29 Aug 2016 14:27:35
Very simple question for the Eds and others (would love to get Ed001 and Ed002's views on this and you both have such different takes on players) .

Is Hart a better keeper for Klopps system than Mignolet?

Not suggesting anything here, but just interested in the views.

Thanks

Z.

{Ed001's Note - no. He has the exact same issues.}


1.) 29 Aug 2016
29 Aug 2016 14:50:27
Well i think he is better, marginally but certainly not worth the outlay it would cost to get Hart. For the money i'm guessing Hart will go for you would be hoping for better, a lot better.


2.) 29 Aug 2016
29 Aug 2016 15:13:10
Was thinking the same Rover, but seeing reports of Hart being offered on loan and Citeh covering up to 75% of his wages. So, outside of a loan fee, he would cost only around £30k per week ("only"?!? He he) .


3.) 29 Aug 2016
29 Aug 2016 15:49:24
Btw, thanks Ed001.


4.) 29 Aug 2016
29 Aug 2016 18:12:14
Karius is a far better fit than either.


5.) 29 Aug 2016
29 Aug 2016 18:50:26
Migs is a good shot stopper - probably one of the best in the Prem. He just needs to work on his distribution and having strength of character to command the box.


6.) 29 Aug 2016
29 Aug 2016 19:05:06
He's really not that good of a shot stopper red. Stops a lot of penalties I will say. If the ball is off the ground he does well. You can slide it to any corner you like though.


7.) 29 Aug 2016
29 Aug 2016 19:21:34
Migs a good shot stopper, sorry I disagree with you kidder. Average at best.


8.) 29 Aug 2016
29 Aug 2016 19:23:59
There are quite a few shots he's failed to stop IIRC.


9.) 29 Aug 2016
29 Aug 2016 20:20:36
Mignolet isn't a good shot stopper, he's an average shot stopper who let's too many easy shots in.


10.) 29 Aug 2016
29 Aug 2016 20:54:37
How many times have you Seen kauris play?


11.) 29 Aug 2016
29 Aug 2016 20:58:03
Welcome back Red Lenin!


12.) 29 Aug 2016
29 Aug 2016 22:51:52
Watching the games this year, you can hear Migs communicating much more with his defence than he did last year, so it seems he is consciously working on that aspect of his game. However it seems to me that this stops when the ball comes into certain danger areas (presumably as he switches to thinking about stopping the ball) - so he still needs to work on calling early to his defence to let them know what he is doing
Also when he doesn't have to think, he is a good shot stopper. The instinctual saves is where he is good at. But it seems when he is forced into situations where he has to think, that he runs into trouble. I wonder what he is like when he is driving a car and has to merge into traffic - can he judge closing distances well?


13.) 29 Aug 2016
29 Aug 2016 22:57:18
If it was a direct choice between mignolet and hart I'd chose hart, but considering he is number two, it doesn't matter.


14.) 29 Aug 2016
29 Aug 2016 22:57:18
If it was a direct choice between mignolet and hart I'd chose hart, but considering he is number two, it doesn't matter.


15.) 30 Aug 2016
30 Aug 2016 01:11:07
They are both poor and have been replaced by both clubs. Does that not tell you something?