01 Nov 2016 19:53:47
Hi eds and reds
As you know, we talk about transfers and how successful we think they were a lot on this page. So I was wondering, who do you all regard as the most successful transfer, from the 14/ 15 season onwards? (So the Lovren/ Lallana window onwards) .

Also, who do you think we'll look back on in a few years as being a great signing, who we may not appreciate now? Sorry if that's a bit vague.

Personally I think Firmino was a great signing, and I'm tipping Emre Can to be a big player in a season or two.


1.) 01 Nov 2016
01 Nov 2016 20:12:34
Firmino for now. Though we did overpay for him.
3 years down the line Divock Origi. We have a 20 goal a season striker if he fulfils even half his potential.


2.) 01 Nov 2016
01 Nov 2016 21:44:22
Firmino for me . Could be mane at the end of the season with Matip .


3.) 01 Nov 2016
01 Nov 2016 21:54:13
Firmino, Can, Matip

I agree I think Can will really mark his place this season, I also believe given the change Ings will prove to be vital for us should he get his chance and of course Origi.

Some may give me a dig for it but Karius, I think he will prove to be exactly what we needed, give the lad time and he's going to shine.

Out of recent new signings my favourites must be Matip and Mane -Matip is quality and it hasn't taken him much time to get settled, we have a strong young lad there we've needed somebody like this for along time.

Mane is up there with Coutinho and Firmino, top class talent and under Klopp he will only improve which is exciting.


4.) 01 Nov 2016
01 Nov 2016 22:02:16
Firmino. He is a level above everyone and in his own league. He is on par with KDB and Hazard in the league.


5.) 01 Nov 2016
01 Nov 2016 22:45:34
Spot on, LFC16. I am ready to give our boys time to prove themselves, Karius include because had we all yielded to knee jerk reactions, would we have the Hendo, Can, Lallana, Lovren and so on, tearing it up right now? Migs had ample time to take the spot of GK as his own and after three years, he has failed. That is not Karius' fault. Migs own awful play is the reason Karius is here and he should be supported as he adapts to the team and the PL. All this knitpicking of his play is just disingenuous, IMO. Let's support him and give him confidence and if after three years like Migs, he fails then he too would will bite the dust.


6.) 02 Nov 2016
02 Nov 2016 00:35:59
Pound for pound it has to be Matip.
But Origi looks great business as well.


7.) 02 Nov 2016
02 Nov 2016 10:10:49
Matip because he was free and looks very assured at the back.

Firmino as, despite the huge transfer fee, is just getting better and better - easily one of the best players in the league right now.