27 Aug 2017 11:46:16
ed001 or 002 has there been any enquires about Mignolet are worst goalkeeper ever to play for Liverpool Really hope so. How anyone say he is a decent keeper is beyond me, i have supported from mid 70's and even are reserve keepers would look world class next to him. And thank you.

{Ed002's Note - I cannot recall any approaches for Mignolet. Goalkeepers don't move as often as other players but for now we have seen that Klipperty still has the Klopps for Mignolet.}

1.) 27 Aug 2017
27 Aug 2017 12:20:07
Worst keeper ever is harsh to say the least. Itandje? Padelli? Westerveld?

2.) 27 Aug 2017
27 Aug 2017 12:45:34
Bogdan?

{Ed002's Note - He is one of Liverpool goalkeepers. Chap with red hair.}

3.) 27 Aug 2017
27 Aug 2017 12:48:04
I loved Westerveld only big mistake was when he come for corner and punched backwards into his own net. But gave me one of my best memories was in restaurant on holiday it was packed and when he did that my dad jumped up swore badly and had to apologise to whole restaurant 120+ people.

4.) 27 Aug 2017
27 Aug 2017 12:50:22
Fair enough comment lad, though that penalty save against Hoffenheim- coming as it did at such a crucial time in the tie, could well have saved us in the champions league. Mig made my eeek savibg that.
So that, allied with the fact that klopp plays so open and, given we know Mig can improve; for me, mig has earned that we persevere with him.
It may well be a stay of execution as you say, but i'd stick with him for now; a wee bit of loyalty.
We demand it of our players. It's nice to see it reciprocated from us fans when they're struggling.
That's my view in it anyways.

5.) 27 Aug 2017
27 Aug 2017 12:51:38
No hyperbole, Mr Dennis, I reckon if you exclude backups, Kop69 might actually be right. At least going as far back as Tommy Lawrence who debuted in 1957 anyway.

Looking at guys who were first choice for a season or more, there's really only Westerveld (wasn't he briefly the most expensive keeper in English football? ) who you can argue wasn't any better than Migs. And at least he made a good save once a while to offset his mortal fear of crosses. Migs doesn't.

6.) 27 Aug 2017
27 Aug 2017 13:19:47
being good at saving penalties should not be enough to keep him in goal, he has started this season like the back end of last season never happened, its over to karius now with ward breathing down his neck, if mignolet had not had reverted back to his old self he would not have been dropped.

7.) 27 Aug 2017
27 Aug 2017 13:34:09
In fairness something red, if you look back over Migs' Liverpool career he has made countless top class saves. His shot stopping reflexes were never in doubt in my mind, up there with the bests in the league in that regard I think. But he doesn't command the area, looks suspect at catching, inspires fear and panic. That's why he will never be good enough. Shame.

8.) 27 Aug 2017
27 Aug 2017 13:34:23
Being good at saving penalties is a red herring. Saving penalties is not a requirement to be come a great GK. Migs lacks the TRUE qualities to become a very good GK. He can't catch a cross, lacks self confidence, lacks distribution, lacks the bottle to command his area, gets beat at will at his near post, the list is endless so him saving a pathetic excuse of a penalty, does not a good GK make, I'm sorry. BTW, Karius is no slouch either at saving penalties either as he has a decent record of this in Germany. We need to stick with Karius now cos he will make mistakes BUT at least we will know if he is the guy or not so we can move on. Good luck to the boys, today.

9.) 27 Aug 2017
27 Aug 2017 14:22:04
I thought you said keepers don't catch crosses anymore bingo. They're all taught to punch. Or so you said the other day in your argument defending Mignolet.