Liverpool Banter Archive February 10 2016

 

Use our rumours form to send us liverpool transfer rumours.

10 Feb 2016 22:12:47
Its funny that every fsg bully boy thinks they've won the war.

"The club has also ended game categorisation - meaning fans will pay the same price for matchday tickets regardless of the opposition. "

This just means instead of £30 for bournemouth at home, itll now be the man u price of £59.

Its kinda like when car insurance had to be made equal between men and women, they didn't lower mens insurance, they just raised womens.

002 do you think that's what's happened here? i think its pretty creative if that's what they've done and i applaud them for it.

Believable3 Unbelievable1

{Ed002's Note - They have more major issues to deal with right now and they will not be happy with the whole situation.}

10 Feb 2016 22:33:39
It's a brilliant PR move to be honest and the reactions seem positive even though many more tickets I would imagine are now actually more expensive then under the previous (now scrapped) scheme. Frankly I didn't have a problem with the last one nor a problem with this one, but I wouldn't exactly say they've conceded much of anything really.


10 Feb 2016 22:40:27
Yep, like trying to get their 110m back they loaned the club to build the new stand, which the bully boys seem to forget when it suits them.
I want JH to sell up, the guy from day 1 has come across as a nice gent with the club at heart.
he gave us kenny, he gave us klopp, he gave managers over 300m, all whilst the club has been losing money hand over fist.
A stand up guy that's tried to do his absolute best sorting out the mess H&G left, sure he's got things wrong, but he's tried.
An what respect does he get for it? i'm pretty sure him and his wife have received death threats in the past ed? they couldn't come watch games for a long while if i remember rightly.
Lfc fans don't deserve FSG, they can do better than us. i hope they sell up for a profit, getting as much back as possible, and get themselves away from us as quickly as possible.
Disgusted they had to apologise publicly like that, like a picked on kid who looked at the big kid the wrong way.
We have made our bed, just hope sos are ready to lie in the repercussions.


10 Feb 2016 23:26:32
Completely agree Benny.


10 Feb 2016 23:38:01
Well said Benny lad.


10 Feb 2016 23:22:50
They made kenny fly to America to sack him.

They gave us Rodgers and we're still paying him.

. Enough said.


{Ed001's Note - I don't see why someone should be applauded for loaning us money in the attempt to turn it into more money for themselves. That is just business, not good ownership.}

11 Feb 2016 03:45:55
They are businessmen, Benny, they weren't sticking their hands in their pockets because they are nice, generous guys who thought the clubs fans deserved it - it's a business transaction. They have their PR machine smoothly oiled if they have fans thinking they deserve better.
Having said that, they are trying to build LFC into a functional and successful sports business which should ultimately mean more on field joy for the fans.


11 Feb 2016 04:06:18
I mean, we could be into a bank for £170M or thereabouts instead, along with all the interest that would invoke. I'd say them loaning the money interest free instead is a pretty nice thing to do.


{Ed001's Note - and they will turn it into equity which will rise in value by a similar amount when they sell up. So no, not nice, just a nice money earner. I wish people would stop making out they are doing us a favour, they are not, they are doing their wallets a favour. Now that does not mean I am against them as owners per se, just that I am not stupid enough to think they are doing anything out of the goodness of their hearts, out of niceness, or to do us a favour.}

11 Feb 2016 04:17:32
Of course they'll get it back eventually, I didn't say otherwise. But I'd much rather owe them £170M than a bank £170M plus a fat gob of interest. Most of the FSG lot are investment banker types, I'm pretty sure they could make far more money off of that money far faster in many other ways.


{Ed001's Note - quite clearly they can't or they would be doing that. They have invested in sports as they see it as the best way to make money. Short term borrowing off them helps us out, long term it is a bigger hindrance. So I guess it depends on whether you care about the club now or whether you give a toss about its future?}

11 Feb 2016 04:36:56
Fair point on the latter, Ed. But on the former these guys are mostly quite capable of making money elsewhere. Henry with his soybeans, DiBenedetto with his investment management and real estate, Gordon back a few years with Vinik, etc. Sports are generally a poor investment compared to other things they could be doing and I do think at least part of them has a passion for it (granted, probably much more baseball related than football) . As you say, they've made their share of mistakes but I do think they also get a bit more grief sometimes then they deserve as well.


{Ed001's Note - no mate, they entered sports as a money making scheme. It is one of the best ways to earn in the USA. Businessmen are desperate to get involved in ownership of sporting franchises, in the main, as they are pretty much a license to print money. That is the sole and only reason they are involved as an investment group. I have no doubts they enjoy some sports, but that is not why they invest money into it, and certainly not why FSG bought Liverpool.}

11 Feb 2016 04:41:17
Turning Liverpool into a profitable machine is itself a success and that also implies on field success as definitely on field success isva necessary means to profitability. Look at Arsenal, i bet liverpool fans will be more than happy yr in yr out to be in ucl and able to buy stars like Sanchez and Ozil.


{Ed001's Note - I am not so sure most of us would be happy to be like Arsenal, though I do agree with your first sentence. Arsenal have the cash in the bank to buy the one or two top class additions that would see them challenge season in, season out, for the league title and Champions league, but it stays there, so instead they challenge for top four and champions league group stages each season. That is the problem with a sports business like Arsenal over a sports team like Bayern or Barcelona.}

11 Feb 2016 04:57:41
Cheers, Ed001. Not sure I agree with you entirely still as surely no one interested in making money would buy a newspaper these days! A good discussion though and appreciate all the replies (along with everything else you do around here) .


{Ed001's Note - newspapers are not dead and buried yet, there are still ways to make money off them. Especially when you have the associated websites to go with them. Certainly no one buys a newspaper to win football matches with it.}

10 Feb 2016 21:44:35
Well, I sympathize with Liverpool fans. But the next time they get on the owners backs to "splash the cash" on a player they want, I hope they remember the reversal in the ticket price increase.

Believable6 Unbelievable2

10 Feb 2016 22:36:38
They won't. It'll be spend spend spend and then turn on the owners when they don't.


10 Feb 2016 22:56:08
The club wasted a lot of money on players most of us here would've told them not to bother. Its the club that spent spent spent on rubbish, stop blaming the fans that pay hard earned cash to support the team.


11 Feb 2016 00:29:22
U go know 2 million should be a problem the size of Liverpool football club that's what would of got .


10 Feb 2016 21:35:16
Wonder if the club senior staff set the price structure and convinced the board it was reasonable and then FSG, after the supporter reaction last week, realised they must step in and rectify the situation, taking responsibility into the bargain to placate the fans and publicly support/ protrct the people who came up with the idea.
Ed2 called it spot on as "the club" not the owners as they don't interfere with day today operations. Respect to Ed2 and respect to FSG for their conciliatory, swift, decisive and responsible action.
If Ed2 is also correct about the SoS long term motives then this clever response will place them firmly on the back foot.
End of the day the correct, fair and honest result all round. Well done FSG well done LFC supporters who stood up in unison and were listened too.
The statement issued tonight surely goes a long way to enable everyone in the Liverpool FC family to unite again under King Klopp. Onwards and upwards together YNWA.

Believable4 Unbelievable1

10 Feb 2016 21:17:28
Evening all Reds, I'm a Wolves fan who would like to congratulate you all for the way you conducted yourselves whilst making a powerful protest last week. You have shown football fans around Europe that supporters have a voice and when done in the right way and with solidarity it can be effective. Very pleased to see Borussia Dortmund follow suit yesterday and this has inspired some of us at Wolves to organise a 10 minute turnaround this Saturday as a protest against our incompetent hierarchy. We can only hope that we receive the same backing that yourselves and BVB have had.
Good luck for the Capital One final and the rest of the season. English football needs a strong and powerful Liverpool FC. All the best. Tommo (Wolves FC)

Believable7 Unbelievable4

10 Feb 2016 21:45:37
Nice one Thommo, thanks for the post man!
Good luck with your protest, hopefully a few more will follow suit!


10 Feb 2016 21:06:06
Anyone watching this young irish lad playing for Peterborough? Marten samuelsen, he is ridiculous. Its like watching a Barcelona player taking the micky out of west brom. Is this guy know ed002? Like premier league teams tried to sign him already?

Believable2 Unbelievable2

{Ed002's Note - Norwegian and he belongs to West Ham.}

10 Feb 2016 21:48:34
double doh, a few clicks later and I found the west ham bit out. They were talking about him playing Ireland so I put 2 and 2 together. Looking forward to seeing him next season in the premiership then.


10 Feb 2016 21:48:51
Forrester is the Irish one, they look and play very similar. Both look like tidy players. As the eds would say this is a Liverpool page, we have brannagan.


10 Feb 2016 20:49:02
Happy about announcement re ticket prices but not clear about paragraph below. Does this mean the new seats will be same as existing seats at 2015/ 16 prices? Anyone clear it up?

Cheers


Though individual ticket prices may move marginally from this season, we are freezing our 2016-17 GA ticket revenue at the 2015-16 level exclusive of newly-added seats in the new Main Stand.

Believable0 Unbelievable2

{Ed002's Note - What it means is the total revenue from the GA tickets (excluding the new ones) will be the same next year as this - so any concessions given in on area have to be made up in another.}

10 Feb 2016 21:38:42
Think of it this way: currently you can get a ticket in the Main Stand lower for between £47 (Tier 2 price, Cat C game) to £59 (Tier 1 price, Cat A game) . Under the new scheme, it's £59 always. I suspect the difference is being used to cover the new Young Adult tier and reduced pricing to £9 for the kids.

Far be it from me to speak for others though as I'm not exactly a member of SoS or any of the other groups. I'll let them do their own analysis.


10 Feb 2016 21:55:24
cheers Ed.


10 Feb 2016 20:42:58
FSG, thank you.

LFC Fans - be careful what you wish for as I doubt any new owners would be as good.

Now, let's get behind Klopp and the team and show what LFC is all about. We may not have had a season we would have hoped, but we are in a final and we are getting some long absent players back. let's make the most of what remains of this season.

YNWA.

Believable5 Unbelievable3

10 Feb 2016 20:07:13
Our owners don't get enough credit!

Believable10 Unbelievable6

10 Feb 2016 20:40:19
I think with the amount of moneyt they have they should be ok with getting credit.


10 Feb 2016 21:09:13
I don't know, their credit probably stands at about 300 million 😉

Fair play to the owners, I hope they get some credit for it at the next match and in the media.

I always thought it was a misjudgement and credit where it's due they've corrected ther mistake.

Well done lads 👌.


10 Feb 2016 21:35:39
I am a long time reader who has not been sufficiently moved to join in the banter - until now!
FSG deserve tremendous credit for their quick and decisive response to the ticket price issue. All supporters should read carefully the open letter on the official site and take on board the words of John W Henry, Tom Werner and Mike Gordon. They are clearly stating (again) that they consider themselves custodians of our club and that their only desire is to return LFC to its position of a club winning and challenging for trophies. Additionally, they have acknowledged that the supporters are the heart and soul of the club. They are clearly demonstrating this by listening, understanding and changing their decision to raise some ticket prices. And with an apology to boot! I think it is time to stand together and support our owners. They have delivered on ground improvements, they have given us a world class manager and they have provided money for new signings. Things are looking up and the club is in a much better state on all fronts than it has been for a long time. let's use this statement from the owners as a way to bring us all together to help the team to deliver on the field. let's shout louder than any other supporters and make Anfield a place that teams fear again. We can win two cups this year and thus qualify for the CL.
YNWA.


10 Feb 2016 22:35:38
I love the free 1000 tickets to school children these sorts of things create the next generation of Liverpool fans and players.


11 Feb 2016 00:06:05
Excellent opening post from you Perured.


10 Feb 2016 19:47:53
Well don to all those who walked out on 77 minutes, sometimes things can be changed with the right effort,
To all those people and anyone else slating the owners maybe its time to lay off? If they sell the club it won't be for a couple of years at least, they've stepped back from the ticket rises, they've given money to spend on players whether they are the right players or not on numerous occasions and its not often a club actually listens to the fans, ours seem to do it regular as clockwork, Klopp, Kenny anyone?
Time to lay off in my book and let's start getting behind the club, the team needs it right now as its so up and down its unreal,
Come on fellas Europa on the way and a cup final!

Believable9 Unbelievable4

10 Feb 2016 21:09:36
Do you not think it's about time this ticket stuff is dropped instead of you bringing it back up when everybody else is taking positives from yesterday's match, let's keep the banter and this site to what it's about instead of you bringing things back up and have everybody bickering agen.


10 Feb 2016 21:10:04
Nice one Richie.


10 Feb 2016 21:48:42
Cheers Ron lad and no Knuckles I dont, this site is also about current LFC news, this was announced tonight by the club so its relevant what's the problem?
We should be glad our owners have stood up and listened to the fans should'nt we?
some people will argue about anything on here some days.


10 Feb 2016 23:02:17
I've had enough of this debate about arguing and if anyone's view on it differs from mine I suggest they make it known so we can have an open discussion on the debate about arguing or not arguing.


10 Feb 2016 23:02:43
Has it really worked out that way? No categorisation for games? If all games are £59, the lower category games won't be £40. Let's just say if all to let's are £59 then there no lower price tickets so has it really achieved anything enlightening me please as am interested to know. I personally don't think anything is any better. One thing it will of done is made the owners wish they never got involved.


11 Feb 2016 00:41:01
Well Knuckles was the complaint not that £77 was too expensive?

Now the top price will stay £59 so those who said £77 was too expensive cannot argue with it.

Everyone who went for cheaper tickets against lower category teams will now pay more than they used to, but crucially no GA tickets will be over £59.

Did you just expect the owners to turn around and bend over?


10 Feb 2016 19:15:17
Wow, so owners have scrapped the new ticket prices for now. Genuinely surprised they went back on this. might find themselves under increased pressure when they next propose a change that's against the general fans wish. Ballsy. Will be interesting to see how this plays out.

Believable10 Unbelievable6

10 Feb 2016 19:22:15
They have frozen for 2 years. After which they will sell the club in all likelihood. You know I only want what's best for the club and hope this is the right decision.

Next should be a walk out unless we sign Messi? Who is in?


10 Feb 2016 19:37:18
Going to be good for the fans having a bigger stadium and having ticket prices frozen for two seasons while the loan made by FSG to LFC for the stadium expansion was interest free.

LFC nothing but a bottomless pit for FSG. I am sure they will be happy to be rid of LFC when they eventually do decide to sell the club.

Grass not always greener on the other side as they say.


10 Feb 2016 20:01:30
The ED`s already said they were revisiting the issue amid the outcry.


10 Feb 2016 20:52:24
The irony for me is that by removing the Cat A/ B/ C pricing, they've actually made many tickets more expensive compared to the previous plan that was disliked. Pretty sure the revenue shift isn't much, if any, different from one plan to the other, but I need an accurate seat count per new tier to verify.


10 Feb 2016 19:13:38
Money grabbing leeches taking money out the club.
Oh, wait.

Believable11 Unbelievable7

10 Feb 2016 22:15:30
They are the best thing that has happened to Liverpool since Istanbul now!


10 Feb 2016 19:12:44
club have apologized and backed down on GBP77 tickets. To remove category based ticketing. Full story on clubs website.

Believable1 Unbelievable3

10 Feb 2016 19:09:31
So the fans got the wish and Fsg are sorry. So the fans do matter.

Believable10 Unbelievable2

10 Feb 2016 19:35:58
Not sure what they had previously done to be questioned if they see fans as important?


10 Feb 2016 19:59:23
Fsg now need to bck Klopp in the summer with quality players not 7 or 8 who can turn out to be good . We ready have that . A new gk is a most this summer.


{Ed001's Note - what they need to do is offload and trim the squad.}

10 Feb 2016 20:30:38
Agreed Ed.

Example; if we didn't have Benteke, Lallana, Milner, Allen, Enrique, Bodgan - would it be that much difference to the team results if a few youngsters had to play?

Then consider, Balotelli, Alberto, Toure (not having a dig - he is out of contract), Sinclair, McLaughin, Wisdom (no hate just doesn't look like he will get a look in) and Markovic could also go and have little impact to the current 1st team squad.

Probably £30m in wages alone on the players above as well.

Here's hoping some of the above if Klopp decides to sell actually bring some money back into the club!


10 Feb 2016 20:42:14
Spot on Ed
We need to sell about a dozen and buy about 5.


10 Feb 2016 22:16:08
Yes ed the squad players should be are younger players Ojo Stewart llori players like that. But we do need to get some players out who's not in kloop plans and replaced them with players who can jump into the starting 11.


10 Feb 2016 19:09:28
FSG: 'It has been a tumultuous week. We would like to apologise for the distress we have caused. We got it wrong. well done to all those who took a stand.

Believable13 Unbelievable2

10 Feb 2016 19:06:15
It looks as though FSG have listened and they have responded quickly and appropriately on the ticket price issue.

Well done FSG.

YNWA.

Believable10 Unbelievable1

10 Feb 2016 18:32:26
Ed001. curious your thoughts on filling some of our weak spots through younger players versus transfers. I believe you have talked a lot of the need to repair the defence. Obviously it will have to be a mixture of transfers and youth. anybody stand out from the youth as real potential starters if not right away, pretty quickly for goalie, back 4 or defensive mid. Is Joe Gomez's long-term future at centre back? what have you thought of Ilori so far, shown you enough to think he has potential to work or not. Is Stewart a real option for defensive mid?

Thanks.

Believable1 Unbelievable0

{Ed001's Note - those 3 you have mentioned all have the potential. Gomez and Ilori have the potential to fill the centre back spots, and I do think Stewart has the ability to hold down the defensive mid speck. We do need to look for a keeper, if Ward is not going to get a shot now then we clearly have no intention of giving him a chance. Fulton looks decent for the long term.}

10 Feb 2016 19:10:02
Spurs have giving young player a chance in recent years and done no harm at all to be fair Stewart is a good player Europa league is a opportunity to show case his talent.


10 Feb 2016 19:21:15
I know ilori has been hailed as the Saint, then abused a bit as per normal, but the improvement in fitness definitely helped, he played a midtable or higher team, and conceded less than our usual defence in two games. He has areas to improve but has the time, and physical attributes to succeed. I'm sure playing with Lucas helped a lot, especially speaking the same native tongue. I'm sure having flanno next to him helped too. Would like to see a lineup of like flanno ilori sakho Moreno Stewart hendo can coutinho firmino sturridge some day.


10 Feb 2016 19:43:21
Ed001

have you heard anything about why Ward has not been given a shot despite being recalled. It's the one thing that baffles me about what Klopp is doing. would have thought he would get a shot in one of the cup games. Is there something they are seeing in practice that they don't like?


{Ed001's Note - I have not heard anything sorry.}

10 Feb 2016 20:17:01
Isn't Danny Ward cup-tied? I don't know if that means for all the cup competitions though.


10 Feb 2016 20:30:04
Fencey, they speak Portugese in Brazil., not Spanish.


10 Feb 2016 20:37:06
ilori was shouting at players to get into position regardless of the language - something we do not see enough of since Carragher leaving!


10 Feb 2016 21:02:16
Ilori is portugese.


10 Feb 2016 21:06:27
More No - Tiago Ilori is Portuguese.


10 Feb 2016 21:07:20
I don't understand the Ward situation either, as surely if he had been brought in last night, done well, he would either have taken over the number one spot or at least given Migs a kick up the backside in saying, if you mess up in the PL, I'm here! It's what competition is all about, players keeping others on their toes!


10 Feb 2016 21:17:13
More no, who do you think was speaking Spanish, Ilori?

The guy has 10 U21 caps and was signed from Sporting Lisbon, which I think you will find is in Portugal .


10 Feb 2016 21:27:33
More no, they also speak Portuguese in Portugal, hence why ilori and Lucas both speak Portuguese 😂😂.


10 Feb 2016 21:47:50
He was born in England and has played football for teams in Portugal, Spain and France, so I think he can speak all 3 languages.


11 Feb 2016 01:08:10
Here's my best guess on the Ward situation.

As awful as Mignolet is, it may be that Klopp doesn't like what he sees from Ward in training. Could be that he's just not up to the level despite a decent loan spell.

Similarly, Klopp took forever to give Bogdan a chance, and I expect that was also because Bogdan didn't look good in training. And, once he finally got a chance, Klopp got burned with two huge Bogdan mistakes that cost us points.

He might feel he'll get burned by Ward, too, if he's not looking impressive in training sessions.

Granted, Mignolet has cost us countless points. But he may, right now, be the lesser of all the evils. That is a scary thing.

I just hope Klopp's constant open backing he's giving Mignolet is just BS to give Mignolet as much confidence as possible for us to make it to the summer. And then he's shown the door.


10 Feb 2016 18:20:34
Hi reds right my take on things last night was Lucas did phenomenal at cb really his interceptions, tackling and also his blocks. Okay he made one mistake but surely the amount of mistakes benteke and Migs made they should hold the brunt of the stick right? Let's start with Migs passing it out under pressure okay he got away with it but a side with pace will exploit that just put ye foot through it. His distribution leaves a lot to be desired also, and his lack of vocal commanding is really troubling. Benteke okay his confidence is low. I think the club need to cut thier losses with Migs and Ben and that be the end of it. Cheers eds in advance.

Believable6 Unbelievable2

10 Feb 2016 20:03:42
Mingo is aweful. That fact has been well established.


10 Feb 2016 23:23:43
So Migs didn't make any mistakes but along with Benteke should shoulder the blame? Seems that Migs has been slammed for so long on here that he now has to take responsibility for our losses even when he's not at fault (or maybe it's all Rogers fault for buying him) . What did he do so wrong? From what I saw he had a decent game especially compared to recent howlers.
Personally, I don't see anyone responsible for the loss except Benteke and the three defenders who didn't challenge Ogbonna. I know he is scapegoat-of-the-month now we've moved on from Lucas, Allen, Lovren but how can you objectively say Mignolet contributed to our exit from the cup?


10 Feb 2016 18:18:50
Apologies if this has been asked, but do the winners of Capital one cup get into the Europa league?
And as City are probably going into CL do we get the spot regardless of winning it (as runners up), or does extra place go to the next highest league place?

Believable0 Unbelievable1

{Ed002's Note - Yes the winners go in to the third qualifying round and there is nothing for the runner up - but a leage space is made available.}

10 Feb 2016 17:49:59
Just heard Jamie Carragher mention that apparently Rodgers picked Lovren over Sakho at the start of the season because Skrtel preferred playing with Lovren.

Is this a regular occurence with managers?

Believable1 Unbelievable1

10 Feb 2016 19:12:56
I'd rather play with lovren myself Sakhos crazy hahaha.


10 Feb 2016 16:10:31
The one thing that a lot of people seem to be forgetting re. Lucas. He IS NOT a natural CB. Now putting aside the should he / shouldn't he have made the tackle. I for one think he was EXCELLENT at cb. He was asked to a job there and did it bloody well. Just my two cents as it were.

Believable19 Unbelievable0

10 Feb 2016 16:42:42
Best player on the pitch last night for me, considering he was playing with a centre half and two centre mids who haven't played much football for Liverpool I thought he was brilliant. Positioning was excellent as well. I wouldn't blame him at all and I'd have no concerns if he was to start at centre half on Sunday.


10 Feb 2016 16:43:43
The problem is, football is about the little details.

If you make a mistake and it leads to a goal, it's an issue, regardless of how well you've played.

I like Lucas, but he has a history of giving away needless free kicks in dangerous areas.

The head scratcher for me is at some point during a game he will clash heads with one of our own players challenging for the ball. I don't really blame him for this as he is the best headerer of the ball in our team and someone has to take responsibility, it just makes me laugh.


10 Feb 2016 17:23:36
every time a corner is taken there all sorts of body contact but very rarely is afoul given. last night Lucas barely touched that player and he went down like he had been shot . In my opinion the ref was conned into giving a free kick. i know this sought of thing happens a lot so I don't blame Lucas at all.


10 Feb 2016 18:24:46
I also thought Lucas was sensational. yesterday, our best player by far and usualy I do not admire him as some other people here. He still shouldn't have done this silly foul. I think in general we give a lot of fouls and free kicks because our defenders are not quick enough. All of them. but it is True Lucas is not a defender.


10 Feb 2016 18:29:15
Well said evered. I've watched 3 games now against West Ham this year and the diving has been shocking. That was laughable last night the ref was falling for it.

Something needs doing about that. And the tackle on Stewart went un-noticed.

Thought Lucas was great last night by the way. Him and Ilori.


10 Feb 2016 18:33:35
He played well last night no question but he makes that kind of tackle wherever he plays and it often costs us.
I like and respect him but do believe we could get better either as a DM or CB. If we don't sign anyone else then for me he plays but personally I would want an upgrade.


10 Feb 2016 18:17:10
That wasn't a free kick. That was Lucas holding his position and his opponent diving in spectacular fashion. If the ref gets conned, then it's a shame, but almost every defender does the same thing all the time. I suppose the best thing I can say is that the diver in question was a much better actor this time.

Until such time as I see different, I'm of the opinion that Lucas is the best CB at the club.


10 Feb 2016 22:33:04
Had we buried even half of the TEN clear chances we created in the game, Lucas' foul or not wouldn't have mattered. You can not control what the refs do but you can control the game if you finish most of the chances you create and we created quite a lot.


10 Feb 2016 15:29:44
Wow, some guys really going to town n Lucas on here,
Lucas had a great game and defended really really well yesterday, he had one mistake, he decided to make the challenge instead of standing off, who knows what would have happened if he hadn't made the challenge.
But let's be honest here lads, if the other players who got on the pitch yesterday had performed the responsibilities of their position last night as well as Lucas performed his duties as CB we would have ran away with that game.

Believable19 Unbelievable1

10 Feb 2016 18:56:33
I can never understand why Lucas gets so much stick. He was just excellent last night and it's not even his natural position. He's been getting grief for years and once has sulked off or bad mouthed the club. But you know the old saying"You never know what you have till it's gone"And trust me he will be missed.


10 Feb 2016 20:24:15
The vital free kick was a dive, as were a number of the free kicks we conceded. Some of them should have won Oscars. They repeatedly got away with it.


10 Feb 2016 22:34:12
Had we converted our chances, this foul or non foul would have been a none issue.


10 Feb 2016 14:30:27
Those like EMS saying Benteke missed all these chances last night.

He didn't miss those chances though did he? Didn't Randolph save them? I think we're not used to seeing a good keeper making important saves.

He should have put the edge of box volley on target but otherwise what else could he do? Free kick on target as well.

He hasn't played well for us for many games, totally agree, but last night he got into the positions we expect, anyother day those corners in the first half would have gone in. If he had 20 goals already this season and the same game last night would he be getting the slating?

Believable6 Unbelievable18

10 Feb 2016 14:44:13
Cheers for the back up Max and good post. I actually forgot about the shots he had from corners. I say keep shooting and playing like that.

As for ems he'll come good too bit of p. ems. t I think. Crap joke but couldn't resist.

You're one of us too ems good or bad.


10 Feb 2016 15:00:51
He's back from goal was good and his link up play . on a naver day he could of had 3 . His work rate will not be like Suarez but now we have Sturridge orig Benteke firminho Ibe coutinho lallana that's a lot of attacking options.


10 Feb 2016 15:15:34
He is a 32 million pound striker. I don't think it is unreasonable for us to expect him to score a simple 1v1 attempt.

We all knew as he approached he wasn't going to score. It has been the same all season when he gets a 1v1 he bottles it.

There's potential but I think he only got in the right areas because defenders were more worried about sturridge or origi or ibe scoring then worry about getting tight to benteke.


{Ed001's Note - to be fair, he did at least create a chance or two from corners, which is something that has been missing for a couple of seasons now.}

10 Feb 2016 17:54:09
And a decent free kick attempt Ed.


10 Feb 2016 20:04:11
He did miss them. He missed the clear cut opportunities to score. He is supposedly a top quality striker that costed us £32.5m, confidence low or not those where chances decent striker would take and he hasn't pretty much all season. If we are to blame anyone for not 'winning' that match its benteke. He played a lot better but I'd rather a striker that goes missing the whole game but actually does what a striker is supposed to do and put it in the back of the net. Apparently he wants to stay until the summer to get into the belgium squad, and honestly that will never happen at this rate. He is as good as gone unless there's a miracle upturn of form.

We need to go to big fishes in big ponds if we are to have top quality performers. Enough of overspending on average players that look good in poor teams.


10 Feb 2016 23:29:09
He didn't miss his chances because the keeper saved them? That is laughable. Shoot at the keeper and it's a missed chance. He missed the area of the goal between the keeper and the post where the ball eventually hits the net.


10 Feb 2016 14:07:11
Is Milner called Millie because for corner kicks he places the ball within a millimetre of the quadrant? Moreno does it as well. Both are wonderful at concentrating and focussing on getting the ball within a millimetre outside the corner kick quadrant. The opposition fans go wild, several times the officials have even gone to check the positioning of the ball whether it be by Millner or Moreno. And for all that uproar, focus, millimetres, all that trying to be smart, when it actually comes to KICKING THE BALL. time after time it is wasted. Along comes young Brannagan. Places ball in centre of quadrant. boom. target hit. every time. Bring on next match. The concentration levels of both Milner and Moreno when placing ball for corner kick will be out of this world, just a shame their kicks go out of this world too.

Believable10 Unbelievable1

10 Feb 2016 14:33:55
I agree that Milner and moreno's corners are poor, but Brannagans, while better, were still very hit or miss.


10 Feb 2016 15:16:37
Least brannagan is not payed 150k a week like milner to deliver those hit and miss crosses.


England Advised To Drop Rooney By Former Man Utd Player, Johnson Admits Guilt In Child Sex Case Trial And More

10 Feb 2016 13:16:28
{Ed's Note - We have posted a new article entitled, England Advised To Drop Rooney By Former Man Utd Player, Johnson Admits Guilt In Child Sex Case Trial And More

Believable0 Unbelievable0

10 Feb 2016 12:48:50
Gutted we not still in the Fa cup but hopefully the displays from the likes of Stewart, brannigan, chirivella and Smith show we have enough in the squad to do a job if needed. Hopefully with this realised we will now target players in upcoming transfer windows who will improve the 1st choice 11 rather than buy an endless amount of overpriced similar ability players who are short of competing for the title.

Believable8 Unbelievable3

10 Feb 2016 15:30:01
well said Red80. quality over quanity, only bring players in who are better than those we already have. would we miss milner or lallana, because we have chosen to use stewart or tex? we do not have a bottomless pit of cash, we need to get smarter in our transfer dealings.


10 Feb 2016 22:37:43
I Milner, Lallana, and Moreno as well as Clyne need to look over their shoulders, especially the first two because Stewart, Smith and Flanno are coming for your spots.


10 Feb 2016 12:19:28
Crouch didn't score his 1st Liverpool goal for 19 games, and if I remember correctly he didn't get half the abuse benteke got. All strikers get bad form . his shooting won't be an issue. The hope should be that his movement gets better with coutinho and Sturbridge back.

Believable8 Unbelievable5

10 Feb 2016 13:12:49
Completely agree. You don't just lose the talent he has. He will come good.


10 Feb 2016 13:36:07
i remember that, rafa persisted with him and when he did score he got dropped, but i agree with you he did not get the stick benteke gets, he is just an easy target, the goals he has scored for us has shown us he will score goals given the right service and when his confidence is there, there are other players who keep getting away with their mistakes who don't get stick in fact they get praised even though when we concede they are in that part of the play some where along the line this player last season cost us 3 goals in the last 2 games of last season and he never got the stick benteke gets, just because he is a fans favourite,


10 Feb 2016 13:55:50
You could never question Crouch's effort and historically Benteke is known for this even before he joined Villa.

3 games on 10 games off.


{Ed001's Note - well said Ron, Benteke has been getting abuse off his own national manager for being a lazy get, Crouch at least made an effort.}

10 Feb 2016 13:59:17
Sounds like something Rafa would do lol.


10 Feb 2016 14:01:46
Was having the same chat last night funnily enough. which is why I've been posting similar about Benteke today. Good post lad.


10 Feb 2016 14:09:37
I am hoping with all the quick attackers around him he will move more, if he doesn't then he simply can't be defended.


10 Feb 2016 17:02:29
I hoping with all the quick attackers around he gets dropped an loses his place on the bench. Had his chances an blew them. Give someone else a go least now we seeing kids more deserving.


10 Feb 2016 18:41:02
even benteke on a good day would make us struggle to compete at the top. he just doesn't have the know how to take that one moment in a match to win the game, where as top teams have those players. we should not be relying on him at all. people sayed he played good last night but he was so frustrating to watch. its kinda funny that spending money to win things actually has a detrimental effect to the team. without benteke, someone else would have done the job.


10 Feb 2016 12:19:28
Crouch didn't score his 1st Liverpool goal for 19 games, and if I remember correctly he didn't get half the abuse benteke got. All strikers get bad form . his shooting won't be an issue. The hope should be that his movement gets better with coutinho and Sturbridge back.

Believable4 Unbelievable4

10 Feb 2016 15:39:25
peter crouch only cost £7m, plus no one could accuse crouchy of not trying. Christian bentenke cost £32m and has stopped playing since Brendan got sacked. are we all forgetting his pathetic performances in 2 games against Exeter? strange how he suddenly gives a damn once sturridge, origi and countinho come back from injury. we have a big summer coming up we need to make ruthless decisions. we also have ings to return next year. imo big bens clock is already ticking.


10 Feb 2016 15:54:09
Everyone knows his clock is ticking. your missing the point though.


10 Feb 2016 17:28:26
feel free to let me know what point i'm missing omalleylfc. he is a striker who is failing to do the basic requirements, ie putting the ball in the bloody net. he wanted a move to a big club, he got it, he should be strutting around the place head up and proving he is worthy to wear the number 9 if he had we wouldn't have been so upset about sturridge being injured for so long. he is making emile heskey look like a bargain!


10 Feb 2016 12:19:28
Crouch didn't score his 1st Liverpool goal for 19 games, and if I remember correctly he didn't get half the abuse benteke got. All strikers get bad form . his shooting won't be an issue. The hope should be that his movement gets better with coutinho and Sturbridge back.

Believable3 Unbelievable1

10 Feb 2016 11:55:53
It would be great if any of the Eds could answer this.

Would the team have to go through the Qualifiers for the EL, after you win the league cup?

What position dies the winner take in the EL campaign next season?

Would it means the team will have to play in the middle of the Pre-Season?

Thanks and regards.

Believable0 Unbelievable1

{Ed002's Note - The winners go in to the third qualifying round and then the play off to get in to the group stages. The first game will probably be on July 28.}

10 Feb 2016 14:16:55
Ed002, n in case the winner has automatically qualified thru league position, then does it goes to the runner up?
Tia.


{Ed001's Note - no.}

10 Feb 2016 11:32:48
I used to get worried about how we going to replace lucas, our only defensive midfielder but Stewart seem to be the answer! Finally a decent defensive mid! Just worried that he won't be given the choice to shine.

Believable11 Unbelievable1

10 Feb 2016 12:38:34
Totally agree

Although with the performances he has had in the 1st team I can see him getting game time next year.


10 Feb 2016 14:04:30
He's been a revelation mate as have a few of the other youngsters. Happy Days.


10 Feb 2016 11:25:27
I have a question for the Ed's if you will. With all the ticket price and TV deal stuff, is there a possibility that one of the large tech, streaming companies could soon be bidding for the TV rights? With the big financial deal involving the former presenters of a certain car show, and the massive increase in popularity of 'on the go' media, it got me thinking after it was mentioned on the radio. Could we soon be watching our football via live streams at all? They certainly have the finances do they not?

Believable0 Unbelievable1

{Ed002's Note - Eventually yes but not whilst there are significant television deals. Once a breakaway happens it will all be up for grabs again at a national level as the big money will go with the breakaway.}

10 Feb 2016 11:50:22
Ok thanks Ed. Bet they increase my subscription fee. probably by £77!


{Ed002's Note - Nothing has been increased by £77 - it would be misleading to suggest it has.}

10 Feb 2016 12:50:57
Tough crowd eh. was merely in jest!


{Ed002's Note - But it is already crystal clear that the vast majority don't understand about the ticket prices.}

10 Feb 2016 10:57:48
Hey ed02, when you have the time, could you again post a list of the players for next summer that YOU think will be good transfers for Liverpool? Your list from last year was rather good!

Believable4 Unbelievable1

{Ed002's Note - I have to go back to California for a couple nof days so it will need to be next week Drigen. Remind me then please.}

10 Feb 2016 10:26:30
I'm extremely proud of the inexperienced players, who haven't been beaten in 360 minutes of football,4 matches.
It's cruel to go out like that but it's part of learning and growing.
The only possible negative is that's the end of starts for Stewart and tex, unless he uses that type of team for the Europa. I really think Stewart could be something great, fingers crossed they get more games.

Believable15 Unbelievable1

10 Feb 2016 10:41:59
Absolutely 100% agree Benny. There is nothing like seeing a young player make it in the 1st team. Hopefully he will use them again in Europe.


10 Feb 2016 10:02:34
Am I the only one who is hoping Teixeira came off early because Klopp is intending to start him at the weekend?

Believable18 Unbelievable4

10 Feb 2016 10:14:58
My initial feeling upon seeing Teixeira having to play with Benteke was disappointment. Big Ben offers little movement for the creativity of Tex. When Origi and Daniel were about to come on I thought Ibe and Benteke would be withdrawn, with Couts and Tex feeding the runs of the two subs. Hopefully Tex gets a chance this weekend alongside the likes of a Coutinho, Firmino, Daniel or Origi. Overall very heartened by our gutsy display last night.


10 Feb 2016 10:18:12
We can live in hope Ed haha! But I find it unlikely! Coutinho, Firmino and Teixeira playing off Sturridge would be a winning combination if you ask me!

I don't think that it will happen though! I'd expect Klopp to go with one of Ibe, Lallana or Milner ahead of Teixeira I'm afraid!


10 Feb 2016 10:28:51
Edd001 you're having a laugh. Klopp doesn't rate him imo and i can see the boy leaving in the summer if things don't change. Lallana will play instead of him. He didn't make the bench last weekend and most likely won't make it again. i'm gutted to be honest by the lads gametime .


{Ed001's Note - how am I having a laugh? How do you know he is not rated?}

10 Feb 2016 10:35:45
Ed01 can you give us your views on the game as a whole last night mate if you have time.


{Ed001's Note - I thought it was a very enjoyable game, with overall mostly good performances. The link up between Teixeira, Coutinho and Smith, in particular, was first class at times. Against West Ham's strongest possible line up, our youngsters pretty much dominated them, which augurs well for the future. Great to see Sturridge back as well. Disappointing to lose, but overall a very positive performance.}

10 Feb 2016 10:55:34
I am having doubts about that, ed. It does not seem that Klopp rates his style of play that much. In all fairness, I think he had a very bright start yesterday, he seems to be bringing speed to his game, which is what he needs badly! I do not believe he will get a long-term chance though.
On a side note, how would you rate Brad Smith and Tiago Ilorri in their defensive play? I am starting to adore Smith, he seems much better going forward than Moreno, but I have a sneaky feeling he is also not good defensively, but I am kind of a bad judge of that aspect of play. Illori seemed to do fine against the strong attackers of West Ham (except the penalty foul) . Do you think this was due to him and the team playing well, or to West Ham being rather weak for large portions of the match?


{Ed001's Note - Smith needs lots of work on his defence, it is a weakness, but he does look better at it than Moreno. He does switch off a bit, loses position, doesn't always get back as quickly as I would like, but overall he looks a step ahead of Moreno.
As for Ilori, I thought he and Lucas worked well together, apart from that one sly pull on the arm which should have given them a pen, he was good. Looks to have real potential, which makes it all the more bizarre that Rodgers never even looked at him.}

10 Feb 2016 11:20:00
Edd001 because he can't get a game ahead of lallana and Milner . he wasn't even on the bench on Saturday and with sturridge and coutinho back he won't make the bench again. Hardly shows he fancies him. Texeira needs a run of games and he's not going to get it here.


{Ed001's Note - if you say so, but I think you are wrong, there is a lot more to it than him simply not being fancied.}

10 Feb 2016 11:53:00
I agree with ed001.

Look at the performance. With better finishing we would have destroyed West Ham.

I really hope that team becomes the regular one. Lallana, Benteke and Milner just fail to impress.

Balotelli will have to return from loan unless we can find a buyer in the meantime.

It would be interesting to see Balotelli under Klopp.
He is not short of skill or pace.


10 Feb 2016 12:10:24
The amazing thing about Sturridge is that he hasn't played for 2 months but comes on and it looks as if he had never been away.


10 Feb 2016 12:36:30
Even more amazing is that flanno has been out for 2 years and looks like he's never been away.


10 Feb 2016 13:53:23
I'm hoping that Lallana and Milner have gotten game time over Tex in order to put them in the shop window or let them prove they are worth keeping. Teixeira's link up play and quick accurate passing was a joy to watch, surely he is worth keeping.


10 Feb 2016 16:12:47
I think Kloppo is holding Tex back for next season. We have loads of players in his position and some need off loading. It will be hard to off load them if they're not playing.

That's my straw and I'm clutching at it 😀.


10 Feb 2016 18:37:59
I do hope so ron. I don't think it would be wise to let this one get away. imagine him after a good run of games under his belt. another bonus for me is that he wants to play for lfc he has the hunger and the desire, and the talent all he need now is the chance.


10 Feb 2016 09:35:45
Hey lfc fans


I didn't watch the game last night but judging from the min by minute report I did read

Benteke is the reason we lost the game for a lack of finishing

Would that be right?

Believable12 Unbelievable4

10 Feb 2016 09:45:48
A bit harsh today we lost because of him, but he did have a good 3 or 4 chances to score last night.

Texeira also missed a very good chance.


10 Feb 2016 09:52:42
David N'Gog would've had a hattrick last night mate. Smith, Teixeira, Sturridge, Origi, Ibe and Coutinho created about 8 clear cut chances for him and he fluffed his lines every time and then laughed about it.

Have a look at Coutinho's set piece delivery and free kick goal though. He was superb. Shame he had to come off due to lack of match fitness really! Stewart and Chirivella bossed the midfield for about 105 minutes. So much so that West Ham played route one football all game. In fact, we were so much the better side that they resorted to diving for the last hour or so of the game.

We literally lost because all of our chances fell to Benteke, because a lucky deflection looped the ball over Smith for their first, and because Valencia was throwing himself to the floor when Lucas or Ilori breathed on him. Lots to be positive about. Ilori looked good all game. Had Payet in his pocket which takes some doing. Even Mignolet made some good saves although he was still dodgy with balls into the box. Texeira and Coutinho looked like a pair of twins with telepatic link up.

Stewart and Smith should be starting in the league though. Can and Moreno are not playing as well as they are, pure and simple.


10 Feb 2016 10:31:26
Totally agree EMS, Moreno countless times gets himself in a great position to deliver a cross and constantly fluffs his lines, in fact it's been that way for months now, time for a change.


10 Feb 2016 10:40:25
Ems migs never had a good game, doesn't command his area, cannot organise a piss up in a brewery, and his position is and was terrible.


10 Feb 2016 12:16:04
In the league matches we should now try and blood in Stewart, Smith and Flannagan. All at the moment playing better than the current players in their position. Put Coutinho back in and replace Lallana or Milner and see how we go.


10 Feb 2016 12:16:04
In the league matches we should now try and blood in Stewart, Smith and Flannagan. All at the moment playing better than the current players in their position. Put Coutinho back in and replace Lallana or Milner and see how we go.


10 Feb 2016 12:16:04
In the league matches we should now try and blood in Stewart, Smith and Flannagan. All at the moment playing better than the current players in their position. Put Coutinho back in and replace Lallana or Milner and see how we go.


10 Feb 2016 09:25:01
Eds, any injury news on Sturridge yet?! Only joking, here's hoping he came through last night unscathed and remains fit for the rest of the season and beyond, God knows we need him.

Believable12 Unbelievable2

10 Feb 2016 10:12:16
rest him until game day.


10 Feb 2016 10:30:29
He is wrapped up in cotton wool.


10 Feb 2016 11:39:58
Could we finally have found the most productive use of Big Ben? Could he be Daniel's minder, and keep him out of harms way, on and off the pitch?!


10 Feb 2016 09:22:44
Hi Eds and Reds,

I don't usually make too many posts but I have a question for Ed001.

You mentioned recently that you feel the main weaknesses of the side are Mignolet, Clyne and Moreno defensively.

My question is that do you think that the ideal 'replacements' for the trio are already at Liverpool in Ward, Flanagan and Smith respectively or do you think we need to look in the transfer market for any, or all, of the three positions?

Thanks and keep up the amazing work the site does!

Believable0 Unbelievable2

{Ed001's Note - I am not sure about Ward, as we have not had the chance to see him play to assess him. He needs a run of games or we will have to buy to replace Migs. I do think Flanno has shown he is good enough at either full back position to step in and raise the level there. He is better than either Clyne or Moreno, possibly even better than them both put together being honest. Smith needs to improve defensively, but right now I would prefer to give him and Moreno the chance to compete for the position next season, rather than sign someone.}

10 Feb 2016 09:48:29
Agree with ed on flanno and smith, let's just remember when flanno first started playing in the team not many thought he would ever make it.

Personally i'd say smith has done better coming into the team Tha when flanno first did.


10 Feb 2016 09:51:51
Flanagan is class ed1 but would you say its important to ease his work load until the start of next season ed, but he makes a massive difference and is a class above Clyne.


{Ed001's Note - well we have Clyne, so he can be eased back in to replace him over the course of the season.}

10 Feb 2016 09:57:32
What about Gomez ed, he'll be ready also.


{Ed001's Note - he is more of a centre back and needs time to get back to full fitness and then he would be better as a back up being eased in to first team action.}

10 Feb 2016 12:33:19
I know he's Australian, but does Smith count as a home grown player for us?


10 Feb 2016 08:48:23
So I was in the match yesterday. Unfortunately I didn't sit with the away fans but this only made me appreciate our fans who did brilliant job and for most of the game were much louder than the locals. Made me proud.

About the game I have just one big big question which I ask almost after every game in the last two years. Can anyone explain why we cannot score goals?

Now save me all these answers of you build from the back and its Mings fault or Skertl or Brendon Rogers or our strikers are lazy. It is something else and it is a real mystery for me.

I was watching the game yesterday thinking, if Suarez was playing for us, even if we were 10 against 11, even if he was instructed not to go out of the last third and play only on the right, and not to create anything himself just finish what other people started, we would have won the game 5:1.
Because we did create chances yesterday but we just cannot finish.

This is how we were two years ago, every time we came forward we scored. But the minute he left he took all our scoring ability with him. Like a spell or a curse and I am not a superstitious person.


And we brought some good scorers after Suarez left, Balotelli, Lambert, Benteke, but once they moved to us they became the most clueless in front of goal you could imagine. Benteke seriously look as if he is under some kind of hypnosis, last year he would have scored three from yesterday's chances. Our midfielders cannot score either other than Couts occasionaly. Other strikers are always injured.

We had this one game, the 6:1 against the Saints in the league cup when I thought here we go again but then the clock stroked midnight and we turned back to our ugly 'cannot score for our life' mode.

This really is the story of this season. Poor finishing (in front of goal), poor finishing of games (conceding late), and in two weeks and can be poor and early finish of this season.

Long trip home yesterday : (

Believable8 Unbelievable4

10 Feb 2016 08:58:54
It's quite simple mate. Strikers.

We have good strikers but they have mostly been injured and out of confidence.

The signs were good last night though so hopefully this will see an end to your worries.


10 Feb 2016 09:12:04
Benteke was unlucky last night. He did everything right, except score. The two efforts from the corners in the first half and his header back in. All good. He should have scored 1v1 but it's a bit 50:50, more confidence and he would have, but he got into that position because he played well.

It's a shame the chances we create before we had Origi and Sturridge on, we not replicated because I think one of those Smith crosses would have been put away.

Anyway, there were enough positives to take from last night and now we have three fully fit strikers let's give them some game time before we close the book. If we were not creating the chances that aren't being scored I'd be more worried, but we do and with strikers the goals should come.


10 Feb 2016 09:13:23
The signs are good in terms of creating chances Alfie. I now looked at the extended highlights in BBC sport I counted about 10 clear cut chances. 10! and not half chances, very good chances. But until you don't score them how does this help?

I can't believe we lost to West Ham 3 times this year and drew the fourth. They are a nice team but we have so much more talent.


10 Feb 2016 09:55:59
Gotta disagree Max. He missed three chances insidevthe six yard box, a one on one, 2 more headers, a 20 yard shot that went 20 yards wide and put a free kick in an excellent position straight down the middle.

He should've had at least 2-3 goals. Absolutely shocking how he missed all those chances.


10 Feb 2016 10:43:08
Completely agree with EMS - there was nothing unlucky about it. Benteke had 5-6 gilt-edged chances and ballsed them up. He's currently performing up front as Migs is at the back and they are both costing us games.


10 Feb 2016 10:50:58
It's because they train with mignolet so it takes less to score but when they come against a 'shot stopper' they struggle! :p.


10 Feb 2016 11:42:32
The good thing is finally we are creating good clear cut chances and as confidence grows they will be taken.


10 Feb 2016 08:40:56
Last night's match was a great FA cup tie, really enjoyed it, and despite the loss there are loads of positives in my opinion.
Coutinho back from injury scored.
Sturridge back looked pretty sharp considering the lengthy layoffs.
Origi back made some positive runs and more options.
Lucas looked settled in back 4 and helped better build up play.
Flanno played full game after a long time off.
Ilori lot more stamina then showed against Exeter
Stewart bossed midfield and cut out a lot of promising WH moves.
Smith lots of crosses and looked as if he can comfortabley trouble Moreno's starting spot.
Chirvella looked more at ease and confident then seen before.
Only negatives were Benteke's conversion rate and Migs still looks a bit nervey (but did ok)
Ok were out of the FA cup but guess we now have better chance of Europa sucsess, well done team, I hate us losing but nice to play football well. YNWA.

Believable6 Unbelievable3

10 Feb 2016 08:36:13
Gutted with the result like everyone else but enjoyed watching our team play for the first time in months.
Thought Chirivella, Stewart and Ilori were fantastic.
Would love to know the opinion of other pool fans but I would be very happy with relying just on the kids next year.
Let's face it - we have a team worth 6-10 place niw but costing 100s if thousands in wages as well as making us all miserable .
I will argue that a team based around these kids (plus 2-3 experienced signings) is worth AT LEAST 6th - probably higher. And this on a fraction of the weekly wages, with the added enthusiasm of nurturing the kids and even making mone for the owners (perhaps ☺) . for a blue print just see where Spurs are now.
I would take this scenario gladly for next year. What do other folk think? Ed001 - agree?

Believable7 Unbelievable1

{Ed001's Note - I have always been in favour of building a small squad that relies on youth to cover injuries and loss of form.}

10 Feb 2016 08:47:20
I was really impressed with Stewart. I also thought the tackle on him was nasty. That could have been a leg breaker.


10 Feb 2016 09:08:43
The challenge on Stewart was appalling, not even a card. Ref bottled that.


10 Feb 2016 09:15:45
Really hope Stewart, Chirivella, Texiera and Smith have a big future at LFC. They are way more deserving of a first team place than some of our overpaid and clueless senior pros. These kids could save us a lot of money. We could easily move on the likes of Lallana, Milner, Allen, Enrique and Toure without requiring to replace them.


10 Feb 2016 11:06:01
Exactly well said.


10 Feb 2016 08:34:10
Considering the game time he has had and that he was up against first team regulars of Prem level, Ilori is looking good. And Lucas got into some excellent positions.

Stewart and Pedro were great as well. I hope these two and Ilori get some more premiership games this season and be a bigger part of next season.

Can you believe Pedro is 18! What a talent we have.

If we could only sign one player in the summer, it has to be a top level GK. We may need others, but if we had to it looks like we have quality kids.

Believable7 Unbelievable3

10 Feb 2016 09:18:26
A GK like u said has to be a priority for the summer transfer window. A quality striker would also be nice to replace the hapless Benteke who seems to have left his shooting boots back at Villa Park. Two quality players for these positions and our promising youth academy could take the club places without needing to rebuild every year and using "transition" as an excuse.


10 Feb 2016 08:12:28
Just seen the goals from last night. Just the three defenders around the West Ham player when he scored the winner. Defence a priority to strengthen surely.

Believable1 Unbelievable3

10 Feb 2016 10:21:23
They all basically dropped deeper than the flight of the ball and nothing they could have done after that to reach it.


10 Feb 2016 08:05:40
Thought Lucas did well in defence last night, in the right positions, was talking all the time and made good interceptions. I think he has lost a bit of pace since his injuries. Eds do you see him adapting to that position and Klopp playing him there?

Believable5 Unbelievable1

{Ed001's Note - it is certainly possible, his passing out from the back is a major plus point. He certainly has the positional sense.}

10 Feb 2016 08:34:54
I think he needs to realise he can't win every header, he did give a lot of free kicks away, yes soft fouls but still a foul.


10 Feb 2016 09:17:36
Wasn't Hummels a CM before Klopp played him at CB?

I noticed Lucas had a pop at Migs a couple of times and one point kicked the ball out instead of a pass back because he didn't come sooner.

If you consider the inexperienced midfield in front and his partner Ilori having very limited game time, he was exceptional.

It must have been the only game where he didn't get a yellow card even though he was in prime position to get one. That again shows how well and controlled he was.


10 Feb 2016 10:22:58
And he is used to contesting for headers against tall strikers and winning more than he goes for so he is also quite strong in the air.


10 Feb 2016 15:26:42
And his communications is so far ahead of anyone else's it's shocking. Last guy who gesticulated, pointed, and guided his players that much was Carra.


10 Feb 2016 07:32:00
My takeout from last night was that Benteke cannot lead the line because no matter what, he cannot score. Yes he played better deeper in the field than usual yesterday, yes he put in more effort (although was caught out very often in attack being no-where near where he should be and doing the complete wrong thing) but I counted 6 golden chances to bury the game last night and he didn't manage to score any of them.

The other takeaway is that Tex, Smith and above all, Stewart, need some PL gametime because every time they play, no matter who against, they are among the most impressive performers on the field. With so many players underperforming at the moment, its time for their turn.

Believable10 Unbelievable1

10 Feb 2016 07:55:25
Pretty obvious now after how many games? that benteke needs to go in summer can't score too slow and positionally inept.


10 Feb 2016 09:03:30
I think he might just surprise you all and I hope he does. Look how good his movement was last night playing with quality.

If he can get a partnership going with Studge we will be laughing.

How good would you all feel if we supported him for a bit and he came good?


10 Feb 2016 09:11:02
Alfie, all this talk about movement and partnerships is c**p if a striker cannot put the ball in the back of the net. Benteke was never going to work out at LFC, he does not fit into our style of play and he can be very lazy and frustrating at times. We need to sign a consistent goalscorer with pace in the summer because Sturridge and Ings are injury prone and Origi has much to learn.


10 Feb 2016 09:19:55
Let's see how he does with a partnership as he looked good when Studge came on, his hold up, touch and link up was really good second half.

If that goes well, gets more confidence and can be used also as an impact sub he might turn his LFC career round. He didn't do much wrong last night.


10 Feb 2016 06:26:15
Thought Stewart, Lucas, Flanno, Coutinho were excellent last night and Teixera, Illori, Chirivella all acquitted themselves well. Smith had a bit of a mixed bag defensively but was good in attack, Benteke (someone needs to practise 1-1's with the keeper with him) and Ibe were better, but they still need another step up to justify their places IMO.

Thought we deserved h win, but in the end you have to put them away and we've struggled all season with that. Very glad to have Sturridge, Origi back.

Only negative was why of why did we have Origi, Ibe, Sturridge and Benteke all on the pitch at one point? We missed having Coutinho or Teixera as our main creators in attacking midfield. m

Hoping next game we have Sturridge upfront with Coutinho, Firmino and Llalana supporting, and we should play Hendo and Can deep midfield. Back 4 of Smith, Lovren, Lucas (if recovers) and Flanno, and Ward in goal.

Believable4 Unbelievable4

10 Feb 2016 07:36:17
Why not Sturridge and Firmino up top with Coutinho on the tip. Henderson on the right, Can on the left and Lucas on the base? I don't disagree with your suggestion by the way Zimbo. Did anyone play well enough against the Hammers to push someone else out, based on your team above?


10 Feb 2016 08:05:57
I'd happily see twin strikers and a diamond. I'd personally go Sturridge and Benteke up top, Firmino in behind and midfield of Coutinho/ Hendo and Can so we have a bit more creativity in midfield. Also think Lucas can then play CB again, he seems to add some stability in defence for a change.

As for those playing well enough against the Hammers to push someone out, my takeaways in a 4-2-3-1 were putting in Smith for Moreno, Flanno for Clyne, Sturridge for Benteke, Lucas for Sakho. I wouldn't have minded seeing Stewart get another game either, but felt with Lucas at CB, probably better to have some size in CM (hence preferred Can) to help out aerially on set pieces. Plus I felt Can was good in the deeper role against Sunderland. He's mobile and physical and breaks up counterattacks well and I personally see that as his best position with a bit more experience there.


10 Feb 2016 10:58:27
Fair enough, cheers Zimbo.


10 Feb 2016 01:45:41
I just despair at the chances Ibe gets to impress compared to texeira. He is so predictable and for me has done nothing. Tex is twice the footballer he is but I fear he will end up leaving to get regular football.

Believable8 Unbelievable3

10 Feb 2016 05:21:31
I wonder if anyone knows how much effort tex puts in to training because no matter how much ability u have if you don't have the attitude to match its not going to happen.


10 Feb 2016 08:23:10
I'm starting to wonder the same about Ward. What is he not doing in training to get a game?


10 Feb 2016 01:32:43
I felt benteke started to show more in the hour he was paired with sturridge tonight than he has since the start of the season. The burden of being the only fit goal scorer may have weighted to heavy on his shoulders. I for one will watch till the end of the season to see if studge n Christian can forge a partnership before castagating him.

Believable6 Unbelievable6

10 Feb 2016 05:07:38
I disagree - we need a player that can play both roles - with a good partner, AND as a lone striker.


10 Feb 2016 07:39:53
As a preference i agree Liverpres however it is about how to get the most out of what you have and if 2 up top works better then that is what you should do. Sturridge is better with another striker, i would think. That being said, i have not seen the game yet.


10 Feb 2016 08:34:32
I would keep Benteke as far away from the first 11 as possible. Apart from flick ons from goalkicks/ clearances that go nowhere what else does he offer. Has to be a front 2 of sturridge/ Firming.


10 Feb 2016 08:43:26
*Firmino. Bloody predictive text!


10 Feb 2016 00:55:07
No one likes loosing.

But on a positive note. I think Stewart was MOM for me, in previous games thought he was okay but nothing too great. But today he was top class and thought for a kid coming in against a pretty strong hammers side he did well. Lucas also did pretty well to.

Glad to see studge and couts back.

We should have finished the game in 90 mins but there you go. that's football sometimes.

It was a encouraging performance i think overall. Still getting caught out on set pieces and hopefully we will find the goal a bit more over the coming weeks!

Believable4 Unbelievable2

10 Feb 2016 05:41:01
lets remember this when summer comes and we start demanding player x y and z. we have these young lads already here, let's start using them before we lose them. sadly I agree with derekpiero about texeira as klopp has aready hinted he will be leaving at the end of the season. a big mistake imo. as for kevin stewart he should start against aston villa. I have been very impressed with him.


09 Feb 2016 23:41:06
Ed002 do you know why Mignolet keeps starting every game? Ward can't seem to get a look in even in the cup tonight when a few other youngsters were playing. Can't be any worse than Migs.

Believable4 Unbelievable1

{Ed002's Note - I am afraid that is a Klipperty question.}

10 Feb 2016 00:22:54
We'd be almost as good not bothering picking a keeper with Mignolet. That's how poor he's been. I don't see any signs that he can improve or change his game as he simply isn't good enough,


10 Feb 2016 07:33:38
An away cup tie with Ilori and Lucas at CB was not the game to start Ward. Why we played that CB pairing is another question but still.


10 Feb 2016 08:08:40
Good question but I still felt more comfortable when Hammers were on the counter than with Lovren/ Sakho at he back. They're not as good in the air but made some great tackles.


09 Feb 2016 20:19:01
Question for Ed002 came up on the Live Chat:
Who's your favourite current LFC player?

I thought Ilori 😇.

Believable1 Unbelievable1

{Ed002's Note - I would like to see Coutinho nail it.}

10 Feb 2016 01:12:32
Nice. A few people predicted that too.


 
Change Consent