28 Oct 2016 08:10:54
Few rumours flying around regarding clyne, possibly city or Barcelona bidding for him in Jan? Why would he be able to leave ed? I think he is a great full back. Or is it just BS in the papers 🤔.

{Ed001's Note - great? He had issues in the summer, we were looking to replace him anyway as he is far from great. Right now he is willing to stay but we are still trying to decide whether TAA is good enough to push him/replace him. The stories about City and Barca are simply them being linked with every possible right back as both need one and are searching for one. Barca have even, idiotically, been linked with Glenn Johnson in the papers.}


1.) 28 Oct 2016
28 Oct 2016 09:13:54
I'm already fedup of rumours and its still 2 months from the transfer window, god help you eds.


2.) 28 Oct 2016
28 Oct 2016 09:45:40
Clyne cannot cross the ball and one of the reason we never use the width. Its the same case on the other side well. Clyne is just about ok. Runs around a lot actually not doing anything great If you watch Bellarin you would understand how far Clyne needs an upgrade.
Our average full backs are the reason we play so narrow and through the middle.
I would happily sell hm to City for a large chunk which they will blew it anyway on a RB.

The reality is PL has no good full backs except Bellarin.


3.) 28 Oct 2016
28 Oct 2016 10:12:19
He's been playing well and I don't really have any complaints, but great he is not. I agree if city does come in for him with a big amount its hard to say no, then we can shove TAA into the first team who I believe has so much potential, that lad has really impressed me from what I've seen, if Clyne is to be flogged we need to gradually put TAA in the next couple of months. I'll support Clyne whilst he's here because I honestly think he's been decent, but for the future of Liverpool we do need better. We'll be in the CL next year, he just doesn't cut it for that.


4.) 28 Oct 2016
28 Oct 2016 10:29:02
Lets just hope City and Barcelona get into a bidding war for Clyne. He has been deecnt so far but anything more than 20-25 million and we will be in luck. No need for a replacement either as we have Flanno coming back and Arnold waiting in the wings. Just spend the money on a LB and make Milner an option for RB as well.


5.) 28 Oct 2016
28 Oct 2016 10:34:38
Exactly, TAA has potential. Nowhere near the finished article. We should keep Clyne 100% until the end of the season at least. At the moment he is the best we have.


6.) 28 Oct 2016
28 Oct 2016 11:01:10
Liverpool FC

". I'll support Clyne whilst he's here. " Not sure what people actually mean by this. I have seen this eerywhere. You only support one club whole your life which means you support the players as well. You could always have an opinion on things you see and observe.

Does it mean you would start hating once this player moves elsewhere? What kind of logic is that?


7.) 28 Oct 2016
28 Oct 2016 10:13:39
any idea who we're looking at, Ed001?

{Ed001's Note - right now we are assessing TAA as I said.}


8.) 28 Oct 2016
28 Oct 2016 10:42:22
Jesus ed didn't see this coming mate. biy shocked tbh. do you think Jan is likely or more like in the summer?

{Ed001's Note - what?}


9.) 28 Oct 2016
28 Oct 2016 13:11:45
Ah right, thanks ed, thought we might've been looking at other names as well in case TAA is deemed not ready.

{Ed001's Note - I expect TAA to be deemed ready to be honest.}


10.) 28 Oct 2016
28 Oct 2016 14:27:32
Not at all sweet chin you automatically assumed nonsense as per usual, are you ever happy? Your just full of it. And to answer your question. I wish him the best where ever he ends up. Suddenly I won't start 'hating' lol you should give up lad every post you make you destroy yourself.


11.) 28 Oct 2016
28 Oct 2016 14:35:02
Harry, Clyne has put some great crosses so far this year, and I personally don't think it's a position we need to strengthen. As for your comparison to Bellerin, if you did watch him play, you'd realise he's a better version of Moreno, with the same defensive faults, and naivety, though good going forward admittedly.


12.) 28 Oct 2016
28 Oct 2016 16:07:11
Ed, do you know what the process is to deem a player ready? If there is one at all?

{Ed001's Note - it will vary. Sometimes there is no process as injuries mean a youngster gets thrown in at the deep end. In a case like this one, it will be taking a look at how he handles himself over the next few weeks, with the media attention surrounding him and being dropped back down to the U23s. They want to see he has the maturity to cope with the ups and downs.}


13.) 28 Oct 2016
28 Oct 2016 21:06:40
Bellerin is no better than Clyne at all, he is just very fast, i like that you atleast used another player in comparisson, instead of just saying Clyne is bad like most other people. I would love to hear who people would replace him with, that is so much better?


14.) 28 Oct 2016
28 Oct 2016 21:41:40
Keep him till the summer, then if he wants to go let Gomez and TAA fight it out for the spot.


15.) 28 Oct 2016
28 Oct 2016 22:08:19
Still baffles me how people rate Clyne. Last season he was at fault for as many if not more goals than the likes of Moreno, Skrtel and Mignolet.

He gives away far too many silly free kicks, his technical abilities are Championship level at best, his ability to track/ mark anyone are non existent etc. He is literally just an athlete. The Shane Long of the right back world. Quick, strong, energetic and never injured. His actual ability as a footballer is below par at best.

This season he has been slightly better and his crossing has developed. He is still a glaringly obvious weak link though hence why we are even discussing an 18 year old right midfielder replacing him! Although TAA is an exceptional talent who can comfortably play in about 5 positions.

I'll drive Clyne to Barcelona if they offer £30m. Just give me a 1% cut of the transfer! Should never have been signed in the first place to be honest. Love his attitude, but I'm not going to pretend he is a good player just because he plays for us.


16.) 28 Oct 2016
28 Oct 2016 23:31:56
Stoupid, if you think Clyne is better than Bellerin, then I fear for you.


17.) 29 Oct 2016
29 Oct 2016 08:02:31
Has everyone forgot about flano? His injuries have set him back a lot and he isn't getting the game time on loan. He was great before he got hurt.

Has he fallen from consideration ed01? Or was the loan to get him back to that lvl? He maybe doesn't have the pace klopp would like for the role. He sure has the defending side.

I'm not sure. It's a shame whatever way it turns out, sadly it doesn't look like he's caught klopp's attention so far.

{Ed001's Note - he is surplus to requirements mate. Klopp would have sold him in the summer, if he could have found a buyer.}