23 Mar 2022 18:21:47
So just wanted to start a little debate on Marcus Rashford and who would take him if he was available. not that they would sell to us but just wanted to put it out there.

other thing would be Sako from the gooners replacing Salah what do folks think?

just a couple of questions to have a chew on YNWA.

1.) 23 Mar 2022
23 Mar 2022 18:55:57
United are such a basket case that I find it hard to judge whether it's Rashford own fault he's been poor this season, or if it's the coaching and general malaise within the club.

Saka's a good player and one I'd seriously consider as a new RW should Salah leave. We would need a bit of patience with him though as he is only 20.

2.) 23 Mar 2022
23 Mar 2022 19:00:27
Rashford is a good player who would be better surrounded by our squad instead of that s#@t-show at utd. And Saka, just don't think there's even a tiny chance of getting him with Arsenal looking like getting Champs Lge football and we have our own prodigy on that wing in Kaide Gordon.

3.) 23 Mar 2022
23 Mar 2022 20:26:30
If he was available for 30mil I'd take him. Was a good player. Needs a proper coach to sort him out.

4.) 23 Mar 2022
23 Mar 2022 20:30:30
Saka would be excellent signing I reckon, if arsenal qualify for champ league can't see him leaving but if they didn't I think he would go. Rashford a few years ago wouldve loved to him at liverpool but not now, he looks disinterested r maybe personal problems, something not right with him anyway.

5.) 24 Mar 2022
24 Mar 2022 00:00:44
Rashford has been the victim of years of terrible coaching and rubbish players around him for sure. I have always rated him and said since the beginning that he’s ‘got it’, but I feel like he may be too far gone.

The biggest factor for me is one that scarcely ever gets mentioned: Solskjaer’s insistence on playing him through injuries. He knew that Rashford needed surgery on a BROKEN BACK, yet played him for months for regardless. That isn’t just bad management, that’s straight up employee abuse of the highest calibre. What’s worse is that all his mates in the media backed him and never said a word. Solsjkaer is not a ‘nice guy’ who’s just out of his depth, he’s an incompetent and parasitic toad, no matter how much the ‘Fergie took time to win things so by that logic literally anybody can become Fergie given enough time’ crowd want to believe it.

I feel like this more than any other factor could be what finishes off Rashford. It’s the same as when Torres was rushed back for the 2010 World Cup and was never the same again, only much much worse.

I love him as a player and as a human being but i’m not sure he can be saved at this point. It’s massive shame.

6.) 24 Mar 2022
24 Mar 2022 00:06:28
If Salah doesn’t sign in this summer I could see us selling for as much as poss and going for Bowen.

7.) 24 Mar 2022
24 Mar 2022 00:25:04
No thanks! Rashford should stay put he is at his level, how is this up for debate? To even suggest him as an option for Liverpool is ludicrous and would be a step back from where we are at. He has no fixed position and is quite terrible in most. Also is part of the problem Man utd have been so poor for years? Sorry this got me Puzzled!

8.) 24 Mar 2022
24 Mar 2022 06:09:31
It’s a no from me on Rashford. You can blame the coaches and managers all you want for his training off the pitch but once he crosses that white line it’s all about him. And his attitude and efforts on the pitch the buck stops with him.

9.) 24 Mar 2022
24 Mar 2022 07:03:50
Rashford is so busy being a (very admirable) humanitarian, he long forgotten how to play football.
He is way to distracted to be part of this group of players and actually contribute.

10.) 24 Mar 2022
24 Mar 2022 07:09:23
Like a lot of players Rushford is living in the shadow of the "Ronaldo show" I'm not surprised his game has gone to pot. Personally I don't think he is THAT good but certainly better than is has shown this year. The signing of Ronaldo has been a regressive step for the club and the players.

11.) 24 Mar 2022
24 Mar 2022 07:25:08
Not opposed to the idea of Rashford joining, just not as a replacement for Salah. He plays predominantly on the left and is right footed. If we replace Salah and unless we change our system we should get a left footer right sided attacker.

12.) 24 Mar 2022
24 Mar 2022 13:52:04
There is no doubt in my mind that, with his footballing skills, Rashford would be a far more effective player anywhere else rather than where he is now. That club is just a circus with so many distractions. How is any player there able to focus on just the football?

13.) 24 Mar 2022
24 Mar 2022 13:57:08
If Salah leaves i want Bowen.

Rashford would maybe be in the top 300 as a replacement option.

14.) 25 Mar 2022
25 Mar 2022 09:50:29
Coming from a United Fan I think Rashford would suit a klopp style team. Also got to consider pre back injury that rashford was progressing quite well until ole ruined him whether he can get back to where he was is another question thought. The seasons prior to his injury 19/ 20 season he scored 25 and assisted 8 in all competitions and 20/ 21 scored 23 and assisted 12 in all competitions he was 22,23 years old in those seasons.

Mane who I will use as an example as they play in similar positions. in the 19/ 20 season mane scored 22 assisted 8 and 20/ 21 season 23 goals with 12 assists. he was 28 and 29 during these seasons a whole 5 and 6 years older than rashford and Mane is/ was in his prime.

stats don't tell the whole picture granted, but I know if you take the names away and who they play fo from the players, I would pick the 22/ 23 year old with better goal involvement than a 28/ 29 year old with slightly less goal involvement and coming towards the end of his career than one about to enter his prime. If rashford was playing for liverpool during those season I suspect he would have even better stats and produce more then Mane has considering Rashford produced slightly better in an awful mismanaged side compared to Mane who produced those numbers in one of the top sides in Europe.