadline day they werent.

{Ed002's Note - That would be one for Klopp.}

3.) 01 Sep 2017 20:44:28
There was a lack of decent CBs available. Hence City going for Evans. Just be patient it's a marathon not a sprint and we are well placed with what we have.

4.) 01 Sep 2017 21:53:52
Ings N Things, that's what I was getting at. Seems our lack of effort at signing a CB was due to a lack of availability of reliable options. I wouldn't quite say we are well placed with what we have though. Three senior CBs are all that are on the books (I'm not including Gomez as he hasn't had a true run there yet) . I still think our XI could compete with anyone, but we're an injury to Matip away from a slight crisis.

5.) 01 Sep 2017 22:30:32
I don't understand this concept of seniority amongst our centre backs? We complain that Lovren and Klavan aren't good enough and yet Joe Gomez isn't classed as a senior because he hasn't had a run of games? Well which is preferable, someone you don't rate or someone you haven't yet?

6.) 01 Sep 2017 22:54:24
It's obvious that klopp had his shopping list and he didn't want to settle for 2nd best.

I'm obviously abit concerned about us not getting a CB as we aren't going to be able to out score every team every game.

On the other hand though we haven't wasted money on a panic buy which is going to haunt us for years too come.

You look at the squad now and apart from a GK and CB back we are looking class.

7.) 01 Sep 2017 22:59:37
It was similar last January when Klopp said, if the right player became available we would move for him. Not the next best, only the right player.

I think its good we have a manager who is strong enough to tell the clubs bosses and the transfer committee the players he wants.

Its probably where Rodgers was lacking a bit and let players he didn't want pushed on him by the money men.

We can see We are on the right track when TOP players are refusing Arsenal, City and Chelsea to sign for us or wait where they are until they can join us.

Im old enough to remember the good times under Paisley, Fagan and Dalglish and also the steady decline that ended with Hicks and Gillette nearly bankrupting the club.

This is the first time in many years that I feel we are the up and coming team, but it won't be all this year butits refreshing to know that Top players are waiting to come.

The owners are not a Cuuntry like qatar backing PSG or the Arabs at City and will not risk the clubs future in the transfer market but even the most negative fan has to see the new stand and all round mprovements everywhere.

8.) 01 Sep 2017 23:10:36
If Klopp is happy to be patient and stick with what he has then I'm happy with that. Just wish we hadn't marred the vvd situation from the off. The world can see we're a club on the up so let's be positive and confident ;)

9.) 02 Sep 2017 00:22:29
LOL. We've even on the TAP UP.

10.) 02 Sep 2017 01:53:08
Thing is we need two CBs. I would have taken a decent 2nd choice for now then Vvd jan. If Matip lovren injured. Gomez klavan. Wow. there's a lot of games till jan and No guareentee VVD will still be adament on lfc move if SHFC say no to us. Then he will move chelsea in jan. Qulaity CB not cup tied in jan will be hard to find.

11.) 02 Sep 2017 02:05:24
I'm with you Lfcder. What excited me the most is the fact that Ox turned down the champions to join Liverpool. Keita willing to wait for a year to join, and Lemar snubbed Arsenal when at the same time Liverpool showed interest (he preferred Liverpool, right? ) . That is a really good sign. I don't like during the Rodgers era when he didn't manage to get his main targets, we ended up with whoever that were available, spend for the sake of spending, and it brought us nowhere.

The only thing dissappoints me is we couldn't get the replacement for Coutinho. Maybe I'm among the minority here (or maybe I am the only one), I read posts in Arsenal forum about Sanchez and couldn't help but to agree, what's the point of keeping a player that wants out. We might ended up better without him.

12.) 02 Sep 2017 08:07:57
LFcder, no players were pushed on BR any money men (whoever these people are) . BR was in charge of the committee and had the final say on who we get and don't get. If BR lacked the bottle to put his foot down then that is his problem and not that of anyone else's. Klopp is in charge of the committee as well with consultation from Buvac (who recommended Grujic) and Kraveitz. He is stubborn and sure of himself, things BR severely lacked which is why he is respected and BR never was. This notion that BR was overruled by the money men or by the TC (which he heads) has been debunked since 2015 by Ed02 so people need to stop pushing this myth as none of it is true.

13.) 02 Sep 2017 19:32:02
Thats exactly what I said.

Its probably where Rodgers went wrong.
There was at the time within FSG the 'moneyball' philosophy. Where the club would invest in players that would develop and to move on at a profit, if the club chose,
Origi, Coutinio, Ballotelli, Borinii, Aspas, Gomes lliori, and many more.

How many of them have had a positive affect on the first team.

Not many. and that's What I meant by money men having control as opposed to football men, as is the case now,

LFC should never have given Rodgers the job, they did so because he had history and Knowledge of youth set ups all round Europe from his time with Chelsea.

We have a strong manager now who knows what he wants snd will go get it if available,
if its not available he won't compromise but will work with what he has already as they are familiar with his requirements.

14.) 03 Sep 2017 07:54:14
I don't get this whole " no centre backs are/ were not available"

The recent issues at the back has been going on since BR's teunure. Klopp would have done his homework on this before he arrived but has still not fully addressed the issue since he arrived in Oct 2015.

Someone said previously klopp won't take second best and is happy to wait, well that's another load of rubbish too. He bought Klavan whom is no where near second best! What about Caulker? ill advised maybe but he should have known better and "waited"

If we can't get a decent CB then we need a new defensive coach to at least try anx work with what we have.

{Ed001's Note - Klavan is a back up, you can't get the best as a back up and he was deliberately chosen because he is strong and good in the air plus able to cover left back. There were no top class centre backs available, you might not get it, but it is true. If there were, do you think there would have been so many teams, including Man City and Arsenal, interested in Jonny Evans? Good as he is, he is a long way from a world class defender.}

15.) 03 Sep 2017 08:32:40
Thanks for the reply ED001.

If you read my post, I quote that klopp has been here since Oct 2015, he would have surely done his homework on the shambolic defence he took over from BR.

I read all your comments Ed"01 and have a hell of a lot of respect wkth what you day but I totally disagree with you regarding Klavan. If you're saying to me that Klavan has been the best available since Oct 2015 then sorry I don't buy that, back up or not

Watford away, I was at that game Ed 1 and Lovren was bullied all afternoon in the air, he couldn't cope. Why not bring on Klavan to deal with their powerful attackers?

We conceded 12 goals from set pieces alone last season. Klopp has had enough time to address this issue.

I'm not alone on this, just about every person I speak to can see the problems we have, why can't the scouting or the defensive coaches?

{Ed001's Note - the scouts and the coaches do see it and are working on it. It is not as easy as clicking your fingers. As for what you are saying about Klavan, you can moan about him all you like, but how many other centre backs could cover left back at the time we bought him that were available to us? Since Oct 15, is irrelevant, we had Sakho before, so we were looking to upgrade on him, Matip was brought in for the right side to upgrade on Lovren. It should be Matip/Sakho as the first choice pairing, with Gomez/Klavan as the back ups.

As for Watford, it was the first game of the season, move on, it takes a while for teams to get going. 7 clean sheets in the last 9 Premier League games suggests there is improvement there defensively. Much better to take a longer view as one off games can be an aberration, such as the Watford one.}

16.) 03 Sep 2017 09:30:36
It's not just about clicking ones ED1, the coaches and scouts have had plenty of time since Klppps arrival to sort out the defence. We conceded 42 PL goals last season, most out of all the top 4. So have the other teams that conceded less not strengthen their defence because there was no one available?

Sakho was banned from March 2016 so the writing on the wall was from then and yes 2015 was relevant because we're no better than BR's defensive unit.

I'm not interested in having a poor defender in Klavan, that can cover LB and CB because it hasn't worked has it?

Did you watch the last game of the season against Boro? One of those last seven you mentioned. Thier attackers got goal side of Lovren at least 3 times, luckily woefull finishing meant we are in the CL places.

Did you also see how Hoffenheim calved us open time after time?

As much as it pains me, you watch how well United do this season with a solid defence.

{Ed001's Note - I watch every game, I also watch hundreds of other games a day and you are quite clearly of the opinion we are worse than everyone else and that no one else's defenders get caught out. Which suggests you need to watch more of other teams because it happens all the bloody time in the Prem, the defending is utter crap in 90% of games. The ones that do best defensively are Spurs, yet Vertonghen regularly gets caught out, it is just that they have a lot more protection from the midfield. They also have a keeper behind them that makes saves, rather than Mignolet. There is a lot more to it than just the defenders.

To be honest this conversation bores me because it is always the same hysterical bull with no balance. Whining on and on about Klavan is not going to change anything. Especially as your whines are so pathetic and just you calling him names. You never explain anything, just whinge. You don't explain why they were goalside of Lovren. Was he ballwatching? Was he trying to hold a line and they got caught out? Was it good play from the forward? Or do you not actually know and just want something to whine about?

As for Hoffenheim, we got carved open because both managers took a chance and gambled on being able to outscore the other. They were throwing extra bodies forward and Klopp was brave and kept his players high to catch them out on the break, believing we were better than them and so could outscore them with the gaps they were leaving. I think we can safely say he was right and it was a very enjoyable game because of that. Ok he could have kept you happy by doing a Jose and sitting all ten outfield players behind the ball and gone for a 0-0, but who wants to watch that?}

17.) 03 Sep 2017 10:38:48
So why are you ignoring the fact we conceded 42 goals last season? This has nothing to do with other teams, all I said was that we conceded more goals than other of the top 4 teams, that's the reality Ed1. Chelsea conceded 33 goals and won the league! So again Ed 1, why haven't we addressed the keeper situation or are you gong to say there were none available?

Whines? Actually Ed 1 if you care to look back on here regarding the Boro game you'll see I explained what happened with Lovren, after I returned from the match.
What names? Just because I call him a poor defender? Shall I send some cotton wool in the post? I didn't realise we were discussing each game in depth right now?

What a different conversation we'd be having had Hoffenhime been more clinical? Scored the penalty from Lovren's mistake?

What did Jose win in his first season playing boring football ? Two trophies and a route into Europe . We played lovely football going forward and what did we win? Who will be remembered?

You want to talk about Whining Ed 1? Come and sit with me on the Kop, listen to the radio Merseyside phone phone in in the way home. Bring your pacemaker, you'll have heart failure.

{Ed001's Note - I can't be arsed, you have nothing of interest to say, nothing new, no insight, you can't even understand anyone else's point just shout about the same old things. Carry on whining it is obviously the only thing that makes you happy is unconstructive criticism.}

18.) 03 Sep 2017 11:01:27
Me neither Ed 1.

I see far more watching the back 4 when it's live.

This conversation is to do with our failure to sign a decent centre half durng his appointment at LFC.

{Ed001's Note - it really depends, if you had access to the scouting sites, you would see even more. You can watch it over and over again from multiple angles. It makes a huge difference.

The conversation is just pointless, no one signed a top class centre half other than one going to Milan. There are very few of them available and each one had 10s of suitors after them if they did. It says a lot that so many were after VVD and Jonny Evans, neither of which are top class. There just aren't many around which is why teams are taking chances on players like Bailly and Lindelof in the hope of getting lucky and they work out. We already have one player in that mould in Gomez, that is intended to be gradually fed in, so we couldn't go and get another without blocking his route. It is a long term view Klopp is taking, it is how he works. There is none of this buying a quick fix, he always wants to look at building for the future.

We have 2 decent centre halves, we don't need a decent centre half now, we need a better centre half and that is the issue, they are all just decent or unavailable. No point buying to stand still with players that are only of equal quality. Better to develop Gomez, who is expected to be far better than decent.}

19.) 03 Sep 2017 15:04:22
Interestingly enough, I think Bailey and Keane ( now at Everton ) are better than both Klavan and Lovren. I only see our CB's live and the errors they make, so full judgment based on seeing the other two live only twice a season is difficult.

I will agree with you regarding Gomez, he looked very composed before he got injured and also the appearances he's made this season. He's not rash on the ball and will try and bring the ball down, chested or otherwise, and puck a pass, as apposed to just heading the ball back to the opposition or no mans land when it comes to him.

Again I agree we need better but we've needed better form when klopp started. For me, Matip is the only one I'd keep out of the three. Conceding 12 goals last season from set pieces is not good enough. Now is that zonal marking? For me it's a mixture of Zonal marking and individual errors.

We are never going to win anything unless we dramatically improve at the back, be it be new personal or better coaching. This has been proven since the BR days and has filtered through to klopps reign. We have won nothing.

I'm fully behind building for the future but as it stands, under klopp, we have improved our strengths but not our weaknesses.

20.) 03 Sep 2017 18:45:19
I think Klopp has improved on Skrtel with Matip and improved on an old Toure with a younger Klavan who is nowhere near as bad as some would have you believe. If he was Russian/ German/ French/ Spanish/ Argentinan nobody would moan as much about him.
So that's 2 he's improved on in less than 2 full years, have some patience man this isn't a video game.

21.) 03 Sep 2017 21:19:45
Seriously Kev 1, are you for real?

22.) 03 Sep 2017 21:55:51
Don't believe the hype and stop looking for arguments Nicholas.

23.) 04 Sep 2017 10:14:43
I personally don't rate Keane as a centre back, he is awkward on the ball and doesn't really have a lot of pace.

Given that we missed out on VVD, I would like to see Gomes getting games above Klavan and if he does well, then the first choice partnership should be Gomes and Matip.

Gomes has a lot to offer, he is very quick, good in the air, physically imposing, confident with the ball at his feet and he appears to be defensively very sound (there are many better judges than us who rate him very very highly) . The only question mark is experience and if he has recovered fully from injury, which you can only answer the experience question with playing games and sticking by him and the injury issue can only be answered by the medical staff and playing time.

24.) 05 Sep 2017 02:30:32
It's so refreshing to read that reply from Ed001 about the defender situation! Our centre backs actually do quite well compared to the rest of the league, but there's more to defence than the centre backs. Not to mention, the set pieces are almost exclusively conceded because of individual errors from the midfielders or strikers not doing their role.

Also our playing style means we need to be disciplined in midfield and most of the time we get caught out is because a mistake there exposed us. Any game plan that involves constantly putting our centre halves in one on one situations, especially against quick players, is always going to be a roll of the dice. I'd go as far to say that Lovren is one of the best in the league for those situations. In a normal backline it's risky defending but when you're exposed so often it's necessary. The amount of times he's had to make a block or interception to prevent an almost certain goal is way too high, and 95% of the time it's not his doing that puts him in that situation.

Defending for Liverpool is harder than for just about any other team so there's no point bringing in a defender who does well in an easier setup. If it's not a clear upgrade, we're wasting our time. We've done well this window, and on top of that we've made a statement. Now we just need to perform on the pitch and by next season can genuinely be seen as an elite European club again.



08 Aug 2017 17:24:12
I hate asking, but ESPN are reporting Liverpool have accepted a bid front Barcelona for Coutinho. Any truth to this?

Yankee Red

{Ed002's Note - I am not aware of any agreement at this point in time.}

1.) 08 Aug 2017 18:05:11
How many times had we signed Keita and VVD according to ESPN and Yahoo etc.

I'd take it with a pinch of salt until anything is confirmed by the club.

2.) 08 Aug 2017 18:59:35
Agreed. That's why I came and asked here. Not trying to brown nose, but I trust the editors here more than anyone in the press.

3.) 08 Aug 2017 19:36:45
None of it is true. Sky Sports have said that Barcelona officials never met with LFC officials and LFC's stance is unchanged. Guillem Balaghe via twitter, also said that LFC's stance has not changed and we met with no one. They however, did go to Germany to thrash out a deal for Dembele, per Bild. We are still holding firm for the time being.

4.) 08 Aug 2017 20:48:33
Do fsg not have a stake in espn. Not sure if I remember correctly. If so worrying.

5.) 08 Aug 2017 23:48:30
No, that's NESN.



21 Jun 2017 13:53:38

What precisely is going on with the FA inquiry? I know it was said that last Monday an announcement would be made. Have they dropped the case?


Yankee Red

{Ed001's Note - as far as I am aware, they haven't yet decided whether to pursue a case against us or not. Monday was expected to be the decision, but this is the FA and they don't necessarily move quickly.}

1.) 21 Jun 2017 18:35:24
Thanks for the response. It's a shame the FA is so slow, especially given that it's the offseason.

2.) 21 Jun 2017 19:51:51
Maybe that's why. Holidays for people.




Yankee Red's banter posts with other poster's replies to Yankee Red's banter posts


07 Sep 2020 16:31:45
There’s a thread on Twitter posted from handle “@SwissRamble” that goes over LFC’s finances and why it has the funds available that it does. It seems to align with what Ed002 is stating, so it might worth a read. Ed002, if he is wrong, I apologize for aligning your name with his. Seems legit though it is on Twitter.

Yankee Red

{Ed002's Note - This has been mentioned multiple times today thanks. I have glanced at some of the things he has produced in the past and they look pretty good from an analysis perspective, but I have not seen what he has posted today.}

1.) 07 Sep 2020 17:45:52
02 but it in simple form for us and he’s said it wks and sick of repeating himself over finances so hopefully this will stem the where’s the money posts!

2.) 07 Sep 2020 18:58:03
JDR, want to bet?

3.) 07 Sep 2020 19:25:31
Do I want to bet will it stem where’s the money posts?

Course not red Meister 🤣.



14 Mar 2019 18:50:59

I was curious if you had an opinion or knew anything regarding Naby Keita's maturity level. I recall you bringing up a number of issues during his time at Leipzig, such as bragging about how much money he is making. I know there have been injuries, but's been somewhat of a disappointment this season. He's clearly gifted, but is struggling to make any impact. Is this down to just injuries, or is he still acting immature?

Thank you for your time.

Yankee Red

{Ed002's Note - I think it is todo with attitude; he arrived after a bunch of issues in Germany - the court case was a big deal, the restaurant issue was an absolute disgrace and there were language issues, the car, the red suit and not showing up for training. He has had more than 18 months to learn English but that has not worked out. The club will persist - at least for a while.}

1.) 14 Mar 2019 19:23:27
He sort of reminds me of Sakho. I don’t know too much about his issues, but it seemed like he was too immature a person to live up to his hype as a player. Only positive I see is that JK doesn’t have patience for those antics. Hopefully Naby gets it together before JK runs out of patience.

2.) 14 Mar 2019 20:28:06
Respect eds02.

3.) 14 Mar 2019 20:25:22
What was the restaurant issue?

Or is that a can of worms we don’t want to open.

{Ed002's Note - It is no secret; leaving a restaurant he took a bunch of notes, screwed them up and threw them on the ground leaving the staff to pick up their tips from the floor.}

4.) 15 Mar 2019 05:35:01
Seems like he is a troll person. We can see that on the bezzies video with Mane aswell. Its not bad to be such person, but you need to know when you hit the limit and stop. Seems like he still needs someone to show him where the limts are, let's hope Klopp is the guy, as Keita has talents and he can become one of the best if he keeps it calm otherwise we can look at someone like Balotelli and wasted career.

5.) 15 Mar 2019 03:55:01
Classy ☹️
Dare I ask for your opinion on how salvageable this is ed2? Is he just "like that" and so beyond help or you think can be taught how people in a normal society should behave?
Thanks for any and all input 👍.

{Ed002's Note - All of the issues were in Germany and many were a result of bravado after signing for Liverpool. If the language issue could be over come it would make life easier for everyone.}

6.) 15 Mar 2019 07:23:34
This season has been a settling in season for him.
We’ll see if he can knuckle down next season, it’s too early to judge him.
Thanks for the insight ed002 - most grateful 🤝.

{Ed002's Note - I don't think using excuses such as "settling in" are addressing the issue.}

7.) 15 Mar 2019 07:58:32
Sorry Ed was this whilst he been with us or at RBL?

{Ed002's Note - In Germany.}

8.) 15 Mar 2019 09:44:34
Not even going to excuse the boy for the restaurant incident. That kind of behavior isn't welcome not just at a football club but in society.

Hugely disappointing to hear this.

{Ed002's Note - This was a year ago and RBL read the riot act.}



25 Jan 2019 18:02:22

Around a year ago - maybe longer - you listed off some of the things that Liverpool needed to do in order to become a more sustainable business and reputable club. It was about 5-6 things, and one I recall sticking out was their management of players out on loan. I was recently reading an article about Harry Wilson in which Julian Ward was mentioned as having kept tabs on the young lad. Ward has held the position of loan pathways manager for over three years now, I believe, and I was curious if you knew whether he had grown into this role or not. Basically, has the club been better about making contact with the youngsters out on loan and helping them adjust, or is it same ole, same ole?


Yankee Red

{Ed002's Note - The club are very aware that they have not been the best at structuring loans. Wilson has stood out because of a few free kicks but largely the issue exists still - perhaps better than it was. It is better than it was wnem Rodgers would send, or perhaps have sent, the occasional text message, but right now it is still haphazard to say the least. Other clubs will put together a plan for progression to players and will keep in regualr contact - putting the onus on players to perform and offering help to get them to the point where this can be achieved. The club does still have players on loan who will struggle for Work Permits - another massive lesson to learn for Klopp.}

1.) 25 Jan 2019 19:33:30
Thank you for your response. I know it is not your typical question on this site.

{Ed002's Note - It is Ok - and good to be asked a reasonable question. The club has recognised a number of failings and is working toward improving the situation. The team is playing well, and getting the rub of the green and making the most of it - and that puts them in a great position for the league this year. Not much needs changing right now.}

2.) 25 Jan 2019 22:05:27
Hi Ed, this is the sort of information I love from you. Please keep these nuggets coming!

Thanks as always


3.) 25 Jan 2019 22:27:05
Ed002 what type of stockings do u wear?
White ones or fishnet?

4.) 26 Jan 2019 15:48:25
{The club does still have players on loan who will struggle for Work Permits}

Ed002, question on this if I may. Does this statement infer some sort of naivety or failure on the scouting front in that they have recognised these young guys with expectation of hitting the big time thus making a WP easier, or is more-so the structural, or lack thereof, nature of the club?

And by Klopp do you mean Klopp himself or he was also unaware of the issues? I assume it would be partly the former due to the Grujic scenario, for example

Cheers :)

{Ed002's Note - Klopp damaged the reputation of the club by lying previously. It certainly did not help.}



17 Jul 2018 18:20:48
Question regarding Shaqiri. I've only ever watched him play on the right. Can he play on the left? Seems the club has a penchant for buying right sided wingers.

Yankee Red

1.) 17 Jul 2018 18:29:08
Yes mate he can play on the left as well.

2.) 17 Jul 2018 18:37:47
Well it's good they're moveable - mane can play both sides, Salah up too, fekir anywhere across the front three if he comes as well as deeper, Ox cm and wide! I think Keita played a fair few games right mid as well, but shouldn't come to that.

3.) 17 Jul 2018 19:34:25
Keita can also play the no. 10 a bit while Shaq can play anywhere behind the striker.

4.) 17 Jul 2018 21:49:26
Any player (or non player) can play any position on the pitch. Question is are they any good at it?

5.) 18 Jul 2018 05:45:21
Bobby's blinders, usually when people say "playername" can play x position, it means they are good in said position. Or they'd say he can’t quite play x position, or, he isn’t really suited to playing in x position.



14 Jul 2018 15:50:42
I hope everyone was paying attention today when Karius was ironically cheered. That kind of support is appalling. Get behind the lad or find a new club.

Yankee Red

1.) 14 Jul 2018 16:09:09
Where playing away. There bury fans 🤣 they don't care about karius.

Be good preparation for the 70k who do it at old Trafford or the 60k at city, 60k at Tottenham or every single premier league club that will hound him for the next season.

The liverpool fans give him a round of applause when he gets to his goal.

Get off your high horse dude :)

2.) 14 Jul 2018 16:33:30
Oh here we go again with the outrage on how our players are treated.

3.) 14 Jul 2018 16:45:35
You’re missing the point. Just look on the LFC post that announced the starting lineup. Most of the replies are trashing him. And if supporting players rather than trashing them puts me on a high horse, than I don’t even want to know how pathetic your life must be.

4.) 14 Jul 2018 17:10:27
Yankee, it was the home fans ironically cheering. You can't police other teams fans. I completely agree we should get behind our own players when they are playing for the team and negative comments made by our own fans before a game when the team is announced is not on, but every game he plays in this season he is going to get negative reactions from other teams fans. He is going to have to deal with that at it will happen.

5.) 14 Jul 2018 17:13:46
It's blind support the lad simply is not any good. Accepting mediocrity is why we have not won a league title in almost 30 years.

6.) 14 Jul 2018 17:15:52
I take your point, I do think Klopp has a blind spot for Karius.

7.) 14 Jul 2018 17:18:53
Exactly redmick.

We can support all we like, doesn't make someone good.

He had all the support in the world and gave the champions league to Madrid as a result.

He's going to Get absolutely destroyed by every single away fan and god forbid if we pull Madrid at any point in the champions league, even if he's had a blinder of a season it will all rear it's head. If he isn't prepared for it then request a move, otherwise get ready for a lot of pressure.

8.) 14 Jul 2018 17:22:07
But there’s no need to abuse the lad REDMICK, that’s unacceptable.

9.) 14 Jul 2018 17:23:16
You are bang on Yankee but seriously mate, just leave it. It's not worth it. We'll all just keep going around in circles.

Karius is going to have to rise above it, so we all might as well do that too.

10.) 14 Jul 2018 17:33:54
Just got back from the game and I can assure you Karius was clapped from all the Liverpool fans (a 3rd of the stadium)
And the one stand of bury fans took the piss out of him. But what do you expect after being awful of late, at Old Trafford Ect he will be under massive pressure all game from the crowd n players. I think we'll need a better Keeper in this window if we want success.

11.) 14 Jul 2018 18:04:33
Well if we all hate Loris so much we better sack Klopp then, as Ed02 has said. What’s that? It’s not up to us? The manager and club might know better than us? Oh. Well that’s a shame. Spose we best just support our team and players then eh? I am a fan after all. Silly me.

12.) 14 Jul 2018 18:08:01
I'm with you Yankee mate but as MK says we're going round in circles. We can discuss it until we're blue in the face, unfortunately this changes nothing.

13.) 14 Jul 2018 18:14:00
He’s one of OUR players!

Yes an upgrade should be signed but why on earth would anyone abuse him?
Makes no sense to me!

No player should be certain of their place; if Maradona of Shearer could be bought I’d bench Salah and Firmino too!

No player should ever walk alone especially while still with and playing for us!


14.) 14 Jul 2018 18:45:15
Yankee, it was the Bury fans doing the cheeky jeers at Karius, not the LFC fans cos the applauded him when he got to his goal. We were playing away from home so what did you expect? Flowers and chocolates for Karius from the Bury fans? This is the hand he would have been dealt should he be no. 1 and as MK said, we will all have to rise above it esp. him and move on cos it ain't going to get any easier when the season begins.

As for the SM fans trashing Karius, there is a good reason why Klopp tells his players to get off SM and look at the wonders that has done for a guy like Lovren. As fans the best way we can help Karius (or any other player in a bad patch), is to drown the boos with hearty cheers to let the player know he is NOT walking alone. That would be my suggestion.

15.) 14 Jul 2018 18:50:56
It sounds like he was getting support from our fans at the ground. How someone reacts on social media is a different matter, no-one knows if the negative comments are from Liverpool fans or not, anyone can claim to support anyone. People create fake accounts.

As long as he’s getting a fair response from fans at the match that’s all we can hope for.

I don’t know why people moan about the starting line-up in friendlies, friendlies are for building match fitness and understandings. If he makes a bad error then criticise, but don’t criticise the line-up for friendlies - pure madness 🤪.

16.) 14 Jul 2018 19:11:18
Social media brings out the worst in people. It gives them an alternate identity they can hide behind, they then believe they can say whatever they like without consequences. Freedom of speech is great, however many people don't stop and think of the effects this has on the subject of their vitriol. I bet most of the people voicing this abuse wouldn't say the same comments to his face and that's the way it should be on SM.

17.) 14 Jul 2018 20:13:36
Who cares what people say on here or what opposition fans do at matches? What is important is that our players feel supported by our fans at matches. It's simple really. None of them are likely to be reading this or any other site and only foolish players and those that don't actually care what folks say to them online would have anything to do with twitter et al. I bet Bobby and Salah etc regularly get pelters, even it it is from opposition fans or whoever, but it's unlikely to be publicised because they don't have a negative focus on them.

Thumbs down me all the folks who can't see the wood for the trees, but Karius will get a tirade of god knows what wherever he goes, but you can better your bottom dollar, if he's on the team sheet come the first match of the season, he'll get cheered like the rest of the players by our fans. If he pays attention to the internet, knowing full well how fickle and harsh it is, more fool him.

18.) 14 Jul 2018 20:43:58
One thing I'v learned about reading on here is that both the praise and the slating is usually over the top. Way over the top. So I read it with a smile. In one ear and out the other. Like everyone else, I too have my liked and disliked players on the team, but I scream and shout for the team to kick ass and do well, during every single game. And at the end of the day, that's all that matters.

19.) 14 Jul 2018 20:57:28
ArAy Your first sentence sums it up for me.

20.) 14 Jul 2018 22:06:09
Sorry Yankee, I can't just pick and choose a new club. I've been a Liverpool fan since I was 6, since I first really kicked a ball. 31 years a Liverpool fan and supporter.

"Find a new club" impossible. It would be like dating a brunette when I'm seriously, deeply, madly in love with a blonde. I like celtic.

21.) 14 Jul 2018 22:29:29
If karius is number 1 come the start of the season then we find out once and for all what he is truely made of.

If i was in his shoes id be coming off every training session hardly able to stand. First one there and last one to leave.

That mansion mtv style video he put up should have been a 5 minute comp video of him busting his ass taking shots for hours on end. Goalkeeper drill training until he threw up.

Favourably edited or not it would have been at least the first step to bridging the gap.

If he doesn't approach this season with a major chip on his shoulder then he just ain't going to cut it.

He has a chance to use what has happened to him in the final and after to make him the the best keeper he can possibly be.

Away fans will murder him this season but above all positions the goal keeper position has no room for snowflakes.

The abuse he has taken from his own fans is unacceptable but its part and parcel in todays football world unfortunately.

Liverpool fans will quickly forgive him if they see effort and improvement in his game. Most true fans don't even see that there is anything to forgive. He simply had a bad game. Goalkeepers don't often get away with having bad games because it usually ends in defeat.

The debate most fans are having or have been having is whether or not they see him ever becoming a top level keeper. That debate was going on way before the final.

If a new big money number 1 keeper is signed karius should knocking on klopps door and requesting a loan move to a team where he is going to see plenty of action.

If he stays as a number 2 he is done for in terms of him ever hoping to be a top level keeper.

And if that aspiration isn't even in his thinking well shame on him.

If it is then i wish him the best of luck in the hopes of achieving his goals.

22.) 14 Jul 2018 22:48:38
Fair post that Wolverine. Nice one mate.




Yankee Red's rumour replies


Click To View This Thread

05 Sep 2020 09:29:01
I agree Gini is very important, but Virgil played the most minutes last season, followed by Robbo, Salah, Trent, Bobby, Sadio THEN Gini. Still most the midfield, but just wanted to correct that stat.

Yankee Red



Click To View This Thread

24 Jun 2020 13:54:20
Thiago could walk into just about any midfield in the world.

Do you think LFC are being mentioned to drive up the price? Seems like a move to Barcelona would make a lot of sense if Arthur is truly leaving.

Yankee Red

{Ed002's Note - I am not aware of any approach from Liverpool nor Barcelona. He would command a high fee and at 29 would not give much of a return.}



Click To View This Thread

23 Jan 2020 02:26:20
Maneminamino, not sure if you’re new to the site but Ed002 has been saying this for years about our youth system looking out for its youth. As I understand it, it has improved over the past couple of years as youngsters on loan wouldn’t even be kept in touch with by the club. However, it’s not surprising that there is room for improvement.

Yankee Red



Click To View This Thread

29 May 2019 19:11:50
It’s too bad your country doesn’t have a president either.

Yankee Red

{Ed002's Note - Right.}



Click To View This Thread

09 May 2019 18:04:45
Why has Liverpool paid more than double the next club in agent fees? I know brought in several expensive players, but it seems we are paying a higher ratio of agent fees than other clubs.

Yankee Red

{Ed002's Note - They are not terribly smart.}




Yankee Red's banter replies


Click To View This Thread

11 Apr 2019 17:11:46
According to an ESPN article (usually when they have one starting with “Source:” it carries some weight; however, I tend to wait for an official announcement before believing), New Balance has the right to match any other bid and it will be accepted by the club. So LFC are in negotiations with Nike, but NB remains a key player. I’ve always wanted Liverpool to have one of the larger brands, but I’ve grown to like NB and would happy to see that relationship continue. Honestly though, I don’t care if the lads wear ZAFUL if they’re coughing up £70m+ a year.

Yankee Red



Click To View This Thread

14 Mar 2019 19:23:27
He sort of reminds me of Sakho. I don’t know too much about his issues, but it seemed like he was too immature a person to live up to his hype as a player. Only positive I see is that JK doesn’t have patience for those antics. Hopefully Naby gets it together before JK runs out of patience.

Yankee Red



Click To View This Thread

25 Jan 2019 19:33:30
Thank you for your response. I know it is not your typical question on this site.

Yankee Red

{Ed002's Note - It is Ok - and good to be asked a reasonable question. The club has recognised a number of failings and is working toward improving the situation. The team is playing well, and getting the rub of the green and making the most of it - and that puts them in a great position for the league this year. Not much needs changing right now.}



Click To View This Thread

14 Jul 2018 16:45:35
You’re missing the point. Just look on the LFC post that announced the starting lineup. Most of the replies are trashing him. And if supporting players rather than trashing them puts me on a high horse, than I don’t even want to know how pathetic your life must be.

Yankee Red



Click To View This Thread

11 May 2018 18:43:37
I’ll be backing Ceballos as I trust Klopp and the scouting department. Just curious though, why would he be expendable if RM are rebuilding? Seems like they should be getting rid of older players on higher wages? Though I suppose developing youth isn’t the RM way.

Yankee Red

{Ed001's Note - they need to raise cash to buy stars, that is the Madrid way.}